placeholder image

Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports


Who’s at fault for Jimmy Garoppolo’s injury?

Sep 24, 2018 at 10:27 AM--


Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Social media is buzzing with angry San Francisco 49ers fans this morning. They have had sufficient time to reflect on yesterday's events, hope for the best for Jimmy Garoppolo, and have started the process of placing blame. After all, yesterday's injury is a huge setback for both the development of the quarterback and the entire team.

Garoppolo went down with less than six minutes left in Sunday's game against the Kansas City Chiefs after a scramble to his left to gain more yards. He collided with Chiefs cornerback Steven Nelson, but the damage was already done. The quarterback immediately grabbed his left knee as he fell to the ground.

"I think Jimmy was just trying to be a ballplayer and trying to make a play," tackle Joe Staley said after the game. "He wasn't running out of bounds. He was trying to get some extra yards for his team, and it was just one of those things."

Of course, Staley is a teammate of Garoppolo's. What else is he going to say? Justin Houston is not Garoppolo's teammate. He is an outside linebacker for Kansas City and had a very different opinion.

"That was his fault," Houston said via Pro Football Talk. "I pray he's not hurt, nothing serious, but as a quarterback, you should step out of bounds. It was only an inch. That inch wouldn't have made a difference. You got the yardage you need, you step out of bounds. You got to be smart."

He's probably not wrong, and thoughts like that were likely going through Garoppolo's head as he was being carted to the locker room at Arrowhead Stadium. His teammates watched as their leader was taken away, and with him, likely the hopes for the 2018 season.

Fans would obviously rather have their franchise quarterback for the remainder of the season than the yard or two that Garoppolo gained by staying inbounds against the Chiefs.

"It's absolutely on Jimmy to know when to go out." said our own Zain Naqvi via Twitter. "This injury could have been prevented by him."

Of course, Naqvi isn't placing all of the blame on Garoppolo's shoulders.

"If he had more blue-chip talent around him, he wouldn't feel like he has to put on the cape and carry the team all the time," Naqvi continued. "(This) should serve as a wake-up call to John Lynch and the [front office] to start using some of that cap money and be more aggressive."

The 49ers, of course, have practiced patience in their rebuilding process. The team didn't even anticipate having its franchise quarterback in place until this past offseason with a potential signing of Kirk Cousins or the drafting of a rookie. At least, that was the plan. Head coach Kyle Shanahan and company got a bit of a head start when the New England Patriots came calling in late October and practically gifted them a franchise quarterback.

The team's patient process did not change, but that doesn't mean it didn't make moves when they seemingly made sense. The 49ers were aggressive in signing veteran cornerback Richard Sherman, who is a perfect fit within their defensive scheme. In fact, he is the prototype for what you want at the position within this defense.

The 49ers also aggressively pursued center Weston Richburg and drafted Mike McGlinchey in an effort to improve the protection in front of Garoppolo. They also added a versatile weapon in running back Jerick McKinnon, who was also lost for the season with an ACL injury.

The areas the team failed to upgrade were at guard, the addition of a dedicated pass rusher, and a big red-zone threat at wide receiver.

General manager John Lynch and the 49ers were reportedly aggressive in their pursuit of former Oakland Raiders linebacker Khalil Mack, which would have addressed the pass rush. They lost in the bidding to the Chicago Bears.

The 49ers at least looked into the possibility of adding former Cleveland Browns wide receiver Josh Gordon. Shanahan had experience with the troubled playmaker, and the 49ers didn't value him as highly as the New England Patriots, who ended up acquiring him via a trade.

So now the 49ers move forward with second-year quarterback C.J. Beathard leading the offense and Garoppolo on the road to recovery and, hopefully, a successful 2019 return.



Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News


placeholder image

Jimmy Garoppolo explains why he signed with 49ers' division rival

By David Bonilla
Mar 20

Jimmy Garoppolo is back in the NFC West after signing a one-year deal with the Los Angeles Rams. The former San Francisco 49ers quarterback recently explained his decision to join the division rival after a one-season stint with the Las Vegas Raiders. "Obviously good players all around," Garoppolo said, per ESPN. "That's a big part of it. Talking to [head coach] Sean [McVay] on the phone, him just running me through offense and things that he had in mind, it really became appetizing. And I know a lot of the coaches here, so a lot of familiarity in that aspect. And then having played against the Rams a lot in my career, I've seen a lot of good things


placeholder image

No Huddle Podcast: What Are The 49ers' Plans For The Future?

By Site Staff
Mar 19

(Episode 322) — Al Sacco and Brian Renick react to the Zach Wilson rumors, what the 49ers should look for in QB2, negative Al speaks up, how the offensive side of the ball is complete for now, replacing all of the superstars will be a challenge, why the 49ers need to draft well this year and next, and more. Note: This episode was recorded before news of Josh Dobbs' signing. The audio for the show is embedded above. Remember to subscribe! You can listen to the latest "No Huddle Podcast" episode above, from our dedicated podcast page, on


placeholder image

5 things to know about new 49ers QB Joshua Dobbs

By Kirk Larrabee
Mar 18

Joshua Dobbs became the latest addition to the San Francisco 49ers' quarterback room after agreeing to a one-year contract with the team on Monday. Dobbs, 28, has 2,920 passing yards in 21 games (14 starts) with 15 touchdowns and 13 interceptions in seven NFL seasons. He also has 91 carries for 496 yards and six rushing touchdowns and a 3-11 record overall as a starter. Dobbs comes to 49ers as a well-traveled NFL veteran who most recently was with the Minnesota Vikings. But Dobbs isn't any ordinary NFL quarterback. Let's take a look at what to know about him as he begins his time with the 49ers. The Joshua Dobbs "world tour" reaches San Francisco The 49ers are Dobbs' eighth team since joining the NFL as a fourth-round draft pick of


placeholder image

Details emerge on 49ers' 1-year deals with Jon Feliciano and Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles

By Site Staff
Mar 19

Offensive lineman Jon Feliciano and linebacker Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles recently re-signed with the San Francisco 49ers on one-year deals. OverTheCap.com has revealed the contract information for both deals. Feliciano signed a contract that includes the minimum base salary for a player with eight accrued seasons of experience—$1.21 million. Flannigan-Fowles' base salary is slightly higher, at about $1.77 million. Feliciano is scheduled to count about $2.28 million against the 2024 salary cap, while Flannigan-Fowles is slated to consume almost $1.3 million. The linebacker's reduced impact is due to the 49ers using a portion of up to $1.45 million of salary that won't count against the salary cap for veteran players. The 49ers are paying Feliciano a


Latest

Trending News

Share 49ersWebzone