Jimmy Garoppolo is ranked No. 21.
Simms has been somewhat critical of the San Francisco 49ers' selection of Lance. It's not that the analyst dislikes the 21-year-old quarterback. He just has questions about Lance, mostly due to the level of competition he played against at North Dakota State.
In his latest Chris Simms Unbuttoned podcast, Simms was asked by a fan whether he liked or disliked Lance's ability to use his feet to make things happen on offense. The analyst has seemingly been complimentary and critical of that specific skill from Lance.
"I've always liked his running ability," Simms explained. "I think it's overrated, I guess is what I'm saying. I'd like to see it, yeah. ... The competition was less than (great). I mean, he's playing linebackers that are me. Sorry. And me is not that impressive at linebacker.
"I felt like [his running ability] was overblown during the draft process. He's certainly athletic and can be, yes, a really dangerous runner running the football on, especially with (Kyle) Shanahan's schematics behind it and all of that.
"I mean, people at first were trying to make him like he was Lamar Jackson. That's probably where I got this guy (asking the question) thinking the wrong thing, where I was going, 'Wait, everybody pump the brakes. He's not Lamar Jackson here.' I mean, Lamar Jackson was doing it against Florida State with Jalen Ramsey and Derwin James. And they were chasing him, and they couldn't tackle him. Sorry, I haven't seen that from Trey Lance."
I'm not sure how many people were comparing Lance's running ability to Jackson. That certainly wasn't the case with some of the more reputable scouting reports on the quarterback leading into the draft. But apparently, Simms heard that somewhere.
"Yes, I think [Lance is] going to be a good runner," Simms added. "I'm just saying, let's pump the brakes on calling him Lamar or Michael Vick quit yet."
You can listen to the entire podcast below. The discussion surrounding Lance begins at about the 58-minute mark.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Analyst says 49ers are overrated, projects 6-7 wins in 2026
The San Francisco 49ers were one of the more surprising teams last season, overcoming a wave of injuries that quickly depleted their roster and making the playoffs. Despite those setbacks, expectations remain high heading into 2026, with many projecting another double-digit-win... -
49ers may not like Adam Schefter's latest Aaron Donald update
As if Myles Garrett joining the Los Angeles Rams wasn't troubling enough for the San Francisco 49ers, speculation about Aaron Donald returning from retirement continues to gain momentum. ESPN NFL insider Adam Schefter provided the latest update on Donald's status during an... -
Mac Jones on 49ers choosing Lance over him, why he was meant to join Shanahan
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones recently joined the Bussin' with the Boys podcast for a wide-ranging conversation. Among the topics he discussed were the 49ers choosing Trey Lance over him in the 2021 NFL Draft, finally joining Kyle Shanahan's team four years later,... -
Robert Saleh names 49ers' biggest rookie surprise from last season
The San Francisco 49ers invested heavily in their defense during the 2025 NFL Draft, using six of their 11 selections on defensive players, including each of their first five picks. One rookie, however, stood out more than the rest to former 49ers defensive coordinator Robert...