Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports
Simms ranks 49ers’ Jimmy Garoppolo at No. 21 among top 40 QBs
Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Chris Simms of NBC Sports continues the countdown of his often controversial annual ranking of his top 40 NFL quarterbacks. The San Francisco 49ers were previously represented by rookie Trey Lance, who
came in at No. 38. Now we know where starter Jimmy Garoppolo falls within the ranking as teams prepare for the 2021 season.
Simms revealed Nos. 21-25 this week, and Garoppolo sits at No. 21. That is one spot higher than Ben Roethlisberger of the Pittsburgh Steelers.
"Availability is an issue," Simms notes while discussing Garoppolo's placement during his podcast. "Let's just start right there. ... It's the first thing you have to think about. It's why the 49ers drafted a quarterback in the first round. ... Jimmy G does a lot of good things. I don't want to totally crap on him here. It's not about that, OK? Because there are a lot of good things."
Garoppolo is 24-9 (including playoffs) as the 49ers' starting quarterback since the team traded for him in 2017. While Shanahan is 6-17 since 2018 with Garoppolo sidelined, Simms argues that many quarterbacks could win games on San Francisco's roster because of the talent there.
"The problem with the 49ers and why that stat looks so crazy sometimes is the 49ers have dropped the ball on good backup quarterbacks," Simms continued. "They've had crap there. So, they've lost a lot of football games that he's not in there just because it's below-average backup quarterback play.
"Even when he's healthy, and yes, they win and all that, they've sent you the signals. 'Yeah, we're winning. We don't think he's playing well enough, still.' They've been telling us for two years, everything. Just listen to John Lynch or Kyle Shanahan, let alone all the things we know about trying to trade (for a quarterback) or get
Tom Brady or
Matthew Stafford, blah, blah, blah."
Simms feels Garoppolo is physically limited in his ability to move within the pocket, and his arm is average. However, the analyst likes his quick release and awareness.
"He is good in the pocket, and with people around, he can kind of get his feet awkward and just flick it, and do things like that, and get the ball out of his hands really quick," Simms said. "So I love that aspect of him. But is he going to make plays out of the realm of the offense a whole lot? Absolutely not."
Simms adds that Garoppolo is very system-dependent, and all of the faults drop him to No. 21 within the ranking.
Below are the spots within the ranking that have already been revealed.
21. Jimmy Garoppolo
22. Ben Roethlisberger
23. Ryan Fitzpatrick
24. Taysom Hill
25. Jameis Winston
26. Daniel Jones
27. Zach Wilson
28. Trevor Lawrence
29. Andy Dalton
30. Mac Jones
31. Jared Goff
32. Teddy Bridgewater
33. Drew Lock
34. Tua Tagovailoa
35. Tyrod Taylor
36. Marcus Mariota
37. Kellen Mond
38. Trey Lance
39. Justin Fields
40. Case Keenum
Facebook Comments
More San Francisco 49ers News
ESPN analyst on Brandon Aiyuk: 49ers shouldn't pay two receivers top dollar
ESPN analyst Matt Miller understands the perspective of San Francisco 49ers fans. After all, he has been a fan of the team since he was a kid. Seeing any of your favorite players leave and put on another uniform is tough.
It's also difficult to pay everyone, and Miller knows that. It's not a formula for successful roster building, including paying two wide receivers top dollar.
The 49ers are trying to negotiate a contract extension with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. The team invested heavily in another receiver, Deebo Samuel, just two years ago. Is allowing each of them to consume a significant chunk of the salary cap feasible for a team that hopes to continue being competitive and win Super Bowls?
"I have to separate the fan part of my brain, who
Could the 49ers trade up in the draft for a top tackle?
The San Francisco 49ers are likely hoping that a top offensive lineman drops to them at No. 31 in the first round of this month's draft. Fans would like to see the team add someone to compete with Colton McKivitz for the right tackle spot and potentially take over for Trent Williams when the future Hall of Famer decides to retire.
Having two studs bookending the offensive line would go a long way in protecting franchise quarterback Brock Purdy. While tackle may be the first-round target, depending on how the first 30 selections play out, San Francisco might have to trade up to get a genuinely impactful
Are these the 49ers' ideal top 2 draft picks?
With the 2024 NFL Draft less than two weeks away, NFL Media draft analyst Chad Reuter recently identified the ideal top two draft picks for each team. The San Francisco 49ers have 10 selections in the upcoming draft, with their first two picks at No. 31 overall and No. 63.
Reuter noted, "I kept some semblance of realism in this process, however, assigning each player only once and making reasonable projections of where prospects may be selected."
Who are the standout picks for the 49ers? Reuter envisions the team addressing both offense and defense with their initial selections. It's widely anticipated that San Francisco will bolster its offensive line with
49ers insider believes team may prefer WR Brandon Aiyuk play on fifth-year option
The San Francisco 49ers don't always do things like other NFL teams do. But they are consistent, for the most part. Seemingly every offseason, especially in recent years, a star player has wanted a new contract. From TE George Kittle and LB Fred Warner to WR Deebo Samuel and Edge Nick Bosa, the 49ers have given new contracts, but they have waited until late July-early August (and in Bosa's case—September) to do so, much to the chagrin of those players, who wanted their new deal sooner rather than later.
It may not have happened as soon as the players wanted it to, but it has happened. Kittle's contract talks reportedly weren't as smooth as he might have hoped, Samuel famously scrubbed his social media accounts of all things 49ers, and Bosa didn't sign until a few days
