Regardless, the 49ers decided to move forward with Garoppolo and even kept their quarterback in the loop during their entire thought process.
"The one thing I can say about the whole situation was Kyle and John were very honest with me the whole time," Garoppolo told The Athletic last week. "That's their job — to put the best team together possible and you've got to respect that. So as long as the honesty and truthfulness is there, I respect those guys, I love those guys."
Garoppolo completed 69.1 percent of his passes for 3,978 yards with 27 touchdowns and 13 interceptions in his first full NFL season as a starter, leading the 49ers to the Super Bowl.
NBC Sports analyst Chris Simms, who is a close friend of Shanahan's, believes the flirtation with the idea of adding Brady this offseason will motivate Garoppolo.
"I think what they're trying to tell him there too is, 'We think you can play better, and, actually, we don't think you kind of played up to the standards we expect all the way through the year, too,'" Simms told Florio on Pro Football Talk Live.
"I think that's something that Jimmy Garoppolo is going to be able to take away from this to realize, 'OK, yeah, they were truthful with me, and then the reality of the situation is that they're kind of saying that to me too. I need to buckle down on whatever it is, the details that they might feel, as an organization, I'm not quite as good at, or whatever it is on the field.'
"I think that, ultimately, is going to make Jimmy Garoppolo a better player."
You can listen to the entire conversation between Simms and Florio below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Brock Purdy lands at No. 17 in Chris Simms' 2026 QB rankings
Last year, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy earned a spot in Chris Simms' "Scheme Dream" tier of quarterbacks, placing him among the NFL's top 13 signal-callers. The ranking marked steady progress for Purdy, who came in at No. 17 in 2024 and No. 26 in 2023. However,... -
Could former 49ers star return to the NFC West?
NFL teams continue searching for value signings as training camps approach, and former San Francisco 49ers and Washington Commanders wide receiver Deebo Samuel remains one of the most notable names still available in free agency. FOX Sports reporter Ben Arthur recently... -
Why NFL.com believes the 49ers could dethrone the Seahawks in 2026
NFL.com analyst Dan Parr recently ranked eight teams capable of dethroning the Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks in 2026, placing the San Francisco 49ers fifth on the list. Parr noted that sharing the NFC West with Seattle strengthens San Francisco's case, as the division... -
49ers urged to counter Myles Garrett trade with blockbuster move of their own
The NFC West landscape shifted dramatically this week when the Los Angeles Rams acquired star pass rusher Myles Garrett, creating another obstacle in the San Francisco 49ers' pursuit of a division title. In response to the move, Bleacher Report's Alex Kay proposed a...