NFC West Preview: Looking Down - The Cats and the Birds

Sep 4, 2001 at 12:00 AM


Carolina Panthers
Predicted Finish: 3-13 (5th in NFC West)

Outlook: Let me just say this about youth movements: they come in layers. You have a small core of seasoned veterans, some guys who have 2-4 years experience, and then a lot of rookies and free agents. You need some veteran presence; a good youth movement should not be a youth movement in totality.

I think someone needs to tell that to George Seifert. The 'youth movement’ was his justification for jettisoning Steve Beurlein in the off-season – despite the fact that doing so made the 2001 Carolina Panthers the only NFL team in modern history with no quarterback on their roster who had ever started a professional game. Yes, Beurlein was injury prone and aging. His salary was a touch high. But he was also just a year removed from a 4,000 yard passing performance and a Pro Bowl berth. All this will do is stunt the growth of many of the young offensive players, destroy the confidence of the young passers they do have, and doom the Cats to a miserable season. Jeff Lewis, the starter early in camp who said he was 'shocked’ by Beurlein’s departure, has already crumbled underneath the pressure and been cut. Now Chris Weinke – a fourth-round rookie – will start. If you can only muster 3 points against Oklahoma, how do you expect to score on New Orleans?

Perhaps this is Seifert’s way of trying to build a team up himself. He was quoted recently as saying that “with Montana and Young, you knew what you had. Right now, we don’t know what we’ve got. What we do know is that we’ve got to find out what we’ve got, and that’s sort of compelling.” Seifert was a good coach, but he is generally credited with merely inheriting his Super Bowl teams – not building them. So perhaps this is his way of cleansing the Panthers of anything inherited (Beuerlein was already the starter when Seifert came on board) and make it his team, for better or worse.

Make that: 'For better or much worse.’

On offense, the only healthy, above-average player is wideout Muhsin Muhammad, but he will be neutralized by the lack of solid play from the quarterbacks. The next two threats on the receiving front, TE Wesley Walls and WR Patrick Jeffers, both have knee problems. Jeffers will not be a factor; Walls is 35 and is an unknown now because of his off-season knee surgery. If Walls is healthy, he will be a big boost to the young passers. The offensive line gave up 69 sacks last year, but new acquisition Todd Steussie, Kevin Donalley, and Jeff Mitchell should upgrade this unit. RB Tim Biakabutuka has never been healthy (his season high is 718 yards) but there is nobody behind him.

Defensively, things aren’t much better. The defensive tackle situation is not bad. The poster child for NFL underachievers, DT Sean Gilbert, had a decent year in 2000 and rookie Chris Jenkins looks like a keeper. Former 49ers Brenston Buckner, who played very good football for the 49ers last year and picked up 7½ sacks, is the backup. But things are not as rosey at DE. To give you an idea of how bad the Panthers ends are: two guys named Jay Williams and Michael Rucker are the starters. The backups are Christian Peter and Chris Slade, a 9 year veteran who has always played linebacker and weighs 250. Ouch.

The linebackers and secondary are filled with rookies and veterans with nothing left. Safety Mike Minter are rookie backer Dan Morgan are the lone bright spots at either defensive area. At corner, Rashard Anderson can’t cover anyone, and Doug Evans has looked terrible since coming over from the Pack.

Key Player: It has to be RB Tim Biakabutuka. While he’s not a top notch back, if Biakabutuka is healthy, then teams will at least have to think about defending the run. If he’s not healthy, they can drop more players into coverage and rush the passer more aggressively. If either happens, any chance of Weinke even being servicable are over.

How to Beat Them: Obviously, you have to harrass the rookie QB with multiple looks and blitz schemes. Oklahoma had a lot of succes vs. Weinke by collapsing the pocket and making him make plays on the run – something he is ill-suited to do. Again, if Biakabutuka is out, it’s hard to see the Panthers beating anybody.

Atlanta Falcons
Predicted Finish: 5-11 (4th in NFC West)

Overview: For a draft that seemed very forward looking with the drafting of Michael Vick, the Falcons did very little to help themselves this offseason. It’s hard to argue that offensive line and defensive line weren’t the biggest areas of need for the Birds. So why is one seventh-round guard the only significant 2001 addition to either unit? The only thing scarier is that that seventh rounder – Kynan Forney of Hawaii – earned a starting position over two-year starter Calvin Collins, who was cut.

Yikes.

Yes, second round pick Alge Crumpler looks like a great player – but with all the needs the Falcons have, can you afford to draft a tight end when you have a servicable Reggie Kelly already there? I don’t get it, but hell, what do I know?

The faces are the same on offense, but this team is not going to go 14-2 this year. Still, I think the Falcons will win some games with Chris Chandler at quarterback, even though he is fading. In fact, the offense could be pretty good if everyone is healthy and a group of players return to 1998 form. But the consensus I’m hearing is that RB Jamal Anderson is a shadow of his 1998 self. It’s hard not to like the Tony Martin signing. He was the deep threat Chandler didn’t have in 1999 and 2000, and at the veteran minimun the Falcons can’t lose. He didn’t pan out in Miami, but who was throwing him the football? Chris Chandler is a much better match for a deep guy like Martin than Jay Fiedler. Terrance Mathis is still a very solid and dependable wideout. The other good news, of course, is that Michael Vick looked a lot better than many were saying he’d look in the preseason. I think the Falcons will find ways to work him in.

Defensively, it’s a mixed bag even when they’re totally healthy. Linebacker Keith Brooking is the only member of the front seven who would start for the 49ers. The defense if full of meatheads who can run, but lack football smarts – guys like Patrick Kerney, Brady Smith, and Marc Simoneau. Still, DT Travis Hall can be a horse in the middle and is a solid veteran.

The corners are very strong, though Ray Buchanon was in a contract year in 2000. But Marty Carter and Ronnie Bradford are very average at safety.

Key Player: RB Jamal Anderson. If he’s back, the Falcons offense could be very good. When he’s running good, he opens up the passing game and eases the pressure on Chandler. The passing game has enough weapons to move the ball even without Anderson; with him, they could be very dangerous. The biggest reason for the dropoff from the 1998 Falcons and the 1999/2000 Falcons was the health of #32.

How to Beat Them: If Martin can spread the coverage out, it will be harder to keep Mathis, Jefferson, Kelly, and Crumpler under wraps underneath. Their passing game could be a real problem. So I say get to Chandler and hit him, which shouldn’t be too hard with that line. He’s never stood up to beatings very well, and that’s the best way I can think to slow the passing game down if everyone’s healthy. I would focus on the pass and make Jamal Anderson show me he can beat me.

Offensively, I still think we run the football on a front seven that is susceptable to it. Still, I like Terrell Owens matched up with anybody, so we can still work the ball down the field. I think that their backers are fast enough to cover our backs, too. Again, I would get physical with the ground game and pound them.

If everyone is healthy, the Falcons actually could surprise some people. But I just can’t see a team with such weak offensive and defensive lines making a lot of noise.

The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Jimmy Garoppolo fighting perception, looking to prove he can lead 49ers

By Sasha D. Robinson
Nov 24

Is the Jimmy Garoppolo who threw for 228 yards and four touchdowns the guy San Francisco 49ers fans were looking for or is this an illusion like last year? Since stepping back into the starting role for quarterback Trey Lance, who suffered an ankle injury in Week 2 against the Seattle Seahawks, the 49ers have a 6-3 record. Garoppolo has thrown 15 touchdowns and four interceptions, but there is something different about him this year compared to his past couple of years with the team. Garoppolo does not look like the same player who lost a heartbreaker in last year's NFC Championship Game. Instead, he has the fiery presence of someone you want to follow on and off the field. Even the former Eastern Illinois Panther quarterback's deep ball seems to have more



Transcripts: Jimmy Garoppolo, DeMeco Ryans, Chris Foerster preview 49ers-Cardinals Week 11 matchup

By Site Staff
Nov 18

San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, defensive coordinator DeMeco Ryans, and offensive line/run game coordinator Chris Foerster spoke with reporters on Friday. The team is in Colorado Springs, preparing for its Week 11 matchup against the Arizona Cardinals in Mexico City. Here is everything they had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. QB Jimmy Garoppolo How much does it take for you to need to wear a glove while you're practicing? "I usually don't. It just depends. If it's freezing, that's a different story, but out here it wasn't terrible. The snow actually makes the ball a little sticky, so I kind of like it in that sense." DL Nick



Kyle Shanahan, DeMeco Ryans preview 49ers-Saints Week 12 matchup

By Site Staff
Nov 23

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan and defensive coordinator DeMeco Ryans spoke with reporters as the team prepares for its Week 12 matchup against the New Orleans Saints. Here is everything they had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Opening Comments: "Injuries for today. [DL] Arik Armstead won't practice, same, foot/ankle. [DL] Samson [Ebukam] will be limited with his quad/achilles and [T] Trent Williams, not injury related, won't practice. Go ahead." Can you go over what was happening during the game as far as DB Jimmie Ward and CB Charvarius Ward and I guess LB Dre Greenlaw left as well. Was it just them



Ndamukong Suh says decision came down to Eagles, 49ers

By David Bonilla
Nov 20

This past week, defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh signed with the Philadelphia Eagles, making his debut on Sunday in a 17-16 win over the Indianapolis Colts. He told Pro Football Talk that he picked the Eagles because he sought another championship. Suh had another option, though, admitting that he could have signed with the San Francisco 49ers. "Suh told PFT by phone after Sunday's 17-16 win over the Colts in his debut with the Eagles that his decision came down to Philadelphia and San Francisco," wrote Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk. "Suh said that he was attracted to the 49ers because of the presence of defensive line coach Kris


Featured

More by Bradford Seaman

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone