The 49ers' performance this season has led to significant emotional reactions, particularly among fans and some media personalities who are suggesting that the team should part ways with Kyle Shanahan and Brock Purdy.
Let's clarify: the 49ers are not moving on from Shanahan. His job is safe for good reason. Since taking over in 2017, Shanahan and John Lynch have transformed a talent-depleted team into a powerhouse. They have guided the 49ers to four NFC Championship games and two Super Bowls. While it's true that the 49ers have not yet won a Super Bowl during this time, it would be unreasonable to overlook the consistent excellence that 49ers fans have come to expect. For those who question Shanahan's ability to secure the big win, consider this: how long did it take Andy Reid to finally win it all?
It's difficult to watch the 49ers struggle, especially in ways that are uncharacteristic for the team. Fumbles, dropped passes, and poor special teams play have all contributed to an almost-lost season. However, there is a silver lining to this down year: a cheaper Brock Purdy. There has been speculation that the 49ers will sign Purdy to a significant contract extension, but this season has shown that he needs a solid supporting cast. While it's true that this applies to all quarterbacks, Purdy has faced more challenges compared to those with standout physical abilities. If Purdy is willing to accept a lower-than-expected salary, extending him is a wise decision. Here's why:
Mental Resiliency
Brock may lack a massive arm or elite speed, but those attributes don't always lead to winning Super Bowls. Many highly drafted quarterbacks possess similar qualities but go on to have mediocre or even disastrous careers. This is often due to developing bad habits because they lack a supportive environment. It's not that they lack the tools to succeed; it's that they get mentally derailed before having a real chance. Brock Purdy excels because of his mental toughness, accuracy, and surprisingly good ability to extend plays.
Consistent Performance
It's easy to envy players like Josh Allen, Patrick Mahomes, or Justin Herbert for their ability to throw exceptional passes in adverse conditions. However, teams should not rely on players to win in situations they rarely encounter. Brock may have underperformed in tough weather conditions, which could cost the 49ers a game or two, but he is likely to play most of the season in favorable conditions. While having a strong throwing arm is impressive, completing low-percentage 70-yard passes isn't a reliable strategy, even for those elite quarterbacks.
Financial Flexibility to Strengthen the Trenches
The 49ers have found success for various reasons, but their dominant defensive line has been particularly impactful. Although the current defensive line isn't terrible, it's clear that something is missing. The team let players like DeForest Buckner and Arik Armstead go, and they are now feeling the consequences of that decision. The skill position players are aging but are still in their prime. If the 49ers can save money by extending Brock Purdy affordably after this down season, they can reinvest that money into rebuilding the defensive line, positioning themselves as Super Bowl contenders once again.
In summary, although the season isn't over, it should be categorized as an anomaly. If the 49ers can sign Purdy to a reasonable extension and revamp the defensive line, Shanahan will continue to demonstrate why he is one of the best coaches in the league.