Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports
49ers Have All the Leverage and Should Just Say No to Paying George Kittle What He Wants
The San Francisco 49ers and star tight end
George Kittle are currently working on a contract extension. The two sides have been for awhile. No one outside of the franchise knows how close the two sides are. What is known is the type of money Kittle is seeking.
Kittle wants to be paid like a top offensive tackle or wide receiver. His agent went public with this info nearly a month ago. Since then there has been silence from both sides. They could be far apart. Heck, they could have already agreed considering the team managed to keep DeForest Buckner's permission to seek a trade and head coach Kyle Shanahan's extension secrets for MONTHS.
It wouldn't be surprising if they aren't close however. This is because the 49ers hold every ounce of leverage in this situation (more on this later). Kittle has no ability to force the 49ers to pay him like a tackle or receiver other than refusing to play. Both Julio Jones (top paid WR) and Laremy Tunsil (top paid LT) are paid an average of $22 million per season.
Refusing to play has been done by others in the past. However, it is neither the way Kittle seems to operate nor does he have the ability to make do without any pay like the 49ers own
Trent Williams did with the Washington Redskins.
Kittle was a fifth-round draft pick. He's made a little more than $1.5 million TOTAL in his three-year career. Living in the Bay Area and getting married during this time period means he isn't likely sitting on a pile of cash. Sitting out all of 2020 would go against the type of person he seems to be and likely put him in a financial predicament.
This is just one reason the 49ers have all the leverage.
The bigger part of why the 49ers can refuse to pay Kittle what he wants is the franchise tag in combination with the amount other tight ends get paid. The current top paid contract among tight ends is the one Austin Hooper signed this off-season ($42 million, four years). It has an average annual salary (AAV) of $10.5 million for the math challenged readers.
That's it. That's the best. If Kittle is seeking top receiver or tackle pay it means he is seeking to double the current AAV of the highest paid player at his position.
Yes, Kittle is uniquely valuable. He blocks like a top tackle and is the 49ers' best receiving weapon in the passing game. His value is only amplified in Shanahan's system as well. He absolutely should reset the market ... by a wide margin.
But doubling the current top pay for his position? Not with the fact the 49ers can control his next four years at a fraction of that cost. Kittle is set to count for $2.2 million against the salary cap in 2020. The 49ers can then start utilizing the franchise tag to keep Kittle on the team.
The TE franchise tag amount is projected to be about $10.6 million in 2020. Assuming that climbs a little in the next year (might decrease due to COVID), let's say $11 million for 2021. That's what Kittle would make two seasons from now. The 49ers could then use the tag again in 2022 and pay Kittle 120 percent of the previous amount. This means Kittle would make $13.2 million in the 2022 season ($11 million X 1.2 = $13.2).
It's not over yet though. The 49ers can then tag Kittle a third time at 144 percent his previous year's salary bringing his 2023 salary amount to a hair more than $19 million.
Add the four years up and you get the equivalent of a four-year, $45.4 million contract extension which is an $11.35 million AAV. The 49ers get that with the added benefit of being free and clear of dead cap space every single year if a catastrophic injury or some unforeseeable decline in quality of play happens.
A four-year, $45.4 million extension with an out for the 49ers every year would be seen as a massive steal of the deal for the team. The 49ers shouldn't and simply don't need to pay Kittle anywhere near the $22 million he is seeking.
Paying Kittle a long-term contract with an AAV in the $13-15 million range is where this negotiation should end up. It represents 130 to 150 percent of the current highest AAV for the position and gives Kittle more money than he would get if the 49ers are forced to go the franchise tag route.
Kittle gets a big pay day immediately as well in the form of a signing bonus. This shouldn't be ignored considering how little he's made so far and the potential of no season this year (yes, still possible).
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
More San Francisco 49ers News
49ers Notebook: George Kittle raves about Trey Lance; Time to expect even bigger things from Brandon Aiyuk; Shanahan assesses Sam Darnold; Nick Bosa's offseason tweak
The 49ers began their annual mandatory minicamp Tuesday, which as always will mark the end of the third and final phase of the team's offseason workout schedule. The team will break for the summer following Wednesday's session, so Tuesday was an opportunity for reporters to catch up with a number of 49ers players as well as head coach Kyle Shanahan to get some final updates before the team departs.
Among those who spoke with the media Tuesday were wide receiver Deebo Samuel, defensive end Nick Bosa, and tight end George Kittle. 49ers Webzone posted updates earlier on some of the most newsworthy moments from those media sessions, but that was far from the only thing discussed Tuesday. Here's a recap of what the players and Shanahan said, including some praise for Trey Lance
49ers' George Kittle looking to avoid another early-season slump
George Kittle was inactive for the first two games of last season due to a groin injury. The San Francisco 49ers tight end averaged under 30 receiving yards in the two games following his return.
The production started to increase from there. The All-Pro tight end felt healthy toward the end of the season, amid a 12-game win streak (including the playoffs). That has carried into this offseason, which is significant for the player who often exits a season feeling the wear and tear on his body.
"It just allowed me to work the way that I wanted to work earlier in the offseason," Kittle told reporters on Tuesday. "Not to take so much time off to rehab and recover, do a bunch of treatments and stuff like that. I was actually just able to get a good foundation in,
49ers Notebook: Javon Hargrave's first 49ers thoughts; Trent Williams' weird late-night workout schedule; Wilks on DBs; Deommodore Lenoir wants to be elite
The 49ers ended their offseason workout program on Wednesday with their final session of mandatory minicamp. But before they made their way out the door for the summer, the team gave fans and reporters one last dose of info in the form of the final media sessions of the spring.
Among those speaking to reporters on Wednesday were defensive tackle Javon Hargrave, left tackle Trent Williams and cornerback Deommodore Lenoir, as well as defensive coordinator Steve Wilks. Each session produced some interesting tidbits, which we'll review in this version of 49ers notebook.
Hargrave speaks
Despite being the splash free agent addition of the offseason for the 49ers, Javon Hargrave had not met with the team's beat reporters in person before Wednesday.
Kyle Juszczyk: 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk "just looks different than everyone else on the field"
Anything short of topping his 78-catch, 1,015-receiving-yard, and eight-touchdown performance from last season might disappoint San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. All were career highs, and the fourth-year wideout expects more of himself in 2023.
"I'm about to take off," Aiyuk declared last week. "That's it. ... We all know it's football. Nothing's ever guaranteed, but just getting a better understanding for my life as a person, and then as a football player, kind of putting those things together and then just looking to get better."
If Aiyuk does "take off" during the upcoming season, it creates an interesting predicament for the organization. When
