49ers place Nick Bosa, Solomon Thomas on injured reserve, sign Ziggy Ansah, announce other roster moves →
Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports


Richard Sherman points out flaws in PFF’s grading system

Jul 28, 2020 at 7:55 AM--


Let me first point out that Richard Sherman was Pro Football Focus' highest-graded (90.3) cornerback last season. The San Francisco 49ers veteran defender is one of just two cornerbacks who have been targeted more than 250 times over the past decade and allowed a completion rate of less than 50 percent. The other is Darrelle Revis.

Sherman is pretty good, and the analytics back that up.

During an Instagram interview with Pro Football Focus, however, Sherman didn't sound ready to endorse the analytics site's grading system. Let's be clear; the cornerback will often share social media posts from Pro Football Focus that tout the high level of play from fellow defenders—especially the defensive backs.

Despite being named among the league's best last season by the analytics site, Sherman pointed out why he felt the grading process, at least at times, could be flawed.

"I'll go games where I don't get targeted the whole game, and in your system, it's kind of like a flat grade for that," Sherman explained during the lengthy conversation. "There's no way to quantify that. But in terms of what we're doing schematically, and how I'm judged off doing my job and making tackles, and being sound, I'm usually right on it.

"And then I'll look up at the grade I'm getting from PFF, and it will be like, 'Well, we didn't have enough information. You didn't get targeted, so there's no way to give you a great grade.' Then it's like, what am I supposed to do? If I get targeted 10 times, and I can get a bunch of PBUs, I can get a high grade. But if I don't get targeted at all, [I can't]."

The interviewer noted that Pro Football Focus is working on finding ways to credit defensive backs who aren't targeted in games. He even invited Sherman to come work for the analytics site and help improve its grading system once his playing days are over.

As noted above, Sherman shares Pro Football Focus' posts, so he does find value in it. Is it perfect? No. No grading system is, especially when you don't have inside knowledge from coaches of what they expect from each player on every play.

Pro Football Focus' data is a tool. One of many that can be used in conjunction with others for player evaluation.

"I think you guys are doing a great job because it's so new," Sherman continued. "So obviously, it will evolve over time. You guys will get better. But there are so many variables involved in coverage, and especially when you're not grading it with an understanding of the scheme that they're running."

Sherman believes analytics can be improved by blending the data with input from those who had a much better understanding of what each team is trying to accomplish with every play.

"I think that you guys' system just needs more conversation," Sherman shared. "More conversation with maybe coordinators and players, I guess. Because the coordinator would be able to coach you up and say, 'Hey, this is what they're responsible for. This is how important it was to the defense.' ... There's too many variables."






More San Francisco 49ers News



Richard Sherman has talked contract with 49ers, plans to play three more seasons after 2020

By David Bonilla
Sep 10, 2020

At some point, Richard Sherman will enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He'll have to wait until five years after retirement to do so, and some wonder when the San Francisco 49ers' veteran cornerback will decide to call it a career. It sounds like that will be after the 2023 season. And Sherman hopes to continue playing for the 49ers. "I do believe that I have good years left in me," Sherman told reporters after Thursday's practice. "I'm only going to play three after this. That's what the wife (Ashley) told me. I don't call any shots after that. "Three years after this, if the good San Francisco 49ers would love to keep me on this ball club, I'd love to be here. But after that, I'm going to go into the booth." Sherman is entering his

Read the Full Article


Robert Saleh discusses 49ers-Cardinals, Fred Warner, Richard Sherman, Kyler Murray, Isaiah Simmons

By Site Staff
Sep 10, 2020

San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh spoke with reporters after Thursday's practice as his team prepares for its Week 1 matchup against the Arizona Cardinals. Here is everything he had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. When you look at the Cardinals offense and the fact that they were able to run the ball so effectively, particularly after getting Arizona Cardinals RB Kenyan Drake last year despite using a lot of three or four wide receiver sets. Why do you think that it is and how difficult is it to defend an offense like that given that they like to spread defenses out? "Give them credit. They've got a good system. They've evolved as the course of the year went

Read the Full Article


49ers-Cardinals: Kyle Shanahan unwilling to reveal starting cornerback opposite Richard Sherman

By David Bonilla
Sep 11, 2020

The San Francisco 49ers released an unofficial depth chart ahead of Week 1. It listed "Emmanuel Moseley OR Ahkello Witherspoon" as the starting cornerback opposite veteran Richard Sherman. While Moseley is expected to start, we may not officially know that until warmups on Sunday morning. Kyle Shanahan sounds content with leaving the Arizona Cardinals guessing until then. The 49ers coach joined KNBR on Friday morning and was asked if the team has officially named the second starting cornerback. "No, we don't officially do anything this year," Shanahan responded. Of course, he knows. That doesn't mean listeners were going to get

Read the Full Article

Featured

More Featured Stories

Trending News

More News
Share 49erswebzone