The San Francisco 49ers' trade for Indianapolis Colts defensive tackle DeForest Buckner made a lot of sense, especially for only a 4th-round pick. Buckner is a star who can add to the pass rush and is stout against the run.

He can also impart a lot of knowledge and help young players, such as defensive tackle Gracen Halton, develop.


But this is a wild time in the NFL, with pundits spilling a lot of digital ink on whom teams should trade for or might trade for. But those prospective deals often don't account for context or what the team would lose.

We just found out that the Niners tried to trade for former 49ers wide receiver Jauan Jennings, but he nixed the deal.

THANK GOODNESS!!!

It isn't that I don't like Jennings. I do. He's a very good player. And a player who would ask for more money next year and probably not get it from the 49ers, which would lead to disharmony.

More importantly, the 49ers already have the following:



Carlos Torres wrote a good article on how crowded that receiver room is going to be very soon. So whom would Jennings replace? Evans? Hardly. Deebo? Give me a break. Robinson? Not on half the route tree. Stribling? He is one of the most important developmental players on the team.

How much playing time would Jennings get? It's one thing if a team trades for a star. That is an impact player. This would be a treading-water-for-a-few-games trade. Jordan Watkins has demonstrated a lot of potential. He could be as impactful as Jennings and cost less—both in money and draft picks.

Should the Niners give up a third-round pick for Josh Downs, a free agent after this year? Last year, they selected running back Kaelon Black in the third round. The year before, they selected nickel corner Upton Stout. Offensive guard Dominick Puni was a third-rounder.

The first is key to keeping running back Christian McCaffrey rested and healthy. The other two are starters, with Stout often touted as one of the best at his position from that draft.


Downs would likely be a rental. But he was the number three receiver in Indianapolis before Michael Pittman left for the Pittsburgh Steelers, and he would be number two now if Alec Pierce hadn't gotten hurt. It would not be worth it.

On the other hand, the Seattle Seahawks gave up a third-round pick for offensive guard Quentin Nelson. Nelson is a multi-year All-Pro at his position, and left guard is a major need for the 49ers. That would have been a great move for San Francisco. (It didn't surprise me that general manager John Lynch didn't go that route. He rarely invests money or draft capital on the offensive line.)

This year's draft gave the 49ers edge rusher Romello Height, Halton, and linebacker Jaden Dugger. It gave them Stribling and Black.

Two years ago, the 49ers landed cornerback Renardo Green and safety Malik Mustapha.

Draft picks in the third round or earlier should be reserved for players who will start now or have the untapped potential to develop into starters. Save late-round picks for players who will at least be immediate backups (and Lynch has been phenomenal at identifying those).


It is easy to get excited about a trade, but I am not so interested in rentals. Buckner will be a free agent at the end of the year, but he is so good he can make a big impact now, and if Lynch can keep him this time around, Buck would transform the defensive line.

I can fantasize about potential roster additions as much as anyone, but those dreams can just as easily be realized through the draft. The difference is that draft picks let the 49ers develop long-term contributors rather than surrender valuable capital for a player who might leave after just a few months.

Written By:

Jack Stewart


Jack Stewart was educated at Alabama and Emory and was a Brittain Fellow at Georgia Tech. His poetry has been published widely in the US and several other countries. His book No Reason was published in the Poeima Poetry Series in 2020.
All articles by Jack Stewart


Follow us on: X, Facebook, Threads, Instagram

Nobody's perfect. Did you find a mistake in this article? Report it.


More San Francisco 49ers News