The QB "Controversy"
After Mac Jones led the 49ers to a 26–23 overtime win over the Rams, the whispers of a quarterback controversy grew louder. Three wins with Jones, compared to Brock Purdy's 1-1 record this season, have fueled talk among fans and media outlets alike. On paper, it's an easy argument: Jones has delivered victories while Brock Purdy has struggled. But coaching decisions are not made based on stat sheets.
What Jones did against the Rams was impressive, but it was also the product of Kyle Shanahan's masterclass in play-calling. Shanahan schemed receivers wide open, designed quick passes to neutralize the rush, and ensured that only 10 of Jones' 49 completions traveled more than 10 yards downfield. Brock Purdy can make those throws too—and he brings more mobility, better pocket presence, and a higher long-term ceiling.
Why Mac Jones Should Stay
The real reason Jones shouldn't be traded is that it would compromise depth. This 49ers roster is talented but notoriously injury-prone. Against the Rams, San Francisco was missing Purdy, George Kittle, Ricky Pearsall, Jauan Jennings, Brandon Aiyuk, and Nick Bosa—just to name a few. And yet, with Jones at quarterback, they still managed to beat one of the league's most explosive offenses.
Purdy has already missed three games this year. Jones stepped in and won all three. That's not something you casually trade away. The playoffs are within reach, and the team can't afford another Josh Johnson situation.
Yes, the 49ers absolutely need to pursue a pass rusher. But doing so at the expense of a reliable quarterback—one who has proven he can keep the season afloat when injuries pile up—would be reckless. So, John Lynch: find your edge rusher. Just don't let Mac Jones be the price.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers trade buzz: Fowler breaks down options for Brandon Aiyuk and Mac Jones
The San Francisco 49ers made it easier to move on from injured wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk this offseason by voiding his guaranteed money for 2026—including a $24.9 million option bonus—in July. The Athletic first reported the decision last week, immediately sparking... -
49ers' Brock Purdy may have a request for Mac Jones, explains sideline arm brace
Last year, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy surprised his offensive linemen with Toyota vehicles—an extravagant gesture considering he had not yet signed his lucrative contract extension. Of course, Purdy was an endorsement partner for Toyota at the time, meaning... -
49ers' John Lynch casts doubt on Brandon Aiyuk's return this season
The San Francisco 49ers have long expressed optimism about wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk returning to the field this season. That optimism appears to be fading. During a Tuesday morning interview on Bay Area radio station KNBR, general manager John Lynch was asked whether it's... -
John Lynch sets the record straight on 49ers' relationship with Brandon Aiyuk
The Brandon Aiyuk situation took a dramatic turn last week when The Athletic reported that the San Francisco 49ers had voided the wide receiver's guaranteed 2026 salary, a move that signaled a potential split between the team and its player. Head coach Kyle Shanahan later...