49ers lose messy one in Cleveland

In an ugly and embarrassing performance in Cleveland, the San Francisco 49ers dropped to 5-1 after a 19-17 loss to the Browns.

The game started off well with an opening touchdown drive, but that was just about all 49ers fans had to celebrate. The defense wasn't good, but the offense was horrible. They couldn't throw, couldn't block, couldn't catch.


Unfortunately, all three of those things are important for an offense to score.

Christian McCaffrey (oblique/rib) and Deebo Samuel (shoulder) both left the game with injuries. We'll have to see the severity of the injuries. Both could potentially miss the Monday night game against Minnesota. Trent Williams was in a walking boot after the game. And Deommodore Lenoir left the game with what looked like a calf injury, hopefully just cramps.

Here's what jumped out to me during the game:

• Another opening touchdown drive for the 49ers. Yawn.

• McCaffrey. All he does is score touchdowns.

• Second game in a row that a Spencer Burford penalty nullified a first down. This was a bad game for Burford overall.
• Ambry Thomas must not have been content playing badly on defense. Now he's doing it on special teams.
• I'm not used to seeing 2023 Brandon Aiyuk drop passes.
• The Browns' defense is as good as advertised.
• Horrible missed tackle by Talanoa Hufanga on the big pass play in the second quarter.
• I had multiple people call me an idiot last week because I said this would be a stiff test for the 49ers. None of them reached out to apologize.
• Brock Purdy had some Jimmy Garoppolo-type throws in this game. Not his best game.
• The 49ers defense gave up too many big plays.
• Welcome to the 49ers, Randy Gregory. Huge first sack.

• The offensive line has been good most of the season. They were awful in Cleveland.
• This was the sloppiest game under Kyle Shanahan since the Denver debacle in week 3 last season. Or maybe the Kansas City game last season.
• The 49ers have been relatively healthy this season. That ended in week 6.
• Penalties kill.
• This was easily Purdy's worst game. He missed a lot of throws.
• The huge interception by Lenoir led to a huge touchdown run by Jordan Mason.

• By the way, is Lenior becoming the 49ers' top corner?
• Isaiah Oliver is a really solid tackler.
• I didn't expect to see the Browns run the ball so well against the 49ers defense.
• George Kittle was the invisible man.
• Did I mention this wasn't the best game for the offensive line?
• The personal foul penalty called on Tashaun Gipson was horrible.

• The defense gave up 19 points to a team starting a career backup at QB.
• Jake "not money" Moody.

Moody will get the blame, but the 49ers should never have put their rookie kicker in that position. Brutal loss and a horrible game from the team that's supposed to be the best in the league. Still, Moody needs to hit that kick. Rookie or not.


After the game, Nick Bosa said, "I don't think we deserved to win today."

I agree.

More San Francisco 49ers News

• 49ers take care of business in Cleveland: Brock Purdy, defense shine in 26-8 win

  Full disclaimer: I only saw the very end of the first half forward as I was taking my daughter to the airport, so I missed return man Skyy Moore's big punt return and running back Christian McCaffery's touchdown run. In fact, the first play I saw was Cleveland tight end Harold...
  Read Article

• Recap: 49ers ride Browns' dysfunctional special teams performance to 26-8 victory in Cleveland

  It felt at times like the Browns were trying to hand Sunday's game at Huntington Bank Field in Cleveland to the San Francisco 49ers on a silver platter, and the 49ers were more than happy to take it. On a cold, blustery day next to the Lake Erie shoreline, where winds were...
  Read Article

• 49ers vs. Browns injury updates: Juszczyk, others exit the game in Cleveland

  The San Francisco 49ers are facing the Cleveland Browns at Huntington Bank Field in Week 13. Below are the latest in-game injury updates for the 49ers. This article will be updated in real time as new information becomes available. Players are listed in order of most recent...
  Read Article

• The Stat No One's Talking About That Could Define the 49ers' 2025 Season

  A lot has been written about the outstanding performance of San Francisco's coaching staff this year. Head coach Kyle Shanahan deserves all the praise for the work he's done with the offense and the overall team chemistry. Defensive coordinator Robert Saleh, of course, is...
  Read Article