Garoppolo is 24-9 as the 49ers' starting quarterback. However, he has made it out of September injury-free just once as a starter. Garoppolo missed 23 games over the past three seasons, with his lone full season as a starter coming in 2019. San Francisco did pretty well that year, making it to Super Bowl LIV.
What if Lance has a superb training camp? While head coach Kyle Shanahan admits he wouldn't be against starting a rookie, he doesn't expect a first-year passer to beat out Garoppolo.
"Jimmy is a very good player," Shanahan said last month. "He's not just coming in trying to beat out a guy who hasn't done it before. When Jimmy's played, he's played at a very high level."
For now, the plan is for Lance to be Garoppolo's backup and understudy, using the time to master Shanahan's extensive playbook. However, some believe fans could see Lance on the football field sooner than expected.
NFL Network's Gregg Rosenthal wouldn't be shocked to see Lance as the 49ers' Week 1 starter. Others feel Garoppolo will start in that first game, but Lance could take over earlier than expected. Jenny Vrentas, a senior writer for Sports Illustrated, falls into that group. A fan recently asked her if other NFC West teams would rather face Garoppolo or Lance.
"The longer Jimmy Garoppolo starts, the longer Trey Lance needs to get ready, and that's certainly the scenario NFC West foes are hoping for," Vrentas responded in a mailbag article. "But I have a hunch we'll see Lance sooner than expected."
The perception is that there is a steep learning curve for Lance, who had limited collegiate experience and hasn't played since October 3, 2020. That was his only game since the Division I Football Championship nine months earlier.
"A lot has been made about Lance's needing time to make the jump from his 17 starts at North Dakota State to the NFL," Vrentas continued, "and keeping Garoppolo gives the 49ers that flexibility not to force Lance into the lineup. But another North Dakota State QB was also expected to sit his rookie year, and Carson Wentz ended up being the Week 1 starter for the Eagles in 2016."
Lance's potential in Shanahan's offense excites analysts. The coach has faith that the versatile quarterback can beat opponents with both his arm and his legs. In 2019, Lance passed for 2,786 yards with 28 touchdowns and no interceptions while adding 1,100 rushing yards and 14 trips into the end zone on 169 carries.
Added Vrentas: "The sooner Lance plays in San Francisco, the sooner it means that he is ready (barring other circumstances, such as an injury opening the door), and so are the new possibilities his versatile abilities can unlock in Kyle Shanahan's offense."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers star Fred Warner turns on the frenzy at the Mexico vs. Ecuador game
Mexico marched into the next round of the 2026 FIFA World Cup with a 2-0 victory over Ecuador in the Round of 32. The game took place at Estadio Azteca in Mexico City. Julian Quinones led the way for Mexico with a goal and an assist in the first half, while... -
Report: 49ers exploring possible relocation of practice facilities
The San Francisco 49ers have invested heavily in their current practice facility in Santa Clara, California, which sits adjacent to Levi's Stadium and serves as the team's headquarters. However, with limited room for expansion, only so much can be done. It turns out, the... -
'We get to hit people in the face': 49ers' George Kittle sends fiery message to division rivals
San Francisco 49ers fans were understandably frustrated watching the Seattle Seahawks capture Super Bowl LX at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara. Seeing a division rival celebrate a championship on your home field is never easy. 49ers All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner understands... -
49ers fans take note: NFL insider warns 'the 18-game slate is coming'
San Francisco 49ers fans would undoubtedly welcome another opportunity each season to watch their favorite team take the field. According to one NFL insider, that extra game is likely on the horizon—it's simply a matter of when the league and players can agree on the...