Three years later, he returns to the free agency market, and is still looking for a home next year.
Sherman, regarded as one of the top corners over the past decade, played in only five games last season due to calf injuries and has also torn his Achilles in the past, raising questions of whether he can still play at a high level.
Regardless, the 49ers should love to bring him back, even as a depth piece, because of his leadership ability and football mind.
However, don't count on it.
This offseason, the 49ers brought back all three of their top corners last season: Jason Verrett, Emmanuel Moseley, and K'Waun Williams, while also drafting Michigan's Ambry Thomas and Oregon's Deommodore Lenoir.
After all of their moves, the 49ers currently have only $4.5 million remaining in cap space.
This doesn't include the likely impending Fred Warner extension, which will need some cap maneuvering in itself to fit under the 2021 cap, such as an Arik Armstead restructure.
Once the Warner extension kicks in, the 49ers will have some cap room, but that emergency space is allotted towards midseason additions if any injuries occur, meaning that they don't have much space for any other offseason additions.
In addition, a player of Sherman's caliber would likely request a deal in the range of at least $5 million annually, as his current market value stands at around $9 million.
While Verrett has struggled to remain healthy throughout his career and Williams only played in eight games last year, the 49ers seem to be going in a youthful direction with their draftees, and Sherman just doesn't fit in that timeline or within their salary cap.
In fact, Sherman himself pointed out last December that the possibility of a reunion with the team was unlikely due to the salary cap issues.
"We've had brief conversations," Sherman said of contract talks with the 49ers. "I think that there's obviously a want from both sides to come back and make this work.
Unfortunately, I don't know that the circumstances will allow it.
"That's the sad, sad truth. It's one of those years where it's not from anybody's fault that it may not work out. And it will be a sad parting because I've really enjoyed my time here.
I've enjoyed this team. I have brothers on this team, and I think we still have work to do. But I don't know that the circumstances will allow it."
During the conversation with NBC Sports, Sherman noted the number of impending free agents that the team had, making it difficult for the 49ers to fit him into their future plans.
"There are a ton of guys that need to be paid and are coming up," Sherman said. "Fred Warner is coming up. There are, like, 40 free agents who need to be re-signed. At the end of the day, they have to do what's best for the majority, for the team. And I got to understand that. And so the numbers are adding up to that I won't be here, unless something miraculous happens, which would be really cool."
While Sherman still has expressed interest in the 49ers, don't look for him in a 49ers jersey next season.
Written By:
Writer/Reporter for 49ers Webzone
All articles by Rohan Chakravarthi
@RohanChakrav
YouTube Channel
Rohan Chakravarthi
Writer/Reporter for 49ers Webzone
All articles by Rohan Chakravarthi
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Dre Greenlaw opens up on 49ers return and reunion with Fred Warner
Dre Greenlaw is back with the San Francisco 49ers this offseason after spending the 2025 campaign with the Denver Broncos, and the veteran linebacker says the return has felt like coming home. Perhaps most importantly, Greenlaw is reunited with All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner,... -
49ers reunion? Nick Bosa, Kyle Shanahan address Joey Bosa interest
Veteran pass rusher Joey Bosa has been linked to the San Francisco 49ers throughout the offseason as the team looks to bolster a pass rush that struggled last year, finishing with an NFL-low 20 sacks. Despite the fit on paper, questions remain about whether a move is realistic... -
Why NFL.com believes the 49ers could dethrone the Seahawks in 2026
NFL.com analyst Dan Parr recently ranked eight teams capable of dethroning the Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks in 2026, placing the San Francisco 49ers fifth on the list. Parr noted that sharing the NFC West with Seattle strengthens San Francisco's case, as the division... -
Stats breakdown shows why 49ers' Kyle Shanahan and Brock Purdy remain elite
Every year, especially at draft time and heading into the season, fans are treated to a lot of potentially unfamiliar vocabulary. Three-technique or five-technique. This or that cornerback can or cannot flip his hips quickly. Statisticians have more categories than ever, even...