It is worth noting that Miller is a lifelong 49ers fan, so that may influence his opinion. But there is certainly a lot of excitement surrounding Lance's potential within head coach Kyle Shanahan's creative offense.
Mel Kiper went with Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts as his choice. Todd McShay went with Pittsburgh Steelers running back Najee Harris. Louis Riddick picked Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver Ja'Marr Chase.
"Great choices guys, but this is still a quarterback league," Miller responded during the SportsCenter segment (h/t to Alex Espinoza of NBC Sports for the find), "and Trey Lance is going to the best possible situation for a rookie quarterback with all the weapons they have, the mind of Kyle Shanahan, a very good offensive line."
It's tough to earn Offensive Rookie of the Year honors if you don't play, and most don't figure Lance to play much during the upcoming season. That could include Shanahan. The 49ers held onto quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo because the team owns a win-now roster, and Lance won't have to be thrown into the situation before he is ready. He has the luxury of sitting and learning for at least a season. It's a blueprint that has worked in the past for teams like Kansas City, Green Bay, and even San Francisco.
"Jimmy's definitely our starter right now," Shanahan recently told Rich Eisen. "Right now, there isn't competition because I don't believe Trey would be in a position to compete. Jimmy is too good of a player, has too good of a grasp of our offense. He'll start out OTAs running, like he's done before, and he'll be the starting quarterback.
"I just see Trey coming in here, trying to learn everything, trying to learn his teammates, and we'll just see how it goes. I'm not going to sit here and say I'll never play a rookie quarterback. And I'm not going to say I will play him. That's kind of up to him."
Miller, however, believes a competition could emerge and that Lance may make his way into the starting lineup earlier than most expect.
"I do believe we see Trey Lance this year, and I think he has the type of year -- we're going to be looking at the Niners as a playoff team once again, and Trey Lance as our Offensive Rookie of the Year," added Miller.
Pro Football Focus recently ranked Lance as having the fifth-best chance to earn Offensive Rookie of the Year honors. Trevor Lawrence, Chase, Pitts, and Zach Wilson were all seen as better potential options — again, due to the uncertainty surrounding Lance's playing time.
"This one is a wildcard bet because it hinges almost entirely on whether Lance starts this season," wrote analyst Michael Renner. "If he helms the 49ers offense in Week 1, Lance is neck and neck with Trevor Lawrence for the favorite. This is someone who has played one game of football in the past year, though, and is making the leap from FCS competition to the NFL. He goes to the single best situation for a rookie quarterback, however, as Shanahan made Robert Griffin III into the Rookie of the Year over Andrew Luck and Russell Wilson back in 2012.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Why NFL.com believes the 49ers could dethrone the Seahawks in 2026
NFL.com analyst Dan Parr recently ranked eight teams capable of dethroning the Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks in 2026, placing the San Francisco 49ers fifth on the list. Parr noted that sharing the NFC West with Seattle strengthens San Francisco's case, as the division... -
Why 49ers coach quickly fell in love with rookie LB Jaden Dugger
The San Francisco 49ers selected linebacker Jaden Dugger out of Louisiana in the fifth round of the 2026 NFL Draft. During the pre-draft process, Dugger stood out as a prospect with the athleticism, instincts, and upside to develop into an impact defender at the NFL level. One... -
49ers mailbag: How much will Kaelon Black play as a rookie? Will SF sign any more free agents? Will the defense be any better in 2026?
The San Francisco 49ers have started OTAs (organized team activities), and there's finally actual football to discuss. It may not be like training camp, but it's close enough. And training camp isn't too far away. We opened the 49ers Webzone Mailbag to see what was on your... -
Why 49ers rookie Romello Height has defensive line coach excited
The San Francisco 49ers used a third-round draft pick on defensive end Romello Height, hoping the rookie can help bolster a pass rush that lacked consistency last season. Height is coming off a breakout 2025 campaign at Texas Tech, where he recorded a career-high 10 sacks and...