What does that mean for both defenders? It means their recoveries may be longer than others. The good news is that both injuries occurred early in the season — during Week 2. Thomas suffered his injury just two plays after Bosa was carted off the field.
"They weren't just straight-forward, isolated ACL injuries," ElAttrache told Barrows. "These were bigger injuries. But they're both ahead of where ordinarily we'd expect them to be. And so they're both going through their initial stages of functional performance training. So it's looking very promising for both of those guys."
ESPN's Adam Schefter reported in September that there was some additional cartilage damage in Bosa's knee, but that wasn't expected to hinder his rehabilitation.
Barrows also notes that ElAttrache is among the top surgeons in the field and has a lot of experience successfully repairing professional athletes' knees, including 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo in 2018.
While the recovery rate for ACL patients is far from 100 percent, ElAttrache adds that athletes can return stronger than before the injury because the surgical techniques and rehabilitation process have improved over the years.
"Rehab's been great," Thomas recently said during a Bleacher Report AMA. "I'm tackling it real hard. There's been some ups and downs, but I'm making progress. It's been a lot of great work. I'm in a great place."
Bosa is preparing to enter his third NFL season, while Thomas is scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent. The latter has not dismissed the possibility of returning to the 49ers and recently stated that he would do so "if the deal is right."
Click here to read Barrows' entire feature over at The Athletic.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers WR jokingly asks for more money after nice Patriots gesture
A gesture by the New England Patriots caught the attention of San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Kendrick Bourne. The Patriots reportedly paid Mack Hollins a $400,000 incentive bonus even though he fell four receptions short of the statistical threshold required to trigger the... -
49ers NFLPA report card revealed: Players grade facilities, coaches, leadership, more
The NFL recently prevailed in its grievance against the NFLPA, preventing the players' association from publicly releasing its annual team report cards, arguing that the release violated the CBA. However, it was only a matter of time before the results surfaced... -
John Lynch: 49ers expect Nick Bosa, key defenders back by training camp
Losing Nick Bosa to a torn ACL in Week 3 dealt a significant blow to the San Francisco 49ers defense, which struggled to generate consistent pressure on opposing quarterbacks throughout the 2025 NFL season. It marked the second ACL injury of Bosa's NFL career, with the first... -
49ers NFL Combine Watch: Defensive Linemen and Linebackers Risers and Fallers
The NFL Scouting Combine always reshapes draft boards, and this year's defensive line and linebacker workouts created clear movement among prospects. Athletic testing, positional drills, and movement efficiency helped several defenders elevate their stock, while others left...