Richard Sherman was not on the list.
He was the first cornerback to receive honorable mention, though, indicating that he just missed the top 10.
"How smart he is makes up for the physical limitations at this stage," said one NFL executive. "If he doesn't win at the line, he can struggle with instant separators, in-breaking stuff. Or if hit vertically, can be tough to recover. But from a ball skills standpoint and football instincts, toughness, tackling, still one of the best."
Sherman's overall Pro Football Focus grade of 88.9 was the second-highest of his career and his best mark since 2012, his second season in the league. He racked up 61 tackles, three interceptions, a touchdown, and 11 passes defensed through 15 starts in 2019, according to Pro Football Reference.
Unsurprising to most, Stephon Gilmore of the New England Patriots came in at the No. 1 spot on Fowler's list. The cornerback was a popular pick among our staff, which was recently asked to identify one non-quarterback who they would pluck from another team for one season to help San Francisco win Super Bowl LV.
Byron Jones of the Miami Dolphins earned the final spot in ESPN's list of the top 10 cornerbacks.
"A voting logjam at 10 made this difficult," notes Fowler, "but Jones separated from Richard Sherman and third-year corners Jaire Alexander and Denzel Ward. The former Dallas Cowboy's man-coverage traits are among the best."
Sherman, 32, is a five-time Pro Bowl selection and three-time first-team All-Pro. He is entering his third season with the 49ers and the final year of the deal he signed in 2018.
The Seattle Seahawks made Sherman a fifth-round pick out of Stanford in 2011. He spent seven seasons in Seattle before signing with division-rival San Francisco.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
ESPN ranks 49ers' offensive playmakers among NFL's top five
On paper, the San Francisco 49ers may trail the Los Angeles Rams in overall roster talent, with many viewing the Rams as the early favorite to win Super Bowl LXI. However, when it comes to offensive playmakers, head coach Kyle Shanahan's roster still ranks among the NFL's... -
Several 49ers land in Prisco's Top 100 NFL Players of 2026 list
Longtime CBS Sports scribe Pete Prisco released his Top 100 NFL Players of 2026 list, which he shares annually. Six San Francisco 49ers earned spots on the ranking. Leading the way for the 49ers is star linebacker Fred Warner, who continues to be regarded as one of the NFL's... -
Do the 49ers have the best quarterback room in the NFC? One NFL analyst believes so
For years, the San Francisco 49ers have been defined by elite offensive playmakers, Kyle Shanahan's offensive system, and a defense built to win championships. But heading into the 2026 season, one NFL analyst believes the biggest strength on the roster may be sitting in the... -
49ers still ranked top trade suitor for Maxx Crosby
The San Francisco 49ers could still benefit from adding a proven veteran pass rusher after finishing with an NFL-low 20 sacks last season. While there's no indication that the Las Vegas Raiders are actively shopping defensive end Maxx Crosby, there was previously a deal in...