Garoppolo's resume as a starter, which includes just seven games, is not as extensive as the two quarterbacks above him. Wilson has started every game for Seattle since being drafted by the team in 2012. He has accumulated four Pro Bowl selections and a Super Bowl championship along the way. Goff has started 22 games since Los Angeles made him the first-overall pick in 2016 and led the Rams to a playoff appearance last season.
Garoppolo has been impressive in his limited number of starts, including a five-game winning streak to end last season with the 49ers. He is preparing to enter his first full season as a franchise quarterback after San Francisco secured him with a five-year deal this offseason.
The only quarterback ranked below Garoppolo within the list was Sam Bradford of the Arizona Cardinals.
"We've got a huge sample size with Sam Bradford, not a huge sample size from Jimmy Garoppolo," said O'Hara. "I really like his accuracy, and I like his understanding of the defense and how to work the offense ... He could end up being a little bit higher (within the ranking) depending on how the season goes."
"Jimmy's got a big-time upside," Carr added. "Super excited to see what he does."
Carr had Garoppolo at No. 10 in a recent top-10 NFL quarterback ranking. Unlike the ranking by O'Hara and Carr, Goff was not included within the latter's top-10 list while Wilson was ranked at No. 5. Nor was Goff listed among the quarterbacks who just missed the list – like Ben Roethlisberger of the Pittsburgh Steelers.
"Garoppolo instantly changed the feel of the season for a 49ers team that didn't get its first win until Week 10," wrote Carr in his earlier ranking. "This is a prove-it season for him."
O'Hara and Carr's NFC West quarterback ranking
- Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks
- Jared Goff, Los Angeles Rams
- Jimmy Garoppolo, San Francisco 49ers
- Sam Bradford, Arizona Cardinals
You can watch O'Hara and Carr break down film of each quarterback, including Garoppolo, here.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
ESPN ranks 49ers' offensive playmakers among NFL's top five
On paper, the San Francisco 49ers may trail the Los Angeles Rams in overall roster talent, with many viewing the Rams as the early favorite to win Super Bowl LXI. However, when it comes to offensive playmakers, head coach Kyle Shanahan's roster still ranks among the NFL's... -
49ers' Brock Purdy addresses tough NFC West, Rams clash in Australia, George Kittle's recovery
Competing in a loaded NFC West won't be easy for the San Francisco 49ers. The team finished third in the division last season, behind the eventual Super Bowl LX champion Seattle Seahawks and the Los Angeles Rams, widely viewed as the Super Bowl LXI favorite entering... -
Do the 49ers have the best quarterback room in the NFC? One NFL analyst believes so
For years, the San Francisco 49ers have been defined by elite offensive playmakers, Kyle Shanahan's offensive system, and a defense built to win championships. But heading into the 2026 season, one NFL analyst believes the biggest strength on the roster may be sitting in the... -
Why Hall of Fame predictions are tricky—and which 49ers are on track
In a recent ESPN article on soon-to-be market-setting contracts, Bill Barnwell calls Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson a "future Hall of Famer." While that might be true—Jackson is a superstar—that phrase is thrown around way too often. Before I get started, let me iterate:...