The 49ers were winless when the decision was made to trade for Garoppolo. The team had options at the position during the upcoming offseason. It was headed toward a high draft pick, and there was the connection between Shanahan and impending free agent quarterback Kirk Cousins. Lynch and Shanahan publicly admitted this offseason that the 49ers' master plan was always to acquire Cousins.
Garoppolo just kind of fell into the 49ers' laps.
Nothing was being handed to Garoppolo following the trade. He was in San Francisco to prove himself to Lynch and Shanahan. It was an audition. What was it about Garoppolo that eventually made choosing him more desirable over the other options?
"I think you go back to when we made the trade," Lynch said Tuesday on The Mighty 1090. "One of the things Kyle and I committed to then was, 'Hey, this is too good an offer to turn down, and we both think highly (of Garoppolo).' We had just, that offseason, tried to trade for Jimmy. So we obviously thought highly of his talent. We didn't know him personally. Kyle had been around him a little coming out of Eastern Illinois.
"But one thing we decided when we made that trade is: 'The rest of the world is going to think we're committing to him long term. We're bringing him in to see what he's got. Let's make that commitment to each other that that's all we're doing.'
"So we did that, and I think having said that, Kyle was extremely patient in making sure that we were setting Jimmy up for success. He had been in New England, apprenticed under Tom Brady, and all of that, but they played a completely different offense, different verbiage, the way they call things.
"And so Jimmy gets here mid-year. It would have been really easy just to say, 'Hey man, you're playing. We're going to figure it out as we go.' But instead, Kyle said, 'Let's give this guy time to at least be able to go out there and have success, set him up for success.'
"We waited four or five weeks, and he worked tirelessly, and I think that was a big part of it. We knew the talent. This guy was blessed with the ability to throw the football very effectively, and athleticism, and a lot of the qualities, the traits in terms of the talent aspect that you want out of a quarterback. But what we really saw during that time is how diligent and how determined he was to learn a system mid-stream, how his teammates reacted to him.
"I always think the greatest mark of a great player, a great leader, is you make people around you better. He made our entire organization better. And with that, was there some faith because he's only had seven starts in his lifetime? Sure. But we felt good enough about it to go make a commitment to him, and we're thrilled that we did."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers QB Mac Jones on likelihood of a trade: "Anything's possible"
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones is entering the 2026 season amid lingering questions about his future. Still, the organization has made it clear it wants him to remain on the roster under the two-year deal he signed last year. Still, league chatter suggested a... -
Maxx Crosby Trade: 49ers Reportedly 'Nuclear Hot'
Trading for Crosby to pair with Bosa would fix the 49ers' pass rush, but it's a bold win-now gamble counter to San Francisco's recent roster strategy. The San Francisco 49ers are "nuclear hot" to trade for Las Vegas Raiders edge rusher Maxx Crosby, Raiders on SI reporter Hondo... -
49ers nightmare? Schefter fuels Aaron Donald unretirement buzz
As if watching their NFC West rivals, the Los Angeles Rams, acquire Myles Garrett wasn't concerning enough, the San Francisco 49ers may soon have another reason to worry. Since landing Garrett, speculation has grown that retired defensive tackle Aaron Donald could make a... -
49ers fans take note: NFL insider warns 'the 18-game slate is coming'
San Francisco 49ers fans would undoubtedly welcome another opportunity each season to watch their favorite team take the field. According to one NFL insider, that extra game is likely on the horizon—it's simply a matter of when the league and players can agree on the...