Do Not Wait To Celebrate This

Dec 6, 2011 at 5:15 PM

In theory, of course, this was no big deal.

For weeks now, the NFC West had been in the bag. It still was one of the league's worst divisions, and the Rams were one of the league's worst teams. So we beat the Rams, and we clinched the division, along with the playoffs. No surprise, and according to Jed York, nothing that's worthy of hullabaloo. "Sometimes celebrating this early isn't always a good thing," he warned. "We haven't won anything yet. ... You have to keep your head down and keep working, or else this doesn't mean anything."

Naturally, I commend Jed for his refusal to be satisfied. Winning the West isn't much of an achievement, especially for this franchise. Even for this season, despite eight years of misery, the bar already was set much higher.

Yet I can't help but think that Jed overdid the whole "eyes on the prize" thing. This is a cause for true celebration. Not so much for what it is--the championship of a crummy division--as for the greater achievement that it represents.

The 49ers' official rebirth.

First let's dispense with this notion that the crumminess of our division is itself a source of diminishment. As a certain writer once explained: "The crumminess of this division should be celebrated, not begrudged. After all, in our glory years, that crumminess was one of our most underrated boons. Remember when the NFC 'West' contained the Rams, Falcons, and Saints, all of whom stunk to high heaven? In the 14 years of our Super Bowl dynasty, the Rams were .500 or worse 8 times, the Saints 9 times, and the Falcons an astounding 12 times. Our own teams were pretty good, of course, but let's face it. Winning at least 10 games every one of those years--except the year in which fewer than 10 games were played--was a whole lot easier when we played 6 a year with the dregs of the league.

We didn't apologize for it then. And we shouldn't apologize for it now."

It's funny. I wrote that more than two years ago, after a shutout win against the Rams gave us what looked like an early stranglehold on the division. I guess I jumped the gun there. But the point was valid enough. Our rebirth isn't minimized by the crumminess of our division; our rebirth is confirmed by the fact that we dominate it.

And yet, really, that's just the beginning.

Earlier in the week, with exquisite timing, the Niners announced that they had secured the funding they needed for their own billion-dollar amusement park in Santa Clara. It goes without saying that the now-inevitable move to the south is more than just a tad controversial. Though no one would seriously contend that the Yorks' move is akin to, say, Art Modell's, it's undeniably a little sad. (Given the mind-blowing numbers involved, it's also likely a little risky, but I'll leave such details to politicians and economists.) The crucial facts, however, are these. The Niners desperately need a new building, and they've needed it for decades; the Yorks gave San Francisco a fair chance, if not an exclusive one, to get its act together; and they showed an uncommon commitment to the Bay Area, when they had every right to go somewhere else. (They might've been hunted down like dogs, but they still had the right.) And thus, with this announcement, those publicity stills look like more than science-fiction. They look, instead, like home, at last.

In the same week that Trent Baalke and Jim Harbaugh delivered a playoff berth--which promises to be the first of many--the Yorks delivered a Bay Area stadium worthy of one of the league's crown jewels.

That's a good week. A week that's worthy of true celebration.

And the milestones didn't even stop there. As if the mood wasn't effusive enough, Frank Gore became the Niners' all-time rushing leader. It's somewhat odd that a representative of such an otherwise dismal era would achieve such a prominent status, but then again, those years of losing only enhance Gore's achievement. Despite his two reconstructed ACLs--and despite picking up various other injuries while being driven into the ground--he's given his maximum effort on each and every single rush. And even as he was running repeatedly into a wall of humanity, he never bitched, never complained. He merely asked for the ball again, trusting that one day he'd play for a winner.

Harbaugh's statue might be a bit much. These statues now have become almost trite, and in any event, the Niners should bronze a dozen guys before they get around to Gore. But there's no denying it: of those who deserve to celebrate this playoff berth, Gore is at the top of the list.

On the other hand, maybe he's second.

Many observers have settled on Alex Smith as our QB of the future. I myself am not quite there, though it was awfully tempting to go all-in when he joined the festivities by putting up a career-best passer rating, with two perfect touchdown bombs (one of which, alas, was dropped). But the bigger point is this. Despite the eternal debate about Smith's abilities, no one can question the man's resilience. Through insult and injury--indeed, through public vilification expressly directed at his destruction--he simply refused to ever give in. He easily could've joined the list of first-round burnouts who've drifted into obscurity, but instead he did what so many of us would hope we could summon the power to do. In the face of a seemingly endless struggle...he just kept going.

No matter what Smith's future holds, he deserves this playoff chance. And he deserves to celebrate it.

And so, of course, do we.

Talk about resilience. Niner fans have been through so much. Okay, maybe we were spoiled by those trips to the playoffs, year after year. But these last eight years, of hopes raised and hopes dashed, have just been torture. Each one a mocking reminder of our winning past, which seemed to be fading into oblivion.

We got restless, of course, and maybe even a little snippy. But we never quit. We stuck it out, holding out hope that we'd retake our place on the postseason stage, not just once but perennially. Hope that we'd be, indeed, reborn.

That rebirth is official now. By all means, guys: Keep your heads down. Keep working. (And please, get in the end zone a little more often.)

But forgive us, Jed, for celebrating early.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • louie
    This season has been a gift from the football gods, but the 49ers "are who we thought they were". Harbaugh (and his staff) are great, but his quarterback and his team isn't there yet.
    Dec 12, 2011 at 7:58 PM
  • AJ Dembroski
    Solid stuff, Jeff. I shall now lay off the Smith stuff, you've given him an unqualified complimentary paragraph. That's all I've ever asked ;) Well, you could incorporate some colons, but I won't harp on that too much :P In all seriousness, good stuff. Thanks for all your hard work.
    Dec 7, 2011 at 7:53 PM
  • Steve
    Jeff, In reading several of your pieces on this site, it's evident that you and I share some of the exact same views on this team. Couldn't have said it better myself. It's a long-awaited thrill to finally exhale after an 8-year postseason dearth.
    Dec 7, 2011 at 6:21 PM
    Response: You know it, Steve. Thanks for checking in.
  • Bill
    CRITIC! Kidding. Very good Mr. Kaplan. Very good.
    Dec 7, 2011 at 2:01 PM
    Response: Whew!
  • NinerTico
    Jeff, well said. We as fans can enjoy the moment while the players prepare further toward the ultimate goal. I applaud your POV here. We may disagree on many points, but it pleases me to agree here. Too many times alternate POV can lead to cracks in the Niner family. Nice to know the Niners Bros can agree and enjoy what's been a long time coming. Thanks Jeff for what you do. We meet, beer on me. BTW, great article. :)
    Dec 6, 2011 at 10:07 PM
    Response: Sounds good, Tico.
  • Quadrupal Bypass
    If you have an erection that lasts longer than four hours .... Call a doctor. Go Niners!
    Dec 6, 2011 at 8:41 PM
  • overthemiddle
    Jeff I couldn't believe you said that either. There is a difference between being negative and being critical. I consider myself to be an experienced optimist, I always look at the positive side but thru many experiences I know s--t happens. Need you to stay critical, not negative and not mean. For instance we have some issues that you aren't addressing. First - penalties, once again two stupid ones, dropped passes, and the most important is why we aren't scoring touchdowns in the red zone. We can win in the playoffs, but we won't if these issues are not taken care of, playoff teams thrive on their opponents' weakness. Come on man!
    Dec 6, 2011 at 8:01 PM
    Response: I hear you, OTM. And I share your concerns, really I do. But this week I just felt like appreciating the end of a truly horrific playoff drought. Rest assured, though: if those issues persist, we will address them, in gruesome detail.
  • Lucky Phil
    Another nice article, Jeff. And even though I agree with you about A. Smith's future with the team, you can't deny this is a man who plays with three testicles. Tough, Tough, Tough! I'm happy you gave him his props. I think A. Smith deserves a lot of credit for the success of this team. The jury is still out on whether he can score enough points to get us to the SB, but he has shown a lot of heart and skill this year. I'm happy for his success, but I don't know if I want to be looking at this guy next year. The defense is exciting to watch, but the offense .... kinda like watching a Giants (baseball) game.
    Dec 6, 2011 at 7:54 PM
  • Rudolph Frimmel
    A little saccharin but I enjoyed reading because of it. We deserve a little sweetness after the last 8 years.
    Dec 6, 2011 at 6:48 PM
  • Ryan
    Jeff, I had a jug of Kool-Aid a few weeks ago, but I think it's done now. Mix another one for us please, bro. Because i'm sure you had quite a few glasses yourself! I think we need to keep improving and go and WIN IT ALL. #Faithful
    Dec 6, 2011 at 6:28 PM
  • Johnny
    Jeff, nice article. It's great that we have won the division. To be honest i see us going in and being embarrassed after the first game. Good teams, championship teams, find ways to score when they have 1st and goal from inside the 5. Alex looked better as he has been improving and shame on VD for dropping that dime. But we played a bad team and had to settle for field goals too often. If we are going to have a chance to win a playoff game against anyone, our defense will have to outscore the opposing offense because our offense is allergic to the endzone apparently. For the D getting a turnover inside the 5 isn't enough, they will have to score at least twice for us if we are going to advance in the postseason. I'm prepping for embarrassment because that's what will happen with this offense that continues to regress. BTW how could we have so many delay of games this late in the season?? That's another thing championship teams don't do. We are a good team but nowhere near a GREAT team and far far from a championship team.
    Dec 6, 2011 at 5:41 PM
    Response: I think you're being a bit too negative, Johnny. (Good lord, did I really just say that?) I agree with the conventional wisdom that our defense will keep us from getting blown out, even by the Packers or Saints. But there's no doubt: to have a chance to beat those teams, we MUST get sevens instead of threes. We need red-zone improvements in both playcalling and execution. But there's time, Johnny. Don't lose hope for bigger things.
  • kerry brown
    boy you put that as sweet as it can get! i agree 100%
    Dec 6, 2011 at 5:38 PM
  • DAN
    Dec 6, 2011 at 5:35 PM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers-Colts: Kyle Shanahan optimistic Jimmy Garoppolo will play; Trey Lance may have to wait a week

By David Bonilla
Oct 20

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke with reporters before today's practice. He informed the media that quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo would be practicing but be limited. Rookie Trey Lance won't practice as he continues to recover from his injury. "It will be good to go out there and be full-go today," Shanahan said of Garoppolo. "I know he's limited because we've got to make sure he can do everything. We'll have a much better idea today, but I'm pretty optimistic about it." Garoppolo is returning from a calf injury suffered in a game against the Seattle Seahawks on October 3. Lance replaced the veteran quarterback in the game and then started the following weekend against the Arizona Cardinals, sustaining a knee sprain. The rookie quarterback's

49ers' Jimmy Garoppolo on calf injury: 'I feel it, but it's not hindering me at all'

By David Bonilla
Oct 24

Jimmy Garoppolo missed Week 5 with a calf injury suffered a week earlier. He returned on Sunday night against the Indianapolis Colts but delivered a sloppy performance on a rain-soaked Levi's Stadium field. Garoppolo finished the game 16-of-27 for 181 yards, a touchdown, and two interceptions. While the outing looked like it might be enough to tempt the 49ers to at least consider a quarterback change this week, head coach Kyle Shanahan said he "would guess" Garoppolo remains the starter. It wasn't exactly a confidence-inspiring response. Garoppolo admits that his calf isn't at 100 percent yet, but the quarterback didn't use the injury as an excuse

Brian Baldinger on 49ers' Jimmy Garoppolo: 'He's just not good enough'

By Marc Adams
8 hrs

Ask fans of the San Francisco 49ers to evaluate current starting quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, and you will probably get an array of responses that lean heavy to the side of disdain. For the organization that once replaced one Hall of Fame quarterback with another, modern-day 49ers fans have had a love-hate (mostly hate) relationship with their team's quarterbacks. Even former Pro Bowl quarterback, Jeff Garcia, felt the fans' wrath, at times. But since then, it's been a steady stream of underachieving signal callers. So Garoppolo isn't the first San Francisco quarterback that fans have wanted to chase out of town with pitch forks and torches (cue the angry mob music). But fans hope...and so do the 49ers coaches and front office, that he will be the last. Right now


More by Jeff Kaplan

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone