No Huddle: 49ers Stay Undefeated Behind Their Offensive Stars →

They Are Who We Thought They Were

Sep 20, 2010 at 10:21 PM

Yes, the story of the evening is that the 49ers beat themselves. The two turnovers that hurt the most were Delanie Walker's fumble and Phillip Adams' muffed punt. I'm sure Matt Maiocco and Matt Barrows will ever so artfully expound upon how the 49ers turned the ball over 3 times inside the Saints' 30 yard-line and ultimately lost the game.

But that's not what I want to talk about.

I want to talk about Frank Gore's 112 yards on 20 carries. I want to talk about Anthony Dixon waltzing into the end zone on third and goal from the 2-yard line. I want to talk about Frank Gore establishing himself as one of the most prolific running backs in 49ers history, passing Joe Perry on the list of 100-yard games (21).

The 49ers played true to the identity they wanted to forge against the Saints. They ran the ball effectively against an average, if not ball-hawking defense. Frank Gore averaged 5.6 yards-per-carry on 20 attempts. And the offensive line protected Smith, as they didn't allow a sack all game.

Alex Smith played an efficient game simply because the running game was working. The play-action pass was available nearly all evening. The Saints asked Smith to beat them with his arm, and he obliged.

Sure, there were a few times when the Saints rushed only three players and Smith had trouble finding the open man against an 8-man zone. The Saints either typically rush three players or come with a blitz and Smith was able to beat the blitz with well-timed throws to the open receiver. Greg Williams, the Saints defensive coordinator, took his foot off the throttle late when Smith more often than not beat the blitz.

Let's not forget the final drive when Alex Smith showed that he can be a legitimate starting quarterback in the NFL.

After this Monday night the 49ers showed that "they are who we thought they were." It's too bad that team finally showed up in week 2 as opposed to week one.

This team isn't going to take the NFL by storm. They need to get a handle on the fundamentals (for instance, snapping the ball or holding onto the ball inside the opponent's 30-yard line). But at the very least - even in a loss - they righted the ship and seemingly got pointed in the right direction.

Now if they could only stay consistent from week to week as opposed to being as manic as Lindsey Lohan near white powdery substances they might just fulfill their expectations this year.
I know it seems like this is a game where Niner fans can claim a moral victory. This is not what I am doing. I am identifying a team that, in some regards, finally played to expectations. Moral victories are for losers, and I think the 49ers might agree. Check out the post-game comments
[quote=Mike Singletary]I don't ever, ever want to say that I think we should have won a football game. If we should have, then we should have won. I mean, it's unfortunate. Our guys played, but the last thing I'm going to say is we should have won. They hung in there, they're world champions from last year. They did the things they had to do to win the game. So they deserve to win the game.
[quote=Alex Smith]I mean, in the end, it's a loss just like last week. Lose by one, or lose by whatever - it doesn't matter. Some things to take away from it, but still killing ourselves.
If this was a game of moral victories Sing's cross hanging from his neck might be enough to win us the division. The reality is at the NFL is about wins and losses and until the 49ers can get over their own mistakes, it will be a roller coaster season.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Johnny
    I was happy I actually had something to cheer about! Ok so we lost, theres no shame in losing in the final seconds to the best team in the NFL. Could we have won without the mistakes? Yes! of course. However, they were mistakes that I beleive we'll learn from. We have seen ASmith have good games here and there. Not consistent. Although, I've never seen him engineer a legit fourth quarter drive like that with the game on the line. He actually looked like a QB, that's major improvement on his part. Kudos to the O-line, they played pretty darn well! No one has mentioned Jimmy Raye, I'm impressed with him pulling his head out, and actually throwing the football! I am much more optomistic today than I was last week, that's for sure. Fix that special teams, and slap DWalker for holding the ball like a loaf of bread! Those two things should help
    Sep 21, 2010 at 12:10 PM
  • v7i7c
    The biggest takeaway for me from this game was that our reshuffled OL, including our two rookies, played pretty dang well. When Heitman gets back and players can return to their normal positions, we're gonna' be in shape.
    Sep 21, 2010 at 9:12 AM
    Response: Snyder might be an upgrade over Rachal.
  • ragomez3
    Thank you, thank you, thank you for not being a Negative Nancy, a Debbie Downer, a Sad Sindy or a Pitiful Petunia. I thought we fought with courage, our defense played out of their minds and ASmith showed why he IS a starting quarterback in the NFL. Our O-line is mauling people, we are picking up the blitz and PWillis is All-World. FGore started his career as a so-called 'fumbler' - but he put in the time to correct it. We, as a team, just need to do the same and then we will be among the elite teams in this league. Again, thank you. I often like to talk about football, not women.
    Sep 21, 2010 at 6:01 AM
  • James
    Well said. Not to be a Negative Nancy, but if it weren't for that first "drive", well..... We didn't right the ship until it was one game and one drive too late. Either way, I am 1000% more optimistic about the season after this game even though we are 0-2. You didn't mention the sacks we got, which leads me to my next point. Our injured guys are only going to make us better when they come back. Ahmad Brooks is one example so far, and Eric Heitman will hopefully be the next. Ginn would be nice too since Crabtree is no longer worthy of targets.
    Sep 20, 2010 at 11:00 PM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Kyle Shanahan on 49ers defense: "I thought they had a couple lapses"

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Oct 1

The San Francisco 49ers improved to 4-0 with a 35-16 victory over the Arizona Cardinals, primarily due to a phenomenal offensive performance where Brock Purdy and Co. scored touchdowns on five of the team's six drives during the game. Additionally, the defense did just enough, with Javon Hargrave securing the 49ers the win with a crucial third down sack to thwart the Cardinals' offensive momentum, to which the offense responded with consecutive touchdown drives. However, after the game, head coach Kyle Shanahan was transparent about the 49ers' defense, sharing his belief that they had some ups and downs. "I thought they had a couple lapses," Shanahan said. "They started out real strong. We had that missed kickoff, I think they got them at the 40,

Kyle Shanahan reveals 49ers contract extensions were finalized before the season

By David Bonilla
Sep 27

Last week, the San Francisco 49ers announced they had signed head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch to multi-year contract extensions, keeping the team's brain trust together for the foreseeable future. However, Shanahan revealed that the deals had been finalized for a while. "We did it before the Pittsburgh game (Week 1), so I had already celebrated with my family and stuff like that, which is huge," Shanahan told reporters on Wednesday. "I feel very grateful just being a coach anywhere for a long time. I know what that means, and I'm extremely grateful for that, to have that opportunity, and mainly for my family to be somewhere for so long, which is cool." The extensions had nothing to do with the 49ers' 3-0 start to the 2023 season. That's


More by Oscar Aparicio

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone