An Almost Painless Journey through the Niners’ Decade Lost

Jan 12, 2010 at 6:15 AM

By the turn of the millennium, the San Francisco 49ers had gotten used to dominating decades. In the 1980s, led by Hall of Fame quarterback Joe Montana, the Niners had won four Super Bowls. In the '90s, led by Hall of Fame quarterback Steve Young, the Niners had set a record for wins in a decade--since broken in the '00s by the Colts--and added a fifth Super Bowl title. Put those decades together, and you've got the longest run of sustained excellence in the history of professional sports.

Alas, as the world was celebrating the dawn of a new age, the Niners were grieving for the death of their dynasty. With a final shot to the head, Young's career had come to a sudden end, and he was replaced by Jeff Garcia, a scrawny unknown. More ominously, Eddie DeBartolo, the managing owner whose passion and spending were the catalysts for those years of glory, had been exiled in the wake of a bribery scandal, and he was replaced by his brother-in-law, John York, who reportedly was far more interested in making a buck than in winning a title.

After those decades of dominance, the '00s were looking to exact a little revenge.

And in brutal fashion, that's exactly what they did.


Oh, we didn't surrender, at least initially. Indeed, as bleak as things looked going into the decade, we found immediate hope, a reason to believe we might keep it all going. Under the tutelage of head coach and notorious quarterback-wrangler Steve Mariucci, Garcia came out of nowhere to be one of the league's best. Brilliantly executing Marty Mornhinweg's third-generation West Coast Offense, Garcia grabbed the Niners' quarterbacking legacy and promptly beat it into submission. For nearly 20 years, either Montana or Young was the Niners' top guy. And in his very first year in that pressurized role, Garcia threw for more yards in a season (4,278, along with 31 touchdowns) than either of those legends ever did. On the receiving end for 1,451 of those yards and 13 of those scores was Terrell Owens, who was entrenched as the league's most dominant (if mercurial) wideout. Add in the 1,142 yards gained by running back Charlie Garner, who greatly outperformed his status as a desperate replacement, and the Niners emerged with the league's fourth-best offense. Granted, that shocking success was undermined by a 29th-ranked D that was still in tatters from the salary-cap purges of the late '90s, and we finished a lowly 6 and 10. But there was no doubt in our minds. The football fates might've been trying to send us into oblivion, but the fates were in for some disappointment. After a stunningly quick rebuilding process, we'd be back.


And we WERE back, even more quickly than that. In 2001, we announced our return, in thrilling fashion. Despite losing Mornhinweg, the offense didn't miss a beat, with Garcia throwing for 3,538 yards and 32 scores, Owens catching for 1,412 and 16, and Garrison Hearst once again proving his indomitable will by returning to run for 1,206. But this year, taking advantage of a long-overdue infusion of young talent, the defense made a huge jump, all the way to 13th. At 12 and 4, we were one of the bigger surprises in the NFL, but the record didn't do justice to a season where seemingly everything went right. Sure, there were suffocating blowouts, such as our late-season beatings of Buffalo, Miami, and New Orleans by a combined score of 94 to nothing. But just as spectacular were our breathtaking escapes, such as our three wins in overtime, including one that featured a touchdown (naturally on a pass from Garcia to Owens) and a two-point conversion with one second left on the fourth-quarter clock.

We were back, all right. Unfortunately, though, in the same division as the "Greatest Show" Rams, 12 wins were good enough for only a wild-card spot, and to make matters worse, we were shipped to Green Bay, where Brett Favre was waiting with that special heartbreak he seems to reserve only for us.

Still, there was no reason to think the '00s would be any different from the '80s and '90s.


In '02, though, things began to change. Though both went to the Pro Bowl for the third straight year, Garcia's efficiency and explosiveness seemed to drop, and Owens was more and more of a clubhouse distraction. Still, the Rams faded out, allowing us to win the division for the first time in five years. And that achievement was followed by a game that sits comfortably in Niners lore alongside anything produced in the dynasty years. Down 38-14 in the third quarter against the Giants, the Niners scored the game's last 25 points to finish off the second-greatest comeback in postseason history. With nothing left for the eventual champion Bucs the next week, that game stands as the highpoint of a decade that was about to see us completely collapse.

You've gotta pity Steve Mariucci. All he'd done was go from six wins to a division title in only two years, and it seemed like everyone wanted him fired. York thought Mariucci was negotiating with Notre Dame and the Buccaneers to try to pry a contract extension out of York. (It didn't help that Mariucci had been hired by Eddie, whom York evidently despised.) General manager Terry Donahue thought Mariucci was after the GM's authority. (An odd concern, since Donahue's primary interest in the job appeared to be its liberal vacation schedule.) And bunches of vocal fans, not yet knowing what REAL suffering was, were disgusted by Mariucci's so-called lack of "killer instinct," most recently exhibited in the playoff loss, when--much to Owens' visible displeasure--the coach elected to run out the first-half clock after his offense had just shown its first sign of life.

So Mariucci was fired. But given what was to come, maybe he doesn't need pity at all.


Donahue appeared to have no one in mind. After an uninspiring process involving uninspiring coaches, Donahue set his sights on his old stomping grounds--the Pac-10--and brought in Dennis Erickson. While certainly a surprise, Erickson at least had a record of success, and his promise of a more aggressive offense with a more vertical passing game was music to the ears of the fans who'd demanded Mariucci's demise. But those plans never even got off the ground; Garcia injured his back on the eve of training camp, and he endured just a miserable season. Despite starting off with a delightful pasting of the Bears, we heartlessly finished at seven and nine, the first in a streak of non-winning years that continues to this very day.


The "Donahue purge," at the end of '03, is where the bottom dropped out. With the Niners a seemingly permanent resident of salary-cap hell, Donahue devised a bold (and very risky) plan. He'd get rid of almost every bit of his veteran talent, he'd replace it with young guys, and by the time those young guys developed, he'd have himself a healthy team both on the field and in the wallet. He warned us it wouldn't be pretty--he used the phrase "taking our medicine"--but he assured us the plan was in place.

The timing seemed right. Garcia looked to be on his last legs, and despite a couple of nice years in Tampa he hardly went on to rejoin the elite. Owens was totally unmanageable, and he went on to prove it at two other stops. Hearst as well was winding down, and one year later he was out of the league. So no, it wasn't that Donahue blew it by shedding all his veteran talent. He blew it with his young guys, who largely had no talent at all.

Donahue had been handpicked by Bill Walsh himself. The great architect of the Niners' dynasty, in his second tour as the team's GM, supposedly taught Donahue everything he knew about building a franchise through shrewd player evaluation. (Of course, his second tour showed he wasn't nearly as shrewd as he'd been in his first.) But whereas Walsh's brilliant drafting was what got us off the ground, Donahue's utter incompetence was what drove us back into it.

The 2002 draft was the first with Donahue fully in charge, and it ranks among the worst drafts ever, certainly by the Niners, perhaps by anyone else. Corner Mike Rumph, who famously didn't allow a touchdown pass in his entire career at Miami, looked as a pro like he'd never played the game before, and he was out of the league in five years. Linebacker Saleem Rasheed, whose religion forced him to go part of the season without eating, was out of the league in FOUR years. And so it went: kicker Jeff Chandler, retired in three years; safety Kevin Curtis, injured and gone immediately; quarterback Brandon Doman, retired in three years; and DT Josh Shaw and tight end Mark Anelli, off the team by '04. Finally in the seventh round, Donahue backed into versatile offensive lineman Eric Heitmann, who became one of the Niners' best players of the decade and is still going strong today. A bit late for a draft to yield a good pick, though, and a total disaster for a team on the brink of a youth movement.

With that draft and two more going into '04--and with Donahue's other first-rounders, OT Kwame Harris and receiver Rashaun Woods, joining Mike Rumph in a stunning trifecta of busts--the stage was set for a collapse of epic proportions. The '04 Niners were easily the worst since before Walsh arrived and are somewhere among the worst teams of all time. Splitting quarterback starts between fringe players Tim Rattay and Ken Dorsey, we ranked 30th in points, 32nd in points allowed, and we were the first team ever to go winless in regulation in a 16-game season. Save for two overtime field goals, both for some reason against Arizona, we'd have beaten Detroit to historic perfection.

Proving he had some semblance of conscience, John York stepped up and fired Donahue and Erickson, putting a serious dent in his image as a tightfisted cheapskate. But the damage had been done. Two years after firing Mariucci in the wake of a division title, the Niners were reduced to the level of an expansion team. And if the history of expansion teams indicated anything, the road back this time would NOT be quick.


In many ways, Mike Nolan was York's perfect choice. As the coordinator of the Ravens' famous defense, Nolan was certainly a hot commodity. But also, his father, Dick Nolan, was a successful Niners coach in the '70s, before DeBartolo came along. This allowed York to have it both ways. He could tap into the Niners' history, and thus show his respect for it, without tapping into EDDIE'S history, which despite its success he didn't seem to respect at all. And so Mike Nolan as coach, with Scot McCloughan his handpicked personnel guru, was chosen to lead us out of the darkness.

Nolan didn't have long to wait before he'd face his defining decision. The consolation prize for the Niners' miserable '04 season was the very first pick in the '05 draft. The top pick is usually spent on a franchise quarterback, which we desperately needed. But in keeping with the Niners' dwindling luck, it was doubtful that any was there to be had. Carson Palmer was a can't-miss in '03; so was Eli Manning in '04. In '05, though, there was no such choice. Nolan was willing to trade the pick, but no one even made him an offer. He had nowhere to go. His only choice was to take a risk.

The only two viable contenders were Utah's Alex Smith and Cal's Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers perhaps was the safer choice; his arm was stronger, and having played in a pro-style offense in college, he was better prepared to make a quick impact. (Although Smith was a Heisman finalist after leading the Utes to an undefeated season, he played in an option offense, almost entirely out of the shotgun.) But Nolan was drawn to Smith, praising his work ethic, leadership, and intellect. Nolan also was impressed by how Smith handled a rigorous workout administered by offensive coordinator Mike McCarthy, and he went so far as to note "little things" like how Smith called his mother "ma'am."

So Nolan chose Smith, saying the decision was easy in the end. As if to validate it, Rodgers dropped to the 24th pick, where the Packers chose him to be Favre's apprentice. Ironically, after the '05 season, McCarthy would become Rodgers' coach in Green Bay, and in '09, starting for only the second year, Rodgers would go to the Pro Bowl.

The road for Smith wouldn't be nearly as smooth.

Not surprisingly, the '05 Niners were bad. Indeed, in one respect we were even worse than '04, as BOTH our offense and defense ranked last. But since Smith had no Favre he could learn from by watching, Nolan decided he'd play. He made seven starts in nine games, and like any rookie on a struggling team, he struggled mightily. He threw only 1 touchdown pass and 11 interceptions, while suffering 29 sacks.

Still, the Niners won their last two games to finish at 4 and 12, and Smith played well in both those wins. We also found a potential star in another rookie, rusher Frank Gore, who broke a hundred yards in the finale.

There'd clearly be no miracle rise, but still we could make out the first signs of hope.


After McCarthy took off for Green Bay, Nolan got lucky. Norv Turner was a lousy head coach, but he was still the same offensive coordinator who'd led the Cowboys to two titles in the '90s. So when the Raiders fired him, Nolan wisely snapped him up. Although the Niners' O, like their D, moved up to rank just 26th, their actual improvement was much more dramatic. Taking every snap, Smith threw for 16 scores and nearly doubled his passer rating. Meanwhile, Gore rushed for a franchise-record 1,695 yards, making the Pro Bowl. There were certainly some lows in '06, such as a 41-nothing pasting in Kansas City and the Chicago game where the Bears led by that score at HALFTIME. But in their last three games, the Niners delivered two stirring wins, in Seattle and Denver. After the finale, which cost the Broncos a playoff spot and raised our record to seven and nine, the locker-room spirit was simply euphoric. We were onto something, and everyone knew it.

And out of the blue, we found ourselves a dark-horse contender. One writer went so far as to forecast a Super Bowl berth. But just as we were almost out of the abyss, the fates made sure to drive us back down.


The Chargers finished '06 with the league's best record. They lost their first playoff game with a dreadful showing against the Patriots, but this was clearly a powerhouse that'd be a contender for years to come. That's why it was so surprising when they fired head coach Marty Schottenheimer. The move was shocking not only because of the Chargers' success, but also because of its timing, in the middle of February when everyone thought the annual coaching carousel had come to a stop. Apparently Schottenheimer and GM A.J. Smith had been trying to work out their mutual differences but couldn't come up with a fix. Someone had to go, and the lower man went. So Smith began to look for a coach, a guy he knew better, a friend. And he found one, in Norv Turner.

The Niners had breathed a collective sigh of relief when Turner had failed to land the Cowboys' head-coaching job earlier in the offseason. Frankly we were surprised he was even a candidate, given his failures in D.C. and Oakland. But we knew how important he was to our rise, and we didn't like other teams sniffing around. In the '00s, though, the Niners only had so much luck. We dodged the Cowboys, but not San Diego, and Turner was gone just as quick as he'd come. (And despite those prior failures, he'd go on to be USA Today's '09 Coach of the Year.)

To make matters worse, it was too late for Nolan to hire a proven replacement, so he turned to his quarterbacks coach, Jim Hostler. Hostler promised an offensive scheme that'd combine elements of Turner's "digit" system and McCarthy's West Coast, which didn't intuitively seem too compatible. But no matter how sound was his abstract design, it couldn't survive his gameday playcalling, which lacked any semblance of creativity or aggression. The offense sank to astonishing depths, ranking last in total yards, last in passing yards, last in yards per play, last in first downs, and, naturally, last in points.

Alex Smith, meanwhile, was completely derailed. In week four, he separated his throwing shoulder, tearing three ligaments. After holding him out for only three weeks, Nolan put him back in for three more. During those games, all losses, it was glaringly obvious Smith wasn't right. When he came out and said so, Nolan responded by doubting his toughness. But tough or no, he was certainly hurt; as the Niners limped to a demoralizing record of 5 and 11, Smith had surgery to repair the torn ligaments. Then, in trying to prepare for the season to come, he mysteriously broke a bone in the same shoulder and wound up missing the entire year.

Smith wouldn't play again until the middle of '09. And by then, Nolan would be long gone.


Once again, the team was in ruins. Naturally, Hostler was fired. Nolan too seemed a dead man walking, but York decided to delay the inevitable; instead of firing Nolan, York promoted McCloughan to general manager, putting McCloughan above the man who'd hired him. Given his last chance, and desperate to bring in a proven offensive coordinator, Nolan elected to hire Mike Martz, late of Detroit. Known as a genius when he ran the O for those "Greatest Show" Rams, Martz was now known as a bit of a madman, continuing to rely almost exclusively on the vertical pass even on teams that were poorly equipped. But Nolan, indeed, was desperate.

The first thing Martz wanted was insurance at quarterback. So when he arrived, he had the Niners go back to Detroit, for J.T. O'Sullivan. O'Sullivan had barely played since joining the league in 2002, but at least he'd studied Martz's playbook. And when Smith went down again, we had our new starter.

With a great quarterback, Martz's O is explosive and dynamic. Without one, it's a turnover waiting to happen, and it was quickly obvious O'Sullivan wasn't great. When he was finally benched halfway through '08, he led the league in both picks and fumbles, with 11 each. In the meantime, though, with his team two and five and going nowhere fast, the ax for Nolan finally fell.

In a way, Nolan's firing was a surprise. The firing itself wasn't surprising, of course. What was surprising instead was the man who announced it. It wasn't John York, and it wasn't McCloughan. It was our new managing owner: Jed York, John's son.

Jed was young, only 27. But he grew up amid the Niners in their glory, and unlike his father, he made no secret of his fan-like obsession with seeing the Niners return to the top. In announcing Nolan's firing, he offered a reassuring promise: "I won't rest until we reestablish a championship culture." We couldn't help but see shades of Eddie, though it remains to be seen whether Jed is more DeBartolo, or more York.

Of course, first he needed an interim coach. Though he had an experienced one in Martz, he was more intrigued by a DIFFERENT member of Nolan's staff. Nolan's right-hand man, Mike Singletary.

Singletary had never been a head coach at any level, but he was considered a rising star, largely because he had the same reputation he'd had as a Hall of Fame player: an intense, fiery motivator. And he didn't wait long to show his reputation was richly deserved. During his first game, a loss to Seattle, he banished tight end Vernon Davis to the locker room, punishing him for his "T.O." demeanor. After the game, the coach delivered a booming sermon, thundering "I want winners!," the first of many such phrases fit to be printed on billboards and T-shirts. For a team that had long been without an identity, Singletary was an immediate solution.

Importantly, though, he didn't just talk. He reined in Martz, looking to win with defense and ball-control, like his old Bears teams did. And to execute that scheme, he replaced O'Sullivan, whose "J.T." had come to stand for "Just Turnovers," with Shaun Hill. Like O'Sullivan, Hill had entered the league in '02 and had barely played, though he'd won a couple of late starts for the Niners in '07. His arm seemed to be strictly backup, but he'd play with guts, protect the ball, and make his new coach look exceedingly smart. With Hill throwing for 13 scores and a rating near 90, and a D that returned to the league's top half, the Niners won five of their last seven games. After the finale, Jed made the seemingly obvious choice. In a euphoric locker room, he took off Singletary's "interim" tag and vowed that we'd missed the playoffs for "the last time." The players exploded with joy, and once again it seemed like we were on the brink of greatness.


Philosophically, Singletary and Martz were like oil and water, so Martz was out, and Singletary went looking for the Niners' seventh offensive coordinator in seven years. The problem was, though Martz's ultra-aggressiveness was out of step with conventional wisdom, so was Singletary's ultra-conservativeness. In a pass-first league, Singletary was a run-first coach, and this made his search look haphazard and strange. He offered the job to Scott Linehan, late of the Rams, but Linehan turned him down, choosing instead the same job with the Lions, who'd gone oh and 16 in 2008. Linehan publicly said he made his decision because of his family's midwest location, but it was widely reported he wasn't excited by Singletary's old-school offensive approach. Singletary went on to consider six others, including Dan Reeves, who'd executed a run-first offense despite having John Elway at quarterback, and who'd been out of the league since 2003. Finally, he settled on an EIGHTH choice, Jimmy Raye. In more than 30 years of coaching, Raye had coordinated 12 offenses, including two for Turner's Raiders. Only one had ranked in the top 10: the 2000 Chiefs, who threw for more than 4,000 yards. So Raye wasn't strictly a run-first guy. For Singletary, though, he was willing to be.

The Niners added to the offensive weirdness by chasing Kurt Warner, who might've been a perfect fit under his old coach Martz, but made considerably less sense after Martz had been fired. Eventually, the quarterback job stayed with Hill, and the Niners won three of their first four games, with the only loss a Brett Favre last-second special. But the Niners' offense was certifiably prehistoric. Time and again, Gore was sent into stacked boxes on first and second downs, setting up third-and-longs that we failed to convert. Finally, after the O was just atrocious in the first half of game six, Singletary made the move to bring back Alex Smith. From then on, the season was marked by offensive schizophrenia. In his debut, Smith ran a shotgun spread like the one he'd run in college, and he was brilliant, throwing for three scores and more than 200 yards in a single half. In subsequent weeks, the spread made token appearances with similar results, but Singletary refused to budge from run-first as his primary scheme. Refused, that is, until players began to complain to the press, at which point he finally gave in. By then, though, the losses had mounted. Despite Jed's promise and Singletary's passion, there'd be no playoffs, yet again.

The Niners won their last two games to finish at eight and eight, and befitting that record, nobody's sure which direction they're going. On the bright side, we've finally got a playoff-worthy D, led by Pro Bowl linebacker Patrick Willis, easily the best of a largely subpar decade of drafts. On the offensive side, there's plenty of skill; Davis matured into a Pro Bowl tight end who tied a record with 13 scores, wideout Michael Crabtree missed five games in a wacky holdout but still was one of the league's top rookies, and Gore became the first Niner rusher to top a thousand yards in four straight years. But it remains to be seen whether Singletary and Raye are creative enough to give that talent its fullest effect, and whether McCloughan is able to fill the holes--particularly on the offensive line--that continue to riddle the roster. If only for the sake of continuity, all three will be back.

Most of the doubt, though, is still where it was for the decade's last half: square on the shoulders of Alex Smith. He had his best season in 2009, with 18 scores and an 82 rating, and he played well enough to go into the '10s as the man we'd presume as our starter. But it wasn't enough to spare us the doubt we've been dealing with since he was drafted.

The '00s exacted revenge, all right. In the '80s and '90s, we lost 94 games. In the '00s alone, we lost 92. We've been tested, of course, but we haven't quit. We're Niner fans, and we won't ever quit.

Here's to a much better decade to come.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • RamItOn
    All right, Mr. Kaplan. It's been almost three weeks since your last article. No more resting upon laurels for you. Ideas for articles for Jeff Kaplan to scribe when he's not litigating: 1) In the Webzone earlier this week, I came upon a couple of threads that compared Walsh, Seifert, Mariucci, and Dick Nolan and the amount of performance they were able to squeeze from their respective rosters. Can you compare their styles and situations that they inherited, and in what state they left the franchise to their successor? 2) T.O., O.J. Simpson, and Ken Norton, Jr. are some of the more salient players that mark the Niners' history. Since all we have to cling to are memories at this point, can you highlight some of their contributions to the team over the years? 3) Possibly a piece on the politics of getting a stadium built (doesn't have to be Niner-centric, although that would be nice). 4) Some details about contract negotiations and some bargain players that we've had over the years (you know, like Rashaun Woods). Just some ideas. I can't write for crap and I don't know a whole lot about football, otherwise I'd do it. Thanks!
    Feb 4, 2010 at 1:22 PM
    Response: Jeez, Ram! Do you write questions for bar exams? Don't get me wrong, I'm SO grateful you're missing me, but I do plan to lie low this offseason. (I think I'm just now starting to catch up on the sleep I lost on all those Monday nights during all those months.) But fear not, I'll be around, and when I get the urge, you'll hear from me. Thanks for being such a loyal reader.
  • danimal
    Overall great summary of the Dark Ages. I do feel you could have included 2 items that I view as unbiased key points of the decade. 2005 - 1.1 pick. You stated that GM's usually go with a franchise QB here if in need of one. Well, there also have been plenty of 1.1 picks used elsewhere because the GM smartly wanted to avoid a make or break decision. Braylon Edwards here would never have broken the Niners' back for 5 more years. 2007, before Alex Smith's injury. There is a huge portion of veteran educated fans who had seen enough of Alex Smith pre Rocky Bernard. In 27 starts Alex was viewed as one of the worst QB's to ever have 27 starts in the NFL. There are many many fans who believe this kid would have failed in any NFL situation, hence rendering all the very valid excuses he has as ultimately moot. I think you failed to recognize the schism that has been in place since early 2007. The fan base is fractured and there is very little middle ground left. Over the next couple of years one side is going to be validated while the other will be blamed for further holding back real progress by sticking with a bust for too long.
    Feb 2, 2010 at 2:09 PM
  • Dan
    Yeah, if you want winners draft from the roster at Boise State. Maybe next year we can keep the injuries down. I just read an article by Tim Kawakami from the Mercury News that suggested Alex Smith was the best quarterback in the NFC West now. What do you think? Matt Hasselbeck has been to the Pro Bowl 3 times, the Super Bowl once and the playoffs five times. If Alex Smith can do any of those things next year I'll be ecstatic. Too bad we only have 2 first round picks next year, we could use first round help with at least three positions, two of them on the offensive line.
    Jan 30, 2010 at 1:52 PM
    Response: If Smith doesn't make a big jump, Dan, there'll be games where he plays like the best QB in the division, and other games where he plays like the worst. If he gets that OL help, and even if he doesn't, that won't be good enough, and that'll be it. Will he make that jump, or not?
  • carl scott
    I believe that the 49ers are on a new and improved path, moving nate clements to FS would be a great move, he has been getting burned all year before injury. Draft another top wideout and that corner from boise state and a RT and we are off to the SUPER BOWL BABY. McCloughan needs to fired, he sucks. I think our defense is a top d in the NFL. Improve the offense this off season and special teams, we should be alrite. I will be happy as long as we destroy those Dallas Cowgirls.
    Jan 29, 2010 at 11:15 PM
  • Niner_Noe
    Outstanding recap. I for one am hopeful we will look back at the last decade as "The Dark Ages." I have a feeling in the pit of my stomach that things will finally start clicking. Perhaps not a Super Bowl berth, but certainly a respectable team that is capable of administering a serious spanking to any of the other NFL teams. Wouldn't that be nice.
    Jan 29, 2010 at 2:38 AM
  • TTTT9ers
    By the way, I never read webzone articles because of amateurish writing (see Mayhew, Sydney - whose style and paragraph-long sentences work better in a novel than a sports article). You, however, are really good. I like the originality of your topic as well. Kudos!
    Jan 27, 2010 at 3:03 AM
    Response: Well, though I certainly don't subscribe to any denigration of my colleagues' efforts, I sincerely appreciate your support for my own.
  • TTTT9ers
    Excellent job. Your analysis of Donahue's performance and especially his drafts is right on. Interested in your take of McCloughan's drafts to date. Another article perhaps? Keep it up!
    Jan 27, 2010 at 2:49 AM
    Response: Thanks, TTTT. I think to a large extent, McCloughan is still an unknown. As I indicated, he's hit with Gore, V.Davis, Willis, and Crabtree. As I also indicated, he's missed with seemingly a half-dozen offensive linemen. But the jury's still out on so many of his guys: Lawson, Haralson, J.Hill, Goldson, Brown, Balmer, Morgan, Coffee, N.Davis. The success (or failure) of these guys will have a big say in how we do in the NEXT decade. In the '00s, though, all his draft picks stood in the shadow of Alex Smith. The last half of the last decade was all about Smith's travails in our ever-changing offensive schemes. McCloughan otherwise was merely a footnote.
  • ninersush
    great article kaplan. excellent recap. you even hit on the most painful points and the few bright spots pretty well. i like how u expressed facts and not opinions/biases. very well written indeed. i do remember however the game against the seahawks when they shut us out. that was the first time we got shut out in like 26 years or whatever the stat was. that is when i knew it was over. another lowlight was getting brandon whiting and a 6th rounder for TO i believe when we could have gotten a 3rd rounder if we had shipped him back due to not passing the physical which could have been arranged. man it felt like you gave a play by play of like getting dumped by the gf or something. it truly does hurt to read this article and think back to the past decade. and ur 09 analysis is on point. i just hope that when u re-write this article in 2020 it's about how we rose from the ashes of mediocrity to the heights of past 9ers lore. hopefully jed is eddie jr, we find/have a coach that is bill jr, and the 2010s r the 80s of the 2000s......
    Jan 19, 2010 at 4:09 PM
    Response: I'll drink (heavily) to THAT, my friend.
  • Bill Bird
    Don't listen to the whiners. You're a good writer Jeff -- very good -- and you put hammer to head of nail on remembering the decade that nobody really wants to remember. Those winning decades now seem so long ago -- and they are. This team has forgotten how to win. They still don't have an identity. I don't think our struggles are quite over yet. I'm not sure this team is playoff worthy yet. I'm still not sold on the QB and with all the linemen we've drafted in the past five years, we should have the greatest offensive line to ever step on the field. The fact that we don't -- is telling. Brilliant drafts used to be the norm with this club. It's getting better -- but some people are still clearly learning on the job.
    Jan 14, 2010 at 11:46 AM
    Response: Thanks, Bill. I appreciate all your support this season.
  • ddmur
    We are still where we were when Smith was drafted. Hill is not the answer, and you can't expect Davis to be ready this soon. Smith is tenacious. He could have moved on. He has kept his cool. He could have voiced bitterness at Nolan and pouted about being beat out by Hill. He must have known that he would get his chance. In the second half of the Texan game, he responded. But he hasn't shown that he is our next Montana. We still had a chance to win in our last drive against the Texans. He got forced into a long passing down, with a penalty, but Montana just didn't let those things happen when he was the QB. If Smith had been able to actually win that game, I think it would have given him more confidence, and the team would have had more confidence in him. Next year are we going to see the Smith who was the QB the first three quarters of the Rams game or the one who was the QB the last quarter? Next year still depends on him. If I were the GM, I would draft a QB EVERY YEAR even if it turns out that Smith is the next Montana. The best teams always seem to have a QB ready to step in. But please DO NOT give up ANY 1st round picks for McNabb.
    Jan 14, 2010 at 2:48 AM
  • ninerdawg
    Great article Jeff! Way to recap our glory years, I noticed when we were on top, the QB position was solidified. We can say over and over, we have a bad Oline, bad coaching, whatever. The problem is our inept QB, and we will remain mediocre until we address this. Jeff I will bet you a field pass, that it wasn't Singletary's philosophy that kept the hot OC's away, it was our QB! How can a coach come in and expect to win with Alex Smith?
    Jan 13, 2010 at 11:14 AM
    Response: Maybe we can SPLIT that field pass, Dawg. Tim Kawakami wrote that Linehan "told associates he had to walk away from the 49ers because he was worried that Singletary's run-pound-run-run grand view would limit the offense." That supports MY theory, but John Crumpacker wrote that "Those close to Linehan say he was not comfortable with Singletary and did not like either of the quarterbacks on the roster, Shaun Hill and Alex Smith." So I think we can agree that BOTH factors were concerns, though I'd argue that Singletary was a stronger deterrent. In any event, I agree with your basic point: we've got plenty of needs, but at the top of the list is better, more consistent quarterback play. Smith will have one more chance, and if, as you assume, he can't improve, that'll be that. Thanks, to all of you, for your feedback.
  • GoldandGarnet
    Great article.
    Jan 13, 2010 at 10:13 AM
  • wrongway9er
    Nice executive summary for the 00's decade but you forgot to mention Nolan's most important reason for selecting Alex Smith as the overall #1 pick in 2005: "He's got great enthusiasm."
    Jan 12, 2010 at 2:50 PM
  • WJ
    This is a very good recap of the decade. To the point, but very informative (maybe more on the draft picks and who we passed on). To the person who commented that the author is pessimistic, what are you talking about with regards to this article? This is a very accurate assessment of the past.
    Jan 12, 2010 at 10:49 AM
  • Italianiner
    Great great article. An excellent (though sad) analysis of our recent history.
    Jan 12, 2010 at 9:08 AM
  • SLNinerFan
    I would love to see one article that is positive from you, Jeff. I can't imagine why you are a fan of this team with all your negative articles and all of your pessimistic views. There must be one positive thing you see, right? If not, I don't know why you are still a fan of this team. It might be time to move on. Maybe the Raiders?
    Jan 12, 2010 at 8:26 AM
    Response: Hey, I mentioned our "playoff-worthy D," didn't I? In fact, I think I noted ALL the positives of the last decade, and I even raised a glass to a "much better decade to come"! But sorry, SL--if you don't think the '00s were largely negative, I daresay I wonder how YOU can be a fan; either you weren't paying enough attention or you didn't care enough to feel the pain. In any case, you've got it wrong when you suggest that if I'm negative I should just stop being a fan and "move on." If you're really a fan, you know that you CAN'T just quit, no matter how bad things get. As I wrote, "We're Niner fans, and we won't ever quit." A nice, positive message, eh?

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers praise Ji'Ayir Brown's journey from draft to starting lineup

By David Bonilla
Dec 1

The San Francisco 49ers are still exploring their safety options due to injuries to Talanoa Hufanga and George Odum. Tayler Hawkins is on the practice squad, and the team has added veteran Erik Harris. General manager John Lynch admits that there aren't many outside options at this point in the season. The silver lining is the depth added through the draft, with Ji'Ayir Brown selected from Penn State in the third round. Brown made a notable debut against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, stepping in for Hufanga, and made his first start against the Seattle Seahawks last week. The rookie's impressive performance has not gone unnoticed, earning a 76.8 overall Pro Football Focus grade against the Buccaneers and a 73.9 grade on Thanksgiving night. The 49ers are optimistic

Niners who could see increased opportunity in Week 14

By Steph Sanchez
Dec 9

While the 49ers have been afforded better injury luck in 2023, it's only natural for the wear and tear of the season to catch up. After a physical game against the Eagles in Philadelphia, the 49ers suffered a number of key injuries including to interior defensive linemen Arik Armstead and backup tight end Ross Dwelley. Arik Armstead popped up on the injury report with a foot injury after Week 12. This stirred concern that he was dealing with the same plantar fasciitis issue that he missed several games with in 2022. Despite not practicing ahead of Week 13, he played against Philadelphia but came out of the game nursing a new knee injury. Kyle Shanahan wouldn't go into much detail on either


More by Jeff Kaplan

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone