Defense Comes Out Of Nowhere, Running Game Goes Into It

Sep 15, 2009 at 6:10 AM

Okay, so maybe the preseason does mean nothing.

In the preseason, we saw a team with a ferocious running game but a soft, passive defense. True to Mike Singletary's vision, we saw a team that was "running at will." But quite contrary to that vision, we also saw defenders who were loose in coverage and slow on the rush.

Sure, the preseason didn't count. But c'mon, we weren't off base to believe those trends would continue. So naturally enough, in the first game that counted, the 49ers turned both of those trends upside-down.

Let's get one thing straight right now. The 49ers won. It might not have been pretty, but Singletary's postgame comments were exactly right. When you've lost as many games as we've lost recently, you don't complain about ugly wins. You take 'em however you can get 'em.

But now that we're looking ahead, it's natural to wonder.

What kind of team is this?!

Let's start with that defense, and let's give Greg Manusky some credit. His explanation for the preseason sleepwalk—that the guys were just playing vanilla—seemed like just a lame coaching excuse. But sure enough, when the alarm-clock rang, these guys got up and got after it. Three sacks, out of a base set. Eight hurries, half by Parys Haralson, who looks ready to break out for good. Two picks, one by Patrick Willis—who's ever more obviously the best in the business—and another by Nate Clements, who stuck to Larry Fitzgerald like glue. The Cardinals converted only 4 of 14 third downs, and Kurt Warner was rattled into a rating of 67.2. And most impressively, led by the indefatigable Justin Smith, the defense stood strong in the second half, despite watching the offense go three-and-out on five of its six possessions. (More on that later.)

My goodness. I mean seriously, wow. This defense, which had looked so flimsy, now looks very, very real.

Now about that running game....

Say what you want about Singletary, but the guy has plenty of confidence. When Jimmy Raye announced to the world (and, not insignificantly, to the Cardinals) that we'd be aiming to run it at 60 percent, he was delivering a message for his boss. Singletary wasn't being deceptive, setting up a bait-and-switch. He was just telling the truth. He really was so confident—arrogant? naive?—that he saw nothing wrong with showing off his plans. This is how tough we are, he was saying. We know we're gonna run, and now you know it too. Let's see if you can stop us.

Okay, the Cardinals said. We'll bite. They loaded up the box, and they blitzed straight into the running lanes. And stop us they certainly did. Frank Gore, Raye's precious "bell cow," had 22 carries for 30 yards. Overall, we had 25 carries for 21 yards, an average of 0.8. Worse, we had an astonishing 10 rushes that gained nothing or went the wrong way. Needless to say, the offensive line, at guard in particular, was completely overrun. And Singletary, you'd imagine, learned a little lesson in humility.

Sure, the line-play was simply deficient. Singletary was perfectly willing to acknowledge that much. What he didn't acknowledge was the blame of his own. If the Patriots' dynasty taught us anything, it's that the game's a lot easier when you know your opponents' plans. Not only did Singletary tip his hand, but Raye continued to play it, again and again, until it was nearly too late.

The good news was, when we needed to pass, we did, and did well. The winning drive won't make anyone forget Super Bowl XXIII, but it was a beauty, a Walshian oasis in a Hostlerian desert.

Fifteen plays. Thirteen passes. Nine completions. Four third-down conversions. Eighty yards. Seven minutes and 26 seconds. And finally, the winning touchdown.

Lost in all the teeth-gnashing about the running game is the fact that somehow Shaun Hill did it again. You just can't help but shake your head. He makes you wince, he makes you cringe, he makes you swear and throw things. And then, at the end, with no help from the run and even less from the line (paging Mr. Pashos, Mr. Tony Pashos), he walks off the field with a rating near 90 and a record of eight-and-three.

You wonder how long he can keep this up. And given that mystery, you don't blame Singletary for making him play second-fiddle. But Singletary must learn from this game. If he gets Hill involved more, and gets Hill involved earlier, Gore will have more room to run. The offense might not be as "tough," but it'll certainly be better.

And a better offense, of course, will help a better defense. Under any circumstances, this D was impressive. Under these circumstances—with an offense that ran itself into three-and-outs on 8 of 13 drives—the D was simply miraculous. Singletary can't demand that miracle every week. It's not realistic, and it's not fair.

We know what'll happen, 'cause we've been here before. Game one, 2007. Our offense produced a paltry 194 yards (only 9 fewer than we put up on Sunday), yet on the strength of the defense, somehow we pulled out a win. The opponent? The Cardinals. The score? 20 to 17.

Our hopes were raised, and were raised even more with a win the next week. And of course, we went on to lose 8 in a row and 10 of 11, largely because our offense was conservative, predictable, and the worst in the league by a hundred miles.

After game one this year, we find our hopes raised once again. Out of the blue, the defense looks ready. But whether this year's just a replay of 2007, or is truly the start of a glorious age, will depend on the offense. And the offense will depend on whether Singletary and Raye are willing to adjust the image they're working so hard to maintain. It'll depend on whether they learn, you don't win because you run.

You run because you win.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • canadianfaithful
    It is a vicious circle. You have to play fast yet controlled defense to disrupt the other team's offense. (Look at the Steelers.) The Niners did that on Sunday with an excellent scheme to stop the Cardinals' passing game. The pass rush was relentless! First time I have seen that kind of rush in years! The defense feeds off of the offense and vice versa. I applaud Sing and Raye for sticking to the run. The Cardinal defense kept pounding Gore, and Raye kept calling run plays. Eventually the Card defense wore down slightly stopping the run and Raye flipped the switch. Pass, pass, pass. Shaun Hill was his reliable self doing enough to help the Niners win. Singletary will have a game plan and stick to it! The key is to have the pass skill once the switch needs to be flipped during a game. If they suck up 8 or 9 in the box to stop the run, then throw it over their heads. If they lay back then pound it for 5 yards a carry until they stop it. The scheme is magical, and with a defense flying around like we saw on Sunday it will work all year. Especially if the team stays motivated and FOCUSED!
    Sep 16, 2009 at 7:24 AM
  • NickSh49
    "...a Walshian oasis in a Hostlerian desert." (Nick stands, begins slow clap of approval for Kaplan's hilarious metaphor)
    Sep 15, 2009 at 3:41 PM
    Response: Thank you, thank you, I'll be here all week, please tip your waitresses well....
  • Dan
    What will it take to calm you guys down? We're going to win games. Not because of the offense. Nor because of the defense. The reason we're going to win is because our players are working hard to win games. Our players are giving 100% for the entire game, and making plays when we really need them. Watch for these types of plays in all the games Singletary coaches. Also, the passing game will be easy for Shaun if teams decide to blitz the run for entire games. If they don't, then we can just run over everyone. So yeah I think he can keep up this level of passing for the entire season. You have to watch for teams that let us run the ball though. Shaun will likely pass less in those games so we don't turn over the ball. Pay attention to what's really going on guys, it's not a mystery.
    Sep 15, 2009 at 11:09 AM
  • Mike in MD
    On the highly welcomed surprise of the pass rush coming alive Manusky surely gets credit but I think Coach Sing does as well. I remember Singletary answering a question from one of the reporters during the preseason that our pass rush was "non-existent" which was true. When Manusky heard word of that, he was surprised. I don't know what else went on behind closed doors but Sing isn't the type to not act when he isn't getting the necessary results out on the field. I believe Sing is lighting a fire under his DC's tail letting him know we NEED that pressure from the D by applying some of his own pressure on him & we got some positive results. Also to Coach Sing's credit is how he's shaping the team & motivating his players esp on defense. They respond to him. Hopefully one or a few of the players take the role as leaders on both sides of the ball. Ex - when Sing pulled the D together at crunch time saying this is it. This is when we have to step up & make a play at this critical stage in the game when they were starting to let up in the 4th qtr. That got the team re-focused. I believe the team made steps after this game & will only get better. NINERS!!!!
    Sep 15, 2009 at 9:25 AM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Resurgent pass rush, Charvarius Ward lead 49ers defense to dominant showing vs. Seahawks

By Kirk Larrabee
Nov 23

After going through a dry spell in late October, it's safe to say the San Francisco 49ers have righted the ship on defense. The 49ers went through a brief slump of sorts on defense towards the end of October when they gave up big passing performances to quarterbacks Kirk Cousins (378 yards, two touchdowns) in a Week 7 loss to the Minnesota Vikings and Joe Burrow (283 yards, two touchdowns) in a Week 8 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals. Then, after a bye week in early November, the defense surged to give up just two touchdowns over a three-game span that has seen the 49ers notch one-sided victories over the Jacksonville Jaguars, Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Seattle Seahawks. The latest win came on Thanksgiving night, when the 49ers held the Seahawks to zero first quarter

49ers defense ranks No. 1 in points allowed

By David Bonilla
Nov 26

It wasn't that long ago that everyone was trying to figure out what was wrong with the San Francisco 49ers' defense. Desperately searching for answers, the team even seemed willing to yield to media pressure, relocating defensive coordinator Steve Wilks from the coaching box to the sidelines during games following its bye week. After struggling through three consecutive losses, the 49ers have won three straight since the adjustment. The defense is playing lights-out football, conceding only 30 total points over the last three games, a notable improvement from the 72 points allowed during its three-game skid. As of Sunday morning, San Francisco's defense stands as the league's stingiest, permitting a mere 15.5 points per game. This marks a remarkable turnaround

49ers mailbag: Who replaces Hufanga? Which players need to step up? Did Danny Gray fall out of favor?

By Marc Adams
Nov 22

It's an exciting time to be a fan of the San Francisco 49ers. And if you asked fans what they're most thankful for, when it comes to the team, you'd get a variety of answers, mostly players and coaches. But one thing all fans can be thankful for is that Jed York has allowed Kyle Shanahan and John Lynch to do what they want. What those two have done has the 49ers far removed from the bleak days in Santa Clara before they arrived. So there's a lot to be thankful for if you're a fan of the 49ers. Speaking of those fans, we opened up the 49ers Webzone Mailbag to grab your questions. So let's jump in and see what questions we can answer: Which positional battle on Thursday are you more concerned about: 49ers WRs vs Seattle DBs, or 49ers DBs vs Seattle WRs? - Scott

49ers vs. Seahawks Injury Updates: George Odum ruled out

By David Bonilla
Nov 23

The Seattle Seahawks are hosting the San Francisco 49ers for a Week 12 Thanksgiving matchup at Lumen Field. It is the first of two matchups between the teams in a three-game stretch. San Francisco is without one of its starting safeties. Talanoa Hufanga suffered a torn ACL against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and will miss the remainder of the season. Rookie Ji'Ayir Brown will start in his place. The 49ers took the field without starting guard Spencer Burford, who is dealing with a knee injury. He was among the team's seven inactive players for the matchup. Below are the 49ers-related in-game injury updates. S George Odum (biceps,


More by Jeff Kaplan

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone