Nancy Gay Has it All Wrong. Pioli? Please.
Quite simply, Nancy Gay has it all wrong. Pioli for president? There are several problems with her reasoning. Sure, it sounds good on face but Gay seems more enamored with the Patriots and Head Coach Bill Belichick than with Pioli. Let's look at her reasoning:
According to Gay, Pioli would be great because he has been a part of the personnel department of 4 NFL franchises. Guess what, Scott McCloughan was with Green Bay under legendary personnel man Ron Wolf and then with Seattle. In fact, Wolf went so far as to say that McCloughan, "has an exceptional eye for talent." Quite simply, the number of franchises you work for has nothing to do with your success rate. It just goes to show you that the good ol' boy network still works.
Gay seems to be in love with Belichick throughout her article. She heaps praise on him with comments like, "detail oriented" and "meticulous." She notes his impressive lists of candidates that is 10-12 coaches deep and further lauds Belichick's "impressive group of protegés."
That's all well and good, but when did Pioli become Belichick? Belichick might be detail oriented, but does that mean that Pioli is too? In heaping all this praise on one man who leads a successful team she forgot that Pioli is a different person with perhaps a different organizational style.
Oh, and my favorite part: Pioli's father-in-law is Bill Parcells. Really. You can't even make the whole "football runs in his genes" argument here because it's his
father-in-law. News flash, Dick Nolan was Mike Nolan's father. Fat lotta good that did the former head coach.
She doesn't even delve into the nitty gritty of what a hire like Pioli would mean for the 49ers. Where would GM Scott McCloughan fall on the organizational chart? Would Pioli keep Singletary? Would Pioli come to a team where the coaching staff was set?
Gay asserts that continuity in the coaching ranks has been a major problem for the 49ers and she is spot on. But Pioli would have no control over this. Coaches would still come and go and he would be stuck drafting for coaches with different philosophies. Does he draft for the Mike Martz offense or a ball-control run-based offense that Singletary seems to prefer? Consistency would not come from Scott Pioli, it would come from the Yorks getting their act together and hiring a coach that will succeed in implementing a vision and a consistent philosophy on offense and defense.
Pioli would have no control over coaching, that's Scott McCloughan's job. Wait...er, um...McCloughan would be fired. Wait, then would Pioli keep Singletary or some other Belichick protegé in his stead? Wouldn't hiring Pioli kind of go against that whole continuity argument?
Scott Pioli is a great talent evaluator for the Belichick system. Belichick is a great coach. Does that mean that Pioli would fix all of the 49ers wrongs? No. Might he be an improvement? Perhaps, but there are just too many gaps in the reasoning. The heart of the 49ers problems lie with coaching and consistency. Scott Pioli does not fix either one of those problems.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
-
Scott
Good read, but it sounds more like a b***h session, than it does an article about the niners...
Dec 27, 2008 at 6:24 AM
-
Mark Egan
Here's a reason you're wrong: Alex Smith. Scott McCloughin didn't do his homework. Alex's old coach said he wouldn't work in a pro system unless he knew it perfectly - which few quarterbacks ever do, much less, a team with rotating offensive coordinators. Pioli is known for running the best prepared organization. That's what we need.
Dec 18, 2008 at 12:50 PM
-
sl
Holmgren not qualified. ( 49ers , GB, Seattle all in the SB) wonder what Gay thought about Tuna taking over in Miami. Miami sure isnt complaining.
Dec 16, 2008 at 8:17 PM
-
Edward
nancy gay and gwen knapp are horrible writers/columnists. this article serves as case in point. even while i'm inclined to agree (or at least consider) that pioli could be a great pick to run the niners organization, gay's article contains no cogent supporting evidence, fails to address pioli's failures and explain why these missteps should be overlooked, and offers a bunch of nonsensical, irrelevant garbage as the basis for her main point. Heres the real truth. the pats's past and success are largely based on three moves: drafting tom brady, the tuck rule, and randy moss. getting brady was pure luck and a fluke. i dont think anyone can plausibly argue that the Pats knew he would be this good. at best, they thought he might be a good nfl qb, not the second coming of montana (just like how i doubt even walsh knew montana was going to be the second coming of unitas). the tuck rule was a gift from the nfl rulebook. and moss was a gift from the raiders.
Dec 15, 2008 at 11:39 AM
-
jon hyde
The 49er personnel picks have been very weak vis-a-vis their draft position since Nolan and McCloughan took over. All you have to do is look around the league to see how much talent and depth other teams have built in the past few years. On top of that, their free agent batting avg. for noticeable contribution/ impact has been terrible. After all these miserable years they're no better than a 8-8 team and yet some people keep thinking they're on the right track. The few top players they picked up are strictly the luck of averages. Nothing more. You must have been a Bush supporter as well. Maybe you still are!
Dec 14, 2008 at 1:48 PM
-
Daniel
i love you
Dec 14, 2008 at 11:11 AM
-
shaj
Oscar, Bellichick (sp?) was a nobody until he came to the patriots. We have already established that a big part of that success was due to Tom Brady, but under Cassel, we have also seen that Bellichick has a system and process that has also been a major reason. That includes awesome team management and drafting. He wasn't able to do that with the Browns, so all factors indicate that Pioli has played a big role in the concurrent success of Bellichick and the Patriots. I think you're highly underrating Pioli.
Dec 14, 2008 at 7:23 AM
-
Steven
I agree with you and wish more people would stop drinking the Pioli Kool-aid. He does a terrible job drafting and most people don't know it. When you go back and look at the Patriot drafts from 2000 to 2005, only 12 players out of 51 selected from all those drafts are still with the team. Their most recent drafts haven't had much success either. There is only 3 players left from the 2006 draft and only one is left from 2007. If he was good at scouting and drafting then more players would be around from the 2006-2007 drafts and fewer would be left from the earlier drafts. They've had 70 draft picks since 2000 and only have 16 players left out of those 70 picks. That is not a good record. McCloughan has shown he has an eye for talent and now those young players are getting their chance now that Nolan is gone.
Dec 13, 2008 at 10:03 AM
More San Francisco 49ers News
Kyle Shanahan says 49ers rookie Dominick Puni has "gotten better throughout camp"
Throughout training camp and preseason, one of the bright spots for the San Francisco 49ers has been rookie offensive guard Dominick Puni. The former Kansas Jayhawk took over the starting right guard spot early in camp due to injuries sustained by Spencer Burford and Jon...
George Kittle: Brock Purdy has new confidence in the 49ers offense
From the moment Brock Purdy first stepped onto the football field as a rookie, he exuded a calm and confidence that immediately stood out. His résumé is already impressive. In just two seasons, Purdy has led the San Francisco 49ers to two NFC Championship Games...
NFL agent: 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk has handled contract drama 'horribly'
Ben Standig of The Athletic recently spoke with several NFL agents about various league topics, including the ongoing contract standoff between the San Francisco 49ers and wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. The situation has escalated, with no resolution in sight.
Aiyuk is currently...
Former LSU Star Has a Chance to Resurrect Career with 49ers
By Sasha D. Robinson
Aug 30
Wide receiver Terrace Marshall Jr. has joined the San Francisco 49ers practice squad after being cut by the Carolina Panthers.
Marshall, who had a subpar start to his first four years in the NFL, now has a fresh opportunity with the 49ers, where he will compete with Trent...
