Nolan Out, Singletary In

Oct 20, 2008 at 3:26 PM

The end of the Mike Nolan era is finally here. And the funny thing about it is, the 49ers can't even fire someone right. If Nolan really is going to be fired after the Seahawks game, why wait? Now all you have is a lame-duck coach who is staring his future in the face.

Either: 1) The team rallies around their coach and plays a great game, throwing the decision into question (although, there really shouldn't be a question). Or 2) The team throws it in because their coach is out and they have nothing to play for.

How prepared is Nolan going to be for the game if Singletary really is going to take over? Even when the 49ers are "decisive" they can't be decisive.

EDIT: The team, apparently realizing they let the cat out of the bag, decided to fire Mike Nolan right away. Instead of waiting for the bye to let the players adjust, they have to deal with a game and a new coach all in 5 days. Is it better than letting Nolan coach a game knowing he would be fired? Yes. But the optimal move would have been to fire Nolan at the bye to let the new HC have some time to get things right with the team.


I'm watching ESPN report on the Nolan firing and here is a quick synopsis of what they had to say:

Chris Mortensen: The 49ers are different than St. Louis. The 49ers play hard, but on Nolan's first year they drafted Smith and that was ultimately the decision that doomed him. Things never came together for him since it was a bad team around Smith.

Steve Young: I'm worried that players and coaches are going to starting to rotating through. Nolan has set a good foundation. They play hard, but don't win. The franchise was basically an expansion franchise when Nolan took over (Oscar's Note: Ouch) and Nolan helped make them better. I worry, though, that this going to be like the Cardinals of the 80's and 90's where people rotate through and good people and players come through and nothing ever gets fixed.

Both had praise for Nolan and said that he was a good football coach.

Is Singletary a candidate to permanently replace Nolan as head coach? What about Martz? I think the 49ers know that Martz is not the long term answer. The same things that plagued him in Detroit and St. Louis are starting to rear their head here. His offense is a high risk offense that lends itself to sacks, turnovers and poor clock management. Teams like New Orleans and Denver are clear examples of where you can craft a great offense and not fall to the kinds of problems that the 49ers have.

Mike Singletary may be a great motivator, and he may be a great linebackers coach. He has ZERO coordinator experience and while he may be a dynamic individual who is respected in football circles, respect is not enough to be a successful head coach. Mike Nolan is respected in the NFL as a coach and the 49ers are all too familiar with how much good that brought them.

Singletary's biggest challenge is his knowledge of the X's and O's. This year, he won't have to worry too much since Martz's offense is effectively an autonomous unit and Greg Manusky is capable of running his defense. Heck, he might even run the defense better than Nolan.

Singletary is a short term answer and I don't expect him to have the kind of impact that Jim Haslett had in St. Louis. But this was ultimately a decision that had to be made because Nolan was not going to survive another season. Firing him now at least shows that the York's are paying attention.
3:45 pm: This is a synopsis of what Trent Dilfer said on Sportscenter:

Mike Nolan is a good man and a good football coach. There is only one person for the job, if Nolan is indeed fired, and that is Mike Singletary. The 49ers are not rebuilding, they need to win now. The person who takes this job has to have three things: #1They need to have some personal and professional integrity to prevent any potential backstabbing. #2 They have to have conviction as to what you need to be on offense and defense. Someone needs to go into the office and say "This is how the offense will run" and "This is how the defense will run." The team has no identity. #3 This team needs to be inspired. Mike is an excellent football coach who was made to lead men. If anyone can inspire the team, it's Mike Singletary.

What needs to happen is that their offensive and defensive systems are not married. They need to get the defense on board with the defense. The team was built on offense to be a bog, physical run team, not a wide open, pass-happy team. Someone needs to make sure the 49ers are moving forward as a team and using the talent based on how the team was built.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Frank
    I knew this day was could feel it. Part of me is sad...because I believe Mike Nolan is a good man and a good football coach. He may just be one of those guys who's forte is as an assistant or coordinator, but not a head coach. There's nothing wrong with that. The problem is, he simply didn't win. He had the support of his players...that's for sure. He had his shortcomings...which have been well chronicled. He gave his heart and soul to the Niners...but, it wasn't enough. So, now the job is Mike Singletary's. I think he'll do well...he's in his 4th season with the team and definitely has all the respect he'll need to succeed. I'm happy MS is getting his shot with the'd be great if the team responds and the York's can award him the job permanently. As for the York's...I hope they've learned from this. They have to do whatever it takes to get this team back on the right track. They also need to find a stadium...or risk losing this team.
    Oct 20, 2008 at 11:06 PM
  • sscl
    is singletary oru haed coach or interim hc???
    Oct 20, 2008 at 9:03 PM
    Response: From what ESPN is saying, he is currently the interim head coach but they are negotiating a long term deal.
  • RBWinddevil
    We have never been the same since Bobb McKittrick, our O-line is a big part of our lack of success. I'm sure you noticed how seldom we move the ball on the ground, other than Gore individual moves. Have you seen sustained drives with the running game? Play selection sequences set-up the def for successful positive yds. Hence it isn't just the O line guys but both good blocking and play calling make things work. It seems like our O line talent can be developed. Last yr K Harris proved he could not pass block most off the time, he's gone. Sure the Def could improve, but our O-line isn't getting it done, unless you think 5-11 or 6-10 is good.
    Oct 20, 2008 at 8:51 PM
  • niner
    Warhop needs to pack his bags up and leave with his boy Nolan! NObody can win behind this pathetic line. Ney NOlan , take your puppy scott with you too!
    Oct 20, 2008 at 8:00 PM
  • frenchmov
    aren't you going to adjust your article? you said we can't even fire someone correctly ("why not fire him now instead of waiting?") and then we did. so i guess we fired him the right way now?
    Oct 20, 2008 at 6:30 PM
    Response: Adjusted.
  • HB
    Way to go YORKS. Who's bright idea was it to let Nolan do the morning press conference and then fire him a few hours later. No tact, no class, no clue. The YORKS continue to be intent on proving to the world how little they know about football, business, and people. SELL THEY TEAM DENISE. you have ruined a once mighty and glorious franchise and turned it into a lughinstock out of spite. Nice going! I hope you are appropriately ashamed and embarrased by the results of your ineptitude.
    Oct 20, 2008 at 6:10 PM
  • 9erstorm
    We may be the only team in the league that can fire their head coach and have someone from his staff step in and be 5 times better. Maybe the stupid coaching decisions will finally end.
    Oct 20, 2008 at 3:38 PM
    Response: Whether Singletary will, in fact, be 5x better is yet to be decided. At least it's an internal promotion.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Watch 49ers legend Frank Gore knock out opponent in pro boxing debut

By David Bonilla
May 15

Frank Gore's NFL playing date may be behind him, but the future Hall of Fame running back is enjoying another passion—boxing. The San Francisco 49ers all-time rushing leader celebrated his 39th birthday on Saturday by knocking out Yaya Olorunsola in the fourth round during his pro boxing debut. You can watch Gore deliver the crushing blow below (h/t Bleacher Report). Today was a great day!!!Want to thank my team for all the hard

49ers Notebook: Frustrated Javon Kinlaw lashes out at reporter

By Rohan Chakravarthi
May 25

After an eventful day of organized team activities (OTAs) on Tuesday, which marked the first time that the media was allowed at practice during Phase 3 of the offseason schedule, the night ended with some unexpected news regarding a certain San Francisco 49ers player. Here is the latest 49ers news: Frustrated 49ers DT Javon Kinlaw lashes out at reporter After an encounter that occurred during the open portion of OTAs between Javon Kinlaw, the third-year defensive tackle for the 49ers, and Sports Illustrated's Grant Cohn, in which Kinlaw reportedly knocked Cohn's hat off, the 24-year old player joined Cohn's YouTube livestream late Tuesday night and provided a profanity-filled response to Cohn's previous criticism of

49ers Notebook: Griese hasn't spoken with Garoppolo; Confidence in Banks; Raiders working out Kaepernick

By David Bonilla
May 25

On Wednesday, the San Francisco 49ers made their assistant coaches available to reporters, as they do every offseason. Below are some noteworthy tidbits from the interactions. No contact with Garoppolo On Tuesday, tight end George Kittle said he hasn't spoken with quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo since the team cleaned out their lockers after the season. Head coach Kyle Shanahan said the 49ers still intend to trade Garoppolo, but also said nothing is guaranteed. On Wednesday, San Francisco's new quarterbacks coach, Brian Griese, said he has worked closely with all of the team's quarterbacks this offseason, except for Garoppolo. In fact, the

Multiple NFL players speak out against 49ers beat writer

By Marc Adams
May 26

It was only a matter of time before SI's Grant Cohn pushed a little too hard. A lot of fans like his approach. Many, however, find it annoying. Cohn has a style of reporting that is unique. Some say it is honest reporting, and nothing more. Yet some say Cohn is gaslighting and only saying or writing the things he communicates in order to receive more attention, and gain more readers and followers, thus leading to more story clicks and YouTube views. Most people respect reporters who speak or write the truth. Fans don't need watered-down reports that hide facts, in an effort to stay on the team's good side. But some believe Cohn takes things a little too far. He has been known to make sarcastic statements about players' injury histories, calling players a bust


More by Oscar Aparicio

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone