20% off at the official 49ers online store with code COACH20 →

49ers Are Going Nowhere

Andre Tameta
Oct 14, 2008 at 10:26 AM


Another game, another loss. Head coach Mike Nolan's seat is getting warmer and is on the brink of losing the team. Is it time for Nolan to go? Many in the Bay Area believe so.

What constituted Nolan getting another shot? Nolan's best record as 49er head coach was 7-9, not exactly a winning season. When is enough, enough?

Nolan's game plan and conservative defense played a huge role in the 49ers' losing ways. His meddling of coaching personnel has hindered this team and his time is now coming to an end in San Francisco.

Although firing Nolan mid-season may not be the recourse the 49ers want to go, but a change is necessary if the 49ers are to return to their glory years, which almost seem like an eternity ago.

With Mike Holmgren leaving Seattle at the end of the season, the 49ers should highly consider hiring Holmgren and bring back some of that glory day luster. Holmgren was the 49ers' offensive coordinator during the Joe Montana era and has three Super Bowl appearances under his belt as a head coach, winning one with the Green Bay Packers in 1996.

Although the 49ers' offense has been decent this season, a return to its roots is necessary. The 49ers are known for its West Coast Offense, not Martz's wide open style. With Holmgren, the 49ers would return to this style of offense, the same very offense that aided in the 49ers winning five Super Bowls.

This has been a dark era for San Francisco football and Nolan has not helped the situation any. Fan support is starting to falter and there's the possibility that games could be blacked out next season if things don't turn around soon.

The 49er defense has been porous. This is Nolan's specialty and he has been unable to come up with game plans to stop opposing offenses. A defensive minded coach is supposed to have his unit on top of things. Unfortunately, Nolan and his defense simply cannot get the job done.

Quarterback J.T. O'Sullivan has been average at best. Although he has shined at times, he still gives up too many turnovers. Nolan obviously did not have a real back up plan if Alex Smith was to fail (which he did) and now the 49ers are stuck with a journeyman quarterback that is starting.

Ever since Steve Mariucci was fired, the 49ers have gone nowhere. Times during the Mooch era don't seem too bad now as we actually got into the playoffs and contended. Although Mooch's teams weren't championship worthy, at least they competed.

After another loss to Philadelphia where Nolan mismanaged another game to another loss, it may be time for the 49ers to consider a change at the head coach now. Fire Nolan now, have Mike Martz finish out the season as interim head coach and snatch up Mike Holmgren in the off season sounds like a good plan to me. A return to our roots is necessary for this team to survive for the future.

Although this may seem like a brash idea, the team is truly going nowhere and a shake up is necessary. Nolan is obviously not the man we thought he was and is a waste of coaching space.

With Nolan's apparent departure soon, one can only wonder if the assistant coaches will be let go as well. If Holmgren is picked to be the successor, there is a plethora of capable assistant coaches that are well versed in Holmgren's style of football. Former coordinators Greg Knapp and Marty Mornhinweg come to mind immediately. Who knows, maybe George Seifert can be brought out of retirement to run the defense, a Seifert specialty.

Speculation abounds as Nolan continually scapegoats other players for team failures. However, when it all comes down to it, it's the head coach that is ultimately responsible. Nolan is the man who we should be pointing fingers at.

A change is necessary. Bring on Mike Holmgren.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


6 Comments

  • Grant
    Nolan must go, ok, but bring in Holmgren and institute the west coast offesne? The NFL has caught up to to that now, and the WCO has prompted the "Tampa-2" retaliation. What the 49ers need is someone to issue in a NEW era and someone who is innovative in their own right.
    Oct 16, 2008 at 7:45 AM
    0
  • Rick Reulecke
    Although I like your article, the idea of Mike Holmgren as our coach next year is not going to happen. Number 1, Mike Holmgren has already stated that he plans to take 2009 off to contemplate things. I like the idea of Seifert as our D coordinator, and Mike Singletary as head coach. Get rid of Mike Fartz (never cared for the man) stir clear of Marty Mornhinweg, and bring in a capable and seasoned O coordinator. We have the talent...all we need are capable coaches that know and understand the X's and O's of football. And PLEASE NOT ANOTHER SUIT!
    Oct 14, 2008 at 7:50 PM
    0
  • jerry roman
    CHALLENGING THAT FIELD GOAL AND LOSING YOUR LAST CHALLENGE AND TIMEOUT SPEAKS VOLUMES ABOUT NOLANS COACHING ABILITY .IM GETTING TIRED OF WATCHING OF THIS GARBAGE.I WISH EDDIE STILL OWNED THE TEAM BECAUSE IT DOESNT SEEM LIKE THE YORKS CARE ABOUT WINNING.ITS TIME FOR NOLAN AND THE YORKS TO HIT THE ROAD
    Oct 14, 2008 at 5:24 PM
    0
  • niner
    if you were the owner wouldnt you want to say something to the fans? If Mr D ( eddies and denises dad ) was here, both york and NOlan would have been replaced 3 years ago! Now we just continue to suffer. This is pitiful.
    Oct 14, 2008 at 5:11 PM
    0
  • Mike in MD
    I agree w/Terry. Give Singletary a look. Manusky would be my other choice but I don't know how much he's been handcuffed by Nolan so no one 100% knows his mentality or style of playing but the Defense SUCKS which brought some doubt on him. I don't trust Martz as the HC who has a bad rep. Keep him at OC where he excels. He manages games BADLY. We need someone who can motivate, coach, develop, & be able to manage games to give our players a chance to win them. I've always been a Holmgren fan but lately he seems to be losing his touch & his team seems SOFT. He's definitely a huge upgrade (ANYONE WOULD) over INCOMPETENT LOSER Nolan but I'd like to see some new blood but still a proven guy. I do like Cowher as an option. Scotty I'm borderline on because I don't know how much Nolan still influences him since he was the GM in the beginning. He needs to ACT ON HIS OWN otherwise we need a total overhaul next season. New GM, HC, OL Coach, re-evaluate everyone, & get rid of the Nolan average favs!! Rebuild the O/D Lines, a future franchise QB, & bring in more TEAM SPEEEED!! Build the team around Gore, Staley, VD, BJ (#2), Morgan, Battle (#3-4), JSmith, RMcD, Willis, Clements.
    Oct 14, 2008 at 3:55 PM
    0
  • Terry Marshall
    When you live in the past you kill your FUTURE!Mike Holmgren is one of the coaches Mike Nolan can beat,fire Nolan after he gets off of that plane from NY after the Giants whip our team 42-12 replace him with Mike Singletary,who the players respect and at the end of year search for a head coach.
    Oct 14, 2008 at 11:01 AM
    0

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Jimmie Ward on 49ers rookie Deommodore Lenoir: 'He's going to be a great player in this league'

By David Bonilla
Oct 7

Cornerback Deommodore Lenoir may end up being one of the best value picks from the San Francisco 49ers' most recent draft class. He was a fifth-round draft pick, and the Niners tend to find gold in that round. Linebacker Dre Greenlaw was a fifth-round draft pick in 2019. D.J. Reed may not be on the team anymore but is proving to be a good player for the Seattle Seahawks. He was a 49ers fifth-round pick in 2018. In 2017, San Francisco drafted some little-known tight end out of Iowa named George Kittle. He's not bad either. Could Lenoir be the team's next fifth-round gem? The rookie's teammate, safety Jimmie Ward, joined 95.7 The Game on Wednesday. The discussion eventually led to Lenoir and the young defensive back's early dividends. The



49ers' Kyle Shanahan on Trey Lance: 'He will give us a chance to win a lot going forward'

By David Bonilla
Oct 11

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke with reporters this afternoon, nearly 24 hours after his team suffered its third consecutive loss of the season. There was a lot of bad from the trip to State Farm Stadium to play the Arizona Cardinals. However, there was also some good. The game was rookie Trey Lance's first NFL start. The 21-year-old quarterback had his ups and downs, but it was an opportunity for growth. Lance was playing because the 49ers' regular starter, Jimmy Garoppolo, is dealing with a calf injury. "I was proud of him," Shanahan said of Lance via a conference call. "I thought he went into a tough environment versus a real good team. I thought he did a lot of real good things. He threw a bad pick on that first drive, but I thought he



Deebo Samuel showing flashes of 49ers great Jerry Rice, says NFL.com

By David Bonilla
Oct 5

Deebo Samuel is the NFL's leading receiver through four weeks of play. He has 490 receiving yards and three receiving touchdowns on 28 receptions, which puts him on pace for over 2,000 yards through 17 games. Now, a lot has to happen between now and the end of the season for Samuel to come anywhere close to that milestone. While Calvin Johnson was 36 yards shy of that mark in 2012, no one has reached it. Samuel would have to maintain his current pace and stay healthy to come close, even with the benefit of a 17-game season. While the receiving record would be a significant challenge, NFL Media researcher Dante Koplowitz-Fleming shares



'My whole entire body was affected': 49ers pass rusher Dee Ford details dealing with chronic back issues

By David Bonilla
Oct 5

Some wondered if San Francisco 49ers pass rusher Dee Ford would ever play an NFL snap again. Ford never questioned that. He started dealing with a back injury after Week 1 last season and never returned to the field in 2020. Most felt that any contributions from Ford this season would be a bonus for the 49ers. Ford has played in all four games this season and racked up three sacks in the process. Two of those came this past weekend against the Seattle Seahawks. Once again, Ford is making an impact on the Niners defense. That's pretty good for a player who many felt might retire. Retirement, though, was never on Ford's mind. "For me, personally, [the injury] was tough," Ford said this morning on KNBR's Murph & Mac show. "... I always


Featured

More by Andre Tameta

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone