Mad Mike or Mike Martz: Which Will the 49ers Get?

Jan 9, 2008 at 1:21 PM


The brick hit me as I am sure it hit many of you. All of this wishing for Cam Cameron coupled with McCloughan's denouncing of the Martz rumors completely blinded me to the fact that the 49ers might actually hire the guy. When I heard the news it was like someone told me Brittany Spears was deemed mentally competent - so wacky you almost have to think it's fake.

Martz was certainly the dark-horse candidate with new GM Scott McCloughan even publicly saying that there was no truth to rumors connecting Martz to the 49ers. SI.com apparently confirmed the rumor through another source in the organization. Like many have already written - Martz's hire clearly shows who the "big trigger" is in this organization.

Front office shenanigans aside - I think he will do a better job than Jim Hostler. When you hit rock bottom you can only go up so really, Martz has only one way to go. The question at hand, though, is not whether Martz will better the offense, because I think clearly he will. Whether in St. Louis or Detroit he clearly shows the ability to produce offensively.

The question now is really whether Mike Martz will be the Mike Martz of 1999-2001 or the post-New-England-I-got-my-arce-handed-to-me-and-it-made-me-crazy Mike Martz.

The Super Bowl loss at the end of the 2001 season seems to be the turning point for Martz's offensive insanity. Remember, that game was "The Greatest Show on Turf" against a young, 6th round QB and a team that was supposed to lose by two scores. Belichick's Patriots dared Martz to run - they lined up in the nickel offense all game and said, "bring it." Martz, of course, never ran the ball and the rest is history. Thereafter, seemingly proving my case, Martz said that he should have passed the ball MORE during the game. If insanity is doing the same thing over and over all the while expecting a different result then this game produced the emergence of Mad Mike Martz.

It was like a switch flipped - he wanted to prove that he could do things his way and make them work, perpetuating his obstinate persona. Websites like DumpMartz.com and FireMartz.com (sound familiar niner fans?) started to spring up and Martz continued to throw. He took stubborn to a new level.

Thus, the case against Martz is quite simply that he is an obstinate fool who is content with never running the ball more than five times a game. Many would cite his paltry 87.8 average rushing yards per game in 2002 with the Rams, or more recently his 79.8 rushing yards per game in 2007 with Detroit. Some would even say that the Lions fired their offensive line coach in 2006 over personality clashes with Martz. In short, Big Ego + Stubbornness = Bad Coach.

But what about the potential positives? Martz's best years were when he had a dynamic running back in Marshall Faulk, a double threat who could damage teams on the ground or through the air. Similarly, the 49ers have Frank Gore, a player Martz quickly admitted will be the foundation of the offense. Under Martz, Faulk had two 1,300-yard seasons and the Rams were virtually unstoppable.

Beyond the personnel, Martz's best year in terms of ground production was his first year as coordinator, 1999, when Dick Vermeil was the head coach. Perhaps Nolan will interject enough caution to moderate the free wheeling, pass-happy offenses Martz tends to prefer.

Martz can certainly has an eye for quarterbacks. Trent Green, Kurt Warner, Marc Bulger and Jon Kitna can all attribute their success to Martz. In fact, Jon Kitna is very much a supporter f Martz and came to his defense even after Martz was fired from the Motor City.

"[I]f you look at our games the past two years, when we were in the game, not down 13 points at halftime or 21 points, we were a pretty balanced football team," Said Kitna of his recently deposed offensive coordinator. "In our seven wins this year, we rushed for more than 100 yards in six of them. But there were three different times this year when we gave up more than 30 points in the first half. It's kind of hard to run when that happens." In short, Kitna believes that Martz was the victim of circumstance, of a bad defense that made him throw early and often.

This, to me is the least convincing argument. Martz established a pattern in St. Louis, low rushing attempts, high passing attempts and high sacks - a pattern that persisted in Detroit. What is to say that the pattern will change now?

Head Coach Mike Nolan, I'm sure, knows plenty about football, but he knows little about the offensive side of the ball. He needs someone to take the offense and be left alone. This was why Turner and Nolan worked so well. Nolan could work on the defense, game day (you heard right, game day) and team management while the offense just worked. The team trusted Turner and his pedigree. This year, they did not trust Hostler and even Gore mentioned it to the press.

When it comes down to it, Mike Nolan is a defensive coordinator who can create an organizational chart, stick with it, and make decisions (as long as they don't pertain to the use of time outs or 4th down calls). If one thing is certain, when Nolan makes a decision, there is no going back.

Martz's autonomy is a double edged sword, though. Too much autonomy and you have the potential for Martz to continue his patterns. Too much meddling and you now have a coach who is not an offensive maven trying to meddle with the guy he hired as the offensive coordinator.

Even more than that, though, Martz sees this as perhaps his last opportunity to move back into the head coaching ranks. This poses a unique dynamic since Martz may not want too much interference from outside parties. Will he want to again prove that he can do things his way, or will he want to prove that he can run the ball when he has a capable running back? Will the relationship these two men apparently established in Washington be enough to minimize the potential clash of egos?

There is no doubt that Martz is the type of offensive coordinator the 49ers need, someone who is good with quarterbacks, someone who can handle the offensive side of the team autonomously, someone who can put some offensive imagination into a team that draws it's character from a cautious head coach. And perhaps more importantly, he is a coordinator the players will trust - just like they trusted Turner. There is certainly the potential to succeed.

Wether or not he is the type of person the 49ers need is the biggest question.

Year by Year Mike Martz Stats

YearTotal Sacks
199933
200044
200140
200246
200343
200450
2005Partial Season
200663
200753
YearRushing yards Per Game
1999128.7
2000115.2
2001126.7
200287.8
200393.5
2004101.5
2005Partial Season
200670.6
200779.8
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


1 Comment

  • Alimayu Price
    I was certainly surprised that Mike Martz was slected as the 49ers' oc. However, my biggest concern is that will Martz keep an open mind to a more balanced attack and not just rely on the passing game. I beleive this is a great opportunity for the 49ers to make use of the talent they already have and place some real wrinkles in the their plays and personnel. 1st of all as much as I like Shaun Hill-I think Alex Smith deserves a chance to fight for his job and may the best man win. 2ndly it's time to use the talent in Jason Hill as a deep receiver and keep Arnaz Battle as a very reliable possesion receiver. Special plays should be made for Vernon Davis-this season the 9ers didn't make use of his speed and power which could really open up the running game for Gore. I also believe that the 9ers are wasting good talent like Delanie Walker who i believe could be an ewxcellent H-back or full back. Walker has tremendous power and great hands. He and Gore could be another Csonka and Morris combo with the added bonus of pass receiving skills from both. I hope martz will be imaginative and creative enough to make use of thes players along Lelie and Jackson. The sky could be the limit
    Jan 9, 2008 at 10:21 PM
    0
    Response: I was right there with you until you mentioned Davis as a mechanism for opening running lanes for Gore. If the 49ers drafted a TE with 4.3 speed to stay in and block then they drafted wrong. I hope Martz utilizes Davis in space and feeds him the ball. He can be a playmaker on a squad lacking playmakers.

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



PFF ranks 3 play-callers ahead of 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan

By David Bonilla
Jun 16

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan is still widely regarded as one of the NFL's top play-callers, which is reflected in Pro Football Focus' 2022 ranking of the best offensive play-callers. How did the analytics site determine its ranking? Contributor Eric Eager used the massive amount of data available to him and adjusted each coach's success based on opponents faced. He also factored in expected points based on available talent and the play-caller's success rate, among other things. San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan and Los Angeles Rams head coach Sean McVay were left off last year's ranking. Eager explained that Pro Football Focus dinged the



49ers' home venue, Levi's Stadium, selected to host FIFA World Cup 2026

By Site Staff
Jun 16

The San Francisco 49ers announced that the team's home venue, Levi's Stadium, has been selected to be among the NFL stadiums to host the FIFA World Cup in 2026. "We have been bidding on the World Cup for 2026," team president Al Guido said last week during the 49ers' State of the Franchise event, which was shared with fans on Wednesday. "I think it's an amazing opportunity for all of us." Guido added that the 49ers are also working to have Levi's Stadium host another Super Bowl, possibly in 2026 (Super Bowl LX) or 2027 (Super Bowl LXI). "We are talking to the NFL and all of our partners around the ability to bring Super Bowl 60 and/or 61 back to the



Eagles sign ex-49ers S Jaquiski Tartt to one-year deal

By David Bonilla
Jun 17

The Philadelphia Eagles have signed former San Francisco 49ers safety Jaquiski Tartt to a one-year deal. He was an unrestricted free agent. Eagles announced they have reached agreement on a one-year deal with former 49ers' S Jaquiski Tartt.— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) June 17, 2022 In April, the 49ers admitted that they had not spoken with Tartt but didn't completely rule out bringing the safety



CBS Sports labels 49ers' handling of QB Jimmy Garoppolo as most questionable offseason move

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Jun 17

Earlier this week, CBS Sports compiled a list of every NFL team's most questionable offseason move, and pointed to the Jimmy Garoppolo saga for the San Francisco 49ers, which still remains unanswered as mandatory minicamp has concluded. While there were several potential choices, such as San Francisco's contract negotiations with Deebo Samuel that ultimately resulted in a trade request by the fourth-year receiver, CBS Sports's Jordan Dajani believed that the outcome of the Garoppolo situation was the most questionable move. "We could discuss something related to Deebo Samuel here, but it seems


Featured

More by Oscar Aparicio

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone