Rattay asked to lead 49ers into Green Bay

Nov 21, 2003 at 12:00 AM0


What's the significance of November 4, 1990? That was the last time the San Francisco 49ers beat the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field. Those were the days of Joe Montana and George Seifert. Since then, the 49ers have accumulated a pitiful 1-9 overall record against the Packers. Their one win was a comeback effort in an NFC Wildcard game at 3Com Park. Those are scary numbers to look back on for the 49ers. But you know what? That isn't the least of the 49ers' worries going into this game.

So it will be Tim Rattay starting once again at quarterback for the injury plagued Jeff Garcia. This Sunday, the 49ers will ask him to do something the team has not been able to do all year...win a road game. The 49ers have not been the road warriors that fans are used to seeing. That's right, they are 0-4 on the road this season.

The 49ers are about to enter a very tough stretch on the road. Not only because of the teams they play, but also because of the weather they will do it in. The 49ers will play 4 of their next 5 games in Green Bay, Baltimore, Cincinnati, and Philadelphia. With a record of 5-5 and with Seattle and St. Louis both owning a 2 game lead in the NFC West, every game from this point on is a must win if the 49ers wish to keep their playoff hopes alive.

It is clear that head coach Dennis Erickson is in no hurry to get Jeff Garcia back in there behind center. Rattay has been sharp in the first two starts of his career. He has beaten the heavily favored St. Louis Rams and shined in the Monday Night Football spotlight against the Pittsburgh Steelers.

In those starts, he has hit his receivers 40 times out of his 54 passes. That's a completion percentage of 74%. Not bad. Those completions have combined for a total of 490 yards, 5 touchdowns, and only one interception. Rattay also has a quarterback rating of 113.2.

To put this into perspective, in 8 games, Jeff Garcia has completed about 55% of his passes averaging about 190 yards per game with a quarterback rating of 72.0. In those games, he has thrown 8 touchdowns and 8 interceptions.

Is Tim Rattay the future? Is there any doubt? Is Tim Rattay the present? Well, according to Dennis Erickson, the job belongs to Garcia and he will be back in there once he is at 100%. Of course it is Erickson holding him out in favor of Rattay so it is his call on when Jeff will be declared 100%. If it were up to Garcia, he would be the one starting on Sunday. In fact, if it were up to Garcia, he would have been ready to go against the Steelers. However, you have to wonder what the call will be if Rattay leads the 49ers to a convincing win against the Packers. Unlike Garcia, who is more mobile and at times more jumpy, Rattay is calm and cool in the pocket and appears to be reading defenses with great ease. He is getting the ball down the field, which is not only making Owens happy, but also making coach Dennis Erickson, who favors the deap ball, very happy.

In Garcia's defense, he has been the victim of nearly every injury you can think of. He has also had the misfortune of playing behind a very shaky offensive line. The line is now pretty healthy and protecting Rattay very well. Plus, it does not hurt that the 49ers running game is moving into high gear. This takes a lot pressure off of Rattay.

The bottom line is that if Rattay continues to impress, there is no doubt that the quarterback controversy in San Francisco will continue to brew. The job is Rattay's to lose despite Erickson's claims that Garcia is his man. Garcia will have to earn his spot back not only by getting healthy as quickly as possible, but by playing better when he is asked to step in.

Surging Defense

While the Packers and 49ers are pretty evenly ranked offensively at 5 and 6 respectively, the 49ers hold the advantage on defense. The 49ers are ranked 8th in total defense compared to the Packers who are ranked 25th overall. Even with linebacker Jamie Winborn's season ending early with a neck injury, the 49ers defense played hard on Monday night against the Steelers. The defensive line is disrupting the backfield getting pressure on the quarterbacks and knocking down running backs for a loss.

Linebacker Julian Peterson is one of the players the 49ers must make a real effort to sign in the offseason. He has turned into one of the premiere linebackers in the league due to his natural speed, ability to read a play, and versatility. He can do everything from stopping the run to helping the defensive line with the pass rush and cover speedy receivers. He has become a leader on defense and one of the most valuable members of the team.

The biggest surprise on defense has to be cornerback Mike Rumph. A first round pick in 2002, Rumph was considered by many to be a bust after being the victim of many deep passes last year. However, this year he has held his own very well starting for injured cornerback Jason Webster. He is sticking to receivers better and not biting on fakes as much. Best of all, he is recovering nicely when he does make a mistake. He is not only playing harder, but smarter as well. Hopefully, this season is a glimpse into his bright future with the team.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Jimmy Garoppolo fighting perception, looking to prove he can lead 49ers

By Sasha D. Robinson
Nov 24

Is the Jimmy Garoppolo who threw for 228 yards and four touchdowns the guy San Francisco 49ers fans were looking for or is this an illusion like last year? Since stepping back into the starting role for quarterback Trey Lance, who suffered an ankle injury in Week 2 against the Seattle Seahawks, the 49ers have a 6-3 record. Garoppolo has thrown 15 touchdowns and four interceptions, but there is something different about him this year compared to his past couple of years with the team. Garoppolo does not look like the same player who lost a heartbreaker in last year's NFC Championship Game. Instead, he has the fiery presence of someone you want to follow on and off the field. Even the former Eastern Illinois Panther quarterback's deep ball seems to have more



Steve Young believes Kyle Shanahan's conservative play-calling is due to 49ers QB Jimmy Garoppolo

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

Is Kyle Shanahan's play-calling too conservative? Many watching Sunday night's game against the Los Angeles Chargers might say it is. The San Francisco 49ers offense scores an average of 22 points per game, ranking 18th in the NFL. Coincidentally, that's exactly how many points they scored in the win over the Chargers. Most would think the 49ers should score more on offense rather than stalling and settling for field goals. There is too much talent on the roster with playmakers like Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk, George Kittle, Kyle Juszczyk, Jauan Jennings, and recently-added running back Christian McCaffrey. On Monday, Shanahan was asked if he felt his offense wasn't clicking and if anything could be done to increase production in the second half of the season.



49ers-Cardinals Injury Report: No Arik Armstead, Samson Ebukam at practice in Colorado

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Week 11 contest against the Arizona Cardinals on Monday night at Estadio Azteca in Mexico City. This week, the team is practicing at the United States Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, about an hour south of Denver, to get acclimated to the altitude. Head coach Kyle Shanahan has already ruled out defensive tackle Javon Kinlaw for Monday's game. Kinlaw remains on injured reserve due to a setback in his surgically reconstructed knee. He did not make the trip with the team. Also missing from Thursday's practice, the first of the week, was defensive lineman Arik Armstead. He is dealing with foot and



49ers Notebook: Shanahan on Cardinals' QB uncertainty, Williams tipping plays, Colorado weather; Lynch on Ndamukong Suh interest

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

The San Francisco 49ers are holding their three practices this week at the United States Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, about an hour south of Denver, to get acclimated to the altitude. On Sunday, the team will travel to Mexico City for Monday night's game against the Arizona Cardinals at Estadio Azteca. Which quarterback will the 49ers defense face when they take the field? No one is really sure. Both Cardinals quarterbacks are day-to-day with injuries. Kyler Murray is dealing with a hamstring injury that kept him out this past weekend against the Los Angeles Rams, while McCoy is working through a knee injury suffered in that game. Both


Featured

More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone