Podcast: 49ers & NFC West Free Agency Updates →
Chuck Cook-USA TODAY Sports

Chuck Cook-USA TODAY Sports


NFL’s Racist Past Has a Part in the Jones Versus Fields Debate

Levin T. Black
Mar 31, 2021 at 6:00 AM


It's time to address the elephant in the room. Racism has helped Mac Jones' stock and hurt Justin Fields' in the lead-up to the draft. Yes, it really is happening.

Now before you freak out, take a breath, and keep reading because I don't mean what you likely think I mean. No, I don't think draft pundits are sitting at their keyboards and purposefully finding reasons to knock Fields while talking up Jones simply because of the color of their skin.

That would be what I would call blatant racism or conscious racism, if you will. Racism has more nuance than that. There is such a thing as unconscious racism and every single person in this country has acted on it at one point or another without realizing it.

How? Why? Because racism has purposefully been built into the very makeup of our society. It is so common, so ingrained, few notice it for what it is anymore.

I'm not going to launch into a non-sports-related topic as diverse and complicated as what our country was built on and how the rules were purposefully set up to give the advantages to those who got to make the rules (look at school district budgets). It's not what you are here for. However, I will explain how it is affecting the quarterback prospects in this year's NFL Draft.

There are two main ways. I'll begin with the bias towards the norm. It is human nature to resist change. Change brings risk. For 75 years a quarterback has looked and played a certain way. Immobile, scan the field pocket passers.

It worked for Johnny Unitas, it worked for Joe Montana, it worked for Peyton Manning and it's working for Tom Brady. A bias has developed towards that type of quarterback because that is all the league has had for most of its history.

The new-age mobile quarterback represents change and it has only really been common during the past decade. This means it is still in its infancy. The thing is, it's taken this long to become common due to the racist past of the NFL.

The athletic quarterbacks are predominantly black. Up until recently, there was a strong and well-documented belief that black quarterbacks weren't smart enough to succeed in the NFL. You can research that on your own. It is undeniable but I will provide you with one example.

Warren Moon is quite possibly the best pure thrower of a football the league has ever seen. Despite leading the University of Washington to a Pac-8 championship, a Rose Bowl victory, and being named the conference player of the year, Moon didn't get an opportunity in the NFL.

Instead, Moon had to go to the Canadian Football League, win five straight Grey Cups (championships) and a Most Valuable Player award before he would get a chance in the NFL.

The racism that delayed the rise of more athletic quarterbacks goes deeper than NFL teams, though. Many of the top colleges didn't give black quarterbacks opportunities, meaning many had to either swap positions (still prevalent today) or go to a small historically black college where the NFL could have justification for ignoring their abilities.

Heck, you can go to the grade school level when kids first start playing. Who is often picked to be the quarterback? It's not a coincidence so many of the quarterbacks in the NFL, especially historically, were clean-cut, All-American white guys. Those roots start at the pee-wee level.

How many great quarterbacks were lost because of this racism? How many ended up having lesser careers at other positions? These are two questions that I sometimes ponder.

Let's also not pretend blatant racism is completely gone from today's NFL. Who are the owners? Rich, old white guys full of privilege and stuck in their upbringing from before the civil rights movement. No, not all owners are this way. I wouldn't even say most. But enough are. (Jed York is not one of them. He is as progressive an owner as there is.)

Now we get to the second main way racism is indeed playing its part in this situation. White quarterbacks are given the benefit of the doubt while black quarterbacks are not.

San Francisco 49ers fans should know this better than most. Colin Kaepernick being blacklisted from the NFL (he literally won a large settlement) wasn't because of some hollow excuse about patriotism. Those old white owners didn't like a black man disobeying.

Even after Kaepernick announced he would no longer kneel, no offer came. It wasn't about the kneeling. No second chances for him, which brings me to Jones.

How many of you are aware he had a DUI while in college? I wasn't until recently. Why? Because NO ONE brings it up. It's been ignored. If Fields had a DUI in his past there's no doubt it would be brought up as a character flaw. Jones, who was involved in a minor car accident at the time of the DUI, was also charged with improper identification (fake ID) at the same time as his DUI.

Along with that, if Fields was carrying around 20 extra pounds he'd be called lazy or be said to be not dedicated to the sport or that he doesn't love football ... take your pick. It would be a major talking point debated and brought up constantly and used as a reason he shouldn't be taken in the top 5.

Jones has that extra weight, and the DUI, and yet has skyrocketed up boards. This is despite being unexceptional. He's not a good athlete, he doesn't have a cannon, he is accurate but Fields has been more accurate in college. He's not bad at anything but not so great at anything to justify ignoring negatives.

So why is he rumored to be in contention for being selected before Fields? It's that traditional quarterback mold I mentioned earlier. For lack of a better word, he's vanilla. He's the safe, reliable selection even though he clearly has multiple character question marks and doesn't possess the same upside as a prospect like Fields.

Allow me to wrap this up with two points I think are important to stress.

First, I don't think ANY talent evaluators or draft pundits are basing their rankings on the color of skin. I do think SOME are unconsciously affected by standards that exist due to racism.

Second, yes, I am white. I believe it is vitally important for anyone to call racism for what it is, but it is especially true for white people. When one group has the majority and the power, change won't come, at least not completely, until that group sees it AND acts on it. Racism has come a long way recently but it would improve so much more if white people cared as much as those negatively affected.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Packers' Christian Watson: 49ers QB Trey Lance has "everything that it takes"

By David Bonilla
Mar 23

Trey Lance entered this past season as the starting quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers. However, a season-ending ankle injury during Week 2 ended his 2022 campaign, opening the door for Jimmy Garoppolo and, eventually, rookie Brock Purdy. Purdy, the last overall pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, showed that he could play at the pro level. The first-year passer entered the game for an injured Garoppolo, leading the 49ers to a Week 13 win over the Miami Dolphins, followed by seven consecutive victories as a starter. Had Purdy not suffered a tear of the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) in his right elbow in the NFC Championship Game against the Philadelphia Eagles, he would likely be the undisputed Week 1 starter for the 2023 season. Of course, the 49ers



Three 49ers rank in NFL's top 25 performance-based payouts

By David Bonilla
Mar 17

Three San Francisco 49ers players are receiving a nice little bonus for their on-field efforts during the 2022 NFL season. Safeties Tashaun Gipson and Talanoa Hufanga, and center Jake Brendel are among the NFL's top 25 performance-based pay distributions for this past season. The NFL Communications staff released the list on Friday morning. Gipson will receive a $708,106 bonus. The safety recently re-signed with the 49ers on a one-year deal. Hufanga will receive $703,926, and Brendel earns $643,691. NFL players will receive $336 million in performance-based pay. The performance-based pay program is a collectively bargained benefit that compensates all players based on their playing time and salary levels. The program was first implemented as part of the 2002



Seven 49ers free agents still searching for an NFL team

By David Bonilla
Mar 20

The first week of NFL free agency is in the books, and there has been a lot of movement made by the San Francisco 49ers. The team added defensive tackle Javon Hargrave, quarterback Sam Darnold, and others to the roster. As is the case every year, departures are inevitable. Gone are some high-profile names like quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (Raiders) and tackle Mike McGlinchey (Broncos). Key players like cornerback Emmanuel Moseley (Lions) and offensive lineman Daniel Brunskill (Titans) have also found new NFL homes. San Francisco has tendered a one-year deal to exclusive-rights free agent wide receiver Jauan Jennings. In addition, the following eight 49ers restricted or unrestricted free agents have returned to the team. C Jake



NFL Draft: 49ers meeting with Wisconsin OL Tyler Beach

By David Bonilla
Mar 23

According to Rohan Chakravarthi, the San Francisco 49ers spoke with Wisconsin offensive lineman Tyler Beach on Thursday at the school's pro day. Area scout Ryan Kessenich plans to meet with the player after the event. Can confirm that G/T Tyler Beach has spoken with the #49ers.He's expected to meet with area scout Ryan Kessenich after today's Pro Day.#49wz— Rohan Chakravarthi (@RohanChakrav)


Featured

More by Levin T. Black

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone