Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports

Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports


49ers Shouldn’t Sign Antonio Brown to Replace Injured Jalen Hurd

Levin T. Black
Aug 17, 2020 at 12:06 PM0


The tantalizing possibilities the San Francisco 49ers were going to have with 2019 third round wide receiver Jalen Hurd have been put on hold. Again.

Hurd has yet to play a down for the 49ers. He missed all of the 2019 season with a back injury. It was a rotten development after scoring two touchdowns in a preseason appearance.

There's no preseason this year and according to multiple reports, there won't be a regular season for Hurd either. The receiver got an MRI on Monday. It is believed the WR has a torn ACL, although no confirmation from the 49ers as of the publishing of this article.

The heartbreaking injury has led some to speculate on the 49ers potentially make a splash signing to replace Hurd. Antonio Brown and Dez Bryant, the usual suspects, have been mentioned specifically.

There doesn't seem to be a need. As was stated earlier, Hurd hasn't played a down for the 49ers so what are they needing to replace? Hurd would certainly bring value to the team if healthy but the team has plenty of depth at the position and how much Hurd was going to play was very much in question.

The 49ers have first round pick Brandon Aiyuk, who is impressing and looks primed for a starting role. Of course, last year's leading receiver, Deebo Samuel, will be back sometime in the first half of the season giving the 49ers a second clear starter.

Following those two on the depth chart is Trent Taylor. With Taylor healthy and a favorite target of quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, he is likely to have a big role in the slot position and come in at No. 3 on the depth chart.

We're down to the fourth spot already and Kendrick Bourne hasn't been mentioned. Bourne is a solid backup at both outside WR positions in coach Kyle Shanahan's offensive system.

He has demonstrated a particular expertise in short yardage. He caught and scored a touchdown on all five of his targets inside the 10-yard line last season. Only two players scored more touchdowns from that close and neither of them had the 100 percent success rate Bourne managed.

The void seemingly created by the loss of the big bodied Hurd would be in short yardage, near the goalline situations. Bourne makes that void negligible.

Filling out the depth chart is Dante Pettis, rookie Jauan Jennings and recent veteran signings J.J. Nelson and Tavon Austin. Pettis in particular stands to benefit. His roster spot was in question and his opportunity to earn one was going to be limited with Hurd needing plenty of practice to get ready after not playing as a rookie.

The team may bring in another veteran on a minimum deal just to give it another body in camp and potential replacement if a COVID-19 outbreak leaves it without multiple WRs. It already has a workout scheduled with one.


As of now, the 49ers have eight WRs who are good enough to be on an NFL roster. Helping move the chains through the air is the 49ers quality receiving options in the backfield and perhaps the league's best tight end duo in George Kittle and Jordan Reed.

The injury to Hurd is a terrible development for him personally but simply put, the 49ers have all the options needed to excel in the passing game without him. No panic button needed.
  • Levin T. Black
  • Written by:
    A graduate of Ball State University in 2009, Levin was an award winning sports journalist until he transitioned into a different career. He's written for Webzone since 2018.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Here's how John Lynch responded when asked if 49ers might be interested in Antonio Brown

By David Bonilla
Jan 8

Wide receiver Antonio Brown cleared waivers on Friday after being released by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Thursday. That officially makes him a free agent. However, teams may be hesitant to sign him given how things ended with his former team. During the third quarter of the Buccaneers' Week 17 contest against the New York Jets, Brown shockingly took off his helmet, jersey, and pads, and then exited MetLife Stadium. "He is no longer a Buc," head coach Bruce Arians said after the game. On Friday morning, before Brown cleared waivers, San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch took part in his weekly KNBR interview. Surprisingly, he was asked if his team might be interested in Brown given his 49ers might be headed to the playoffs with a win over



49ers-Cowboys: Jimmy Garoppolo provides an update on his injured thumb

By David Bonilla
Jan 12

San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo played through a significant amount of pain during Sunday's 27-24 playoff-clinching overtime win against the Los Angeles Rams. He is dealing with a torn ligament and chipped bone in his right thumb, making throwing a football a challenge. Garoppolo could require offseason surgery. Right now, he is focused on the 49ers' playoff opponent—the Dallas Cowboys. Garoppolo spoke with reporters via Zoom before Wednesday's practice. He was asked how his thumb felt after Sunday's thrilling game and how it felt on Wednesday as the 49ers start preparing for the Cowboys. "The thumb held up pretty well,"



49ers-Cowboys: Fred Warner injured late in the game

By David Bonilla
Jan 16

It didn't look good for Fred Warner. The San Francisco 49ers linebacker went down in the fourth quarter and was clutching his left leg in obvious pain. It was a non-contact injury on the Cowboys drive that followed the interception thrown by quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo. Dallas ended up scoring on the drive. San Francisco still leads 23-17 at the time of this post. Warner played in 16 games this season, racking up 137 tackles, seven tackles for a loss, three quarterback hits, 0.5 sacks, four passes defensed, a forced fumble, and three fumble recoveries heading into this playoff game, per Pro Football Reference. Update: The 49ers announced that Warner is "questionable" to return due to an ankle



Comparing Offensive Rosters: 2019 49ers vs. 2021 49ers

By Brian Renick
Jan 11

The San Francisco 49ers are heading back to the playoffs for the first time since their 2019 Super Bowl run after a thrilling Week 18 overtime victory against the NFC West champion Los Angeles Rams. The 49ers were a 13-3 powerhouse in 2019, earning the #1 seed and a first-round bye, but this 2021 version, a 10-game winner and the 6th seed, may actually be better positioned to win it all than the 2019 squad. Let's compare the offensive position groups from each season to see who has the edge. Quarterback 2019 Jimmy Garoppolo 16 games, 329/476 69.1%, 3978 yds, 27 TDs and 13 INTs, 2.7 INT% Nick Mullens 2021 Jimmy Garoppolo 15 games,


Featured

More by Levin T. Black

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone