49ers sign 1st-round draft pick Trey Lance to 4-yr, $34.1 million deal →
Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports


The 49ers Are Better Off Passing on Adams and Sticking with Tartt as Things Sit Right Now

Levin T. Black
Jul 13, 2020 at 6:00 AM0


(This is a follow up to an earlier article that explained the 49ers can afford Jamal Adams)

Just because something can be acquired doesn't mean it should be. That is my stance when it comes to the idea of the San Francisco 49ers trading for the New York Jets' Jamal Adams.

The 49ers have the capital needed to acquire Adams between the team's draft capital and current players. On some levels it make sense to do what it takes to add the All-Pro player but ultimately the team shouldn't.

Incumbent strong safety Jaquiski Tartt is a free agent following the 2020 season. The 49ers have likely inquired about what kind of extension Tartt is seeking. The lack of news on that is a sign the two parties are not on the same page. It is certainly possible, with the way this 49ers front office has kept things quiet, that the two are close to an extension but it seems very unlikely.

It is also possible the 49ers prefer a cheaper, younger option at the position after this season and have simply not pursued an extension with Tartt. That is not to say Tartt isn't a quality player. He's a good starter who falls just short of being great.

The biggest hindrance to a long-term extension could be Tartt's injury history. He has missed at least four games in each of the past three seasons and 19 total in that time frame. Tartt plays a very physical position and is headed into his late-20s. Signing him to multi-year deal seems too high of a risk at this juncture.

I can see why fans, and even some 49ers players, are excited by the opportunity to add Adams. He is not only better than Tartt, he's younger and a safer bet to pay big money to in an extension.

My hang up in this enticing proposition is simply salary cap allocation. The 49ers can not afford to pay their entire defense top dollar. They have already given out big contracts to multiple players on the defensive line (Dee Ford, Arik Armstead), a linebacker (Kwon Alexander), and a corner (Richard Sherman) and free safety Jimmie Ward just signed a decent sized extension (13th highest paid safety in league).

Adding to this is the escalating salary, due to being taken No. 2 overall, of Nick Bosa, an extension for Fred Warner next year and an extension or replacement for Sherman next year as well. That's just the defensive side. Obviously the offense also has some big names due for extensions (George Kittle and Trent Williams are the biggest two).

The 49ers could trade for and pay Adams but it means being unable to afford someone else. I'm not completely against the idea. Adams is truly a dynamic player. Adding him to the 49ers defense gives it a chance to be an all-time great defense with good health in 2020.

Yes, the 49ers can shed Alexander's big contract next year with a manageable dead cap hit. That alone probably isn't enough, though. Ford is also an option for cap savings next offseason but he carries a bit higher dead cap penalty.

The 49ers can make it work with an Adams extension. They would, without a doubt, be better in 2020. Past 2020 is questionable and that really is my issue.

The 49ers can stick with Tartt and still be a strong favorite in the NFC this year and then enter the draft as one of the few teams without a glaring hole. This would allow them to target a safety early.

Safety has also been a position with veteran bargains late in the free agency period. Tre Boston is the prime example of a quality vet safety signed to a multi-year deal at a discounted rate.

I prefer the 49ers to hold their ground ... for now. Maybe, if Adams truly holds out, the ability to swindle the Jets develops in the future.

The safety position has seen its value rise considerably in recent years so maybe I'm behind the times, but I simply don't view the position as valuable enough to spend top dollar on. This is one of the advantages of having a dominant pass rush. You don't need as great of a secondary.

There is a belief system out there that any time you can add a true game-changer, you do it. I get it. I'm not totally opposed to this line of thinking. I don't view this specific scenario as a black and white, must do it or it's a mistake to do it.

The 49ers are in a good position whether they trade for Adams or not. I will say, I have no interest in seeing Adams twice a year on the Seattle Seahawks. Maybe trading for him is the right move after all, if only to keep him away from that ugly green and blue.

Call me a fence sitter if you want. There isn't a definite correct position to every sports topic. As a columnist I'm supposed to find one and defend it. I prefer to stay true to my beliefs rather than take up a position I don't truly support.

Maybe that's why I still have a day job and do this on the side. I do accept donations though. You can reach me on Twitter.
  • Levin T. Black
  • Written by:
    A graduate of Ball State University in 2009, Levin was an award winning sports journalist until he transitioned into a different career. He's written for Webzone since 2018.
The views within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



49ers' Kyle Shanahan: 'There's no open competition right now' between Jimmy Garoppolo, Trey Lance

By Kirk Larrabee
22 hrs ago

Trey Lance may well find himself as the starting quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers before the season's out, but he clearly won't be starting training camp that way based on what head coach Kyle Shanahan said Tuesday. The 49ers obviously plan on Lance eventually being the starter over incumbent Jimmy Garoppolo after trading up to select him with the third overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft. But as of now, the job remains Garoppolo's to lose. "There's no open competition right now in terms of they're getting equal reps with the same group," Shanahan told reporters Tuesday, one day before the start of camp. "Jimmy's coming in as the one and Trey's coming in as the two." Lance



49ers' Jeff Wilson, Tarvarius Moore to start camp on PUP; Updates on Jaquiski Tartt, Nick Bosa, Dee Ford, Jalen Hurd

By David Bonilla
21 hrs ago

On Tuesday, San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch informed reporters that running back Jeff Wilson Jr. and safety Tarvarius Moore are being placed on the active/physical-unable-to-perform (PUP) list as the team prepares to kick off training camp. Wilson suffered a non-contact knee injury in May. Moore underwent surgery after suffering a torn Achilles during practice in June. "[Players are] going through physicals today, and if there are any additions, Kyle (Shanahan) will hit you up in the coming days," Lynch said. "But that's where we are right now." Lynch and Shanahan were asked if there were any other potential candidates that they knew of. "A couple of guys that you know had some things that we'll see on their physicals, if



John Lynch: 49ers defense 'feeds off' Fred Warner's leadership and energy

By David Bonilla
Jul 22, 2021

The San Francisco 49ers officially announced the five-year extension for star linebacker Fred Warner. News of the deal was first reported yesterday. The $95.225 million contract could keep the All-Pro defender with San Francisco through the 2026 season. "We're extremely excited to have completed a long-term contract extension with Fred prior to the start of training camp," general manager John Lynch said via a statement. "Fred brings the type of leadership and energy every day that our defense and team feeds off. He earned this extension through hard work, discipline, and the professional way he goes about his business. We look forward to watching him continue to play at an



49ers claim return specialist Nsimba Webster off waivers

By David Bonilla
Jul 21, 2021

According to Aaron Wilson, the San Francisco 49ers have claimed wide receiver and return specialist Nsimba Webster off waivers from the Los Angeles Rams. Nsimba Webster claimed by 49ers off waivers from Rams— Aaron Wilson (@AaronWilson_NFL) July 21, 2021 The Rams signed Webster (5-10, 180) as an undrafted free agent out of Eastern Washington in 2019. He didn't register any catches in his two NFL


Featured

More by Levin T. Black

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone