Geoff Burke-USA TODAY Sports

Geoff Burke-USA TODAY Sports


Why the 49ers should steer clear of Le’Veon Bell in 2019

Bobby Horne
Jul 18, 2018 at 5:36 PM


The San Francisco 49ers and disgruntled Pittsburgh Steelers running back Le'Veon Bell will continue to be connected to each other throughout the 2018 season and into 2019 free agency for no other reason than money.

Bell's contract situation with the Steelers hasn't been a smooth process as he recently declined the Steelers' final offer of 5-years, $70 million and chose to play on the $14.5 million franchise tag for the second year in a row. It's safe to say that in 2019 he will likely be on the market as it seems there is bad blood between the two parties.


Per Over the Cap, the 49ers are projected roughly $75 million in salary cap space after factoring in the rollover from 2018. That's a lot of money, certainly enough to pay Bell whatever he wants. But should they? No.

Don't get me wrong here, I firmly believe that Bell is the best RB in the league and think that even the $14.5 million he is making on the franchise tag is not enough. However, there is more to consider than just paying Bell because he's good.

Bell is one of the most productive players in NFL history, averaging 1,599 total yards and eight touchdowns per season during his five-year career. Will the on-field production carry over from Pittsburgh to San Francisco? If so, is it enough to justify paying Bell double 49ers running back Jerick McKinnon's $7.5 million annual average salary?

Can Bell have similar success in San Francisco? I don't think so. That's not to say that I don't think he could be productive with the 49ers, but looking a little deeper, Bell's success should be partially contributed to playing alongside quarterback Ben Roethlisberger and receiver Antonio Brown - both Hall of Fame-caliber players.

Defenses are weary of stacking the box with eight defenders with Brown out wide as Bell only faced eight or more defenders on 19.94% of his charted runs. Bell has almost always had space to work with. The 49ers don't currently have the talent out wide that the Steelers do. Defenses would stack the box and put the pressure on Bell all game long, forcing 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo to beat them with his arm, likely decreasing Bell's production.

Beyond that, the 49ers need to think about longevity. Bell has over 1500 touches in his career and averages 308 per season. That's a lot of miles for a 26-year-old running back who will likely want a long-term deal with high guarantees - something the 49ers haven't been keen on doing outside of quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo. There's little chance the 49ers would be willing to shell out major guarantees for a back nearing 30 years old and close to 2,000 touches.

McKinnon, who is the same age and has almost 1,000 fewer touches, could put up numbers close to what we would expect from Bell in coach Kyle Shanahan's offense. That doesn't mean that I'm comparing the two, but Shanahan knows how to get the best out of his players.

In 2017, former 49ers running back Carlos Hyde managed to rack up 1,288 total yards and eight touchdowns. It's unclear how well McKinnon will do, but it isn't a stretch to say that he can top those numbers in 2018. McKinnon is a quicker and more elusive back with better ability as a receiver.

With the aforementioned considered, you can start to seehow signing Bell to a mega-deal might not hold value for the 49ers. They have made all the right moves so far in the current regime and inking the league's highest-paid running back would be the first move that could set them back in the long run.

The money they would spend bringing in Bell would be better invested into the defense's lack of pass rush. The 2019 free agent market may see the availability of premier pass-rushing talent in Dallas Cowboys' Demarcus Lawrence and Detroit Lions' Ezekiel Ansah. Both would be better options as the 49ers can likely muster solid production from their current running back for much less money.

As flashy as it would be to see Bell in the red and gold, it would be a costly mistake that could keep the franchise from taking its next step towards a Super Bowl run.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Baldinger explains why 49ers' Kyle Shanahan should have challenged the catch vs. Eagles

By David Bonilla
Jan 31

It wasn't a catch. We learned that soon after the Philadelphia Eagles quickly got back to the line of scrimmage and ran another play, after which the San Francisco 49ers could do nothing. In what looked like an amazing one-handed leaping grab by DeVonta Smith, replays showed that the Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver failed to maintain possession. Many feel that, in the end, it would not have mattered. The Eagles ended up winning the NFC Championship Game 31-7. Maybe it would have mattered, though. Who knows what would have happened had officials overturned that play call? The drive would have ended because it was a 29-yard catch



Why Baldinger says the 49ers should avoid signing Tom Brady

By David Bonilla
Jan 31

After watching injury after injury devastate the San Francisco 49ers quarterback room this season, several fans on social media are willing to see what adding a veteran like Tom Brady might do to improve the team's outlook. If you don't count the four games he was suspended in 2016, Brady has started every game in all but one season since 2002. Meanwhile, Kyle Shanahan has started six different quarterbacks since becoming the 49ers' head coach in 2017. Unfortunately, he can't seem to keep his signal callers healthy. Of course, there is also a very vocal group of fans against a potential Brady signing. Their reasoning is sound. Brady will be 46 years old at the start of the 2023 season. In hindsight, the 49ers probably should have signed Brady in 2020, when they



Should the 49ers cut DT Javon Kinlaw?

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Jan 30

The offseason is officially upon us, as the San Francisco 49ers were eliminated by the Philadelphia Eagles in the NFC Championship Game to a score of 31-7 after losing quarterback Brock Purdy to injury on their first offensive drive. The 49ers have many personnel decisions to make, as 25 players are currently scheduled for free agency, but there are other tough situations to handle, such as the contract of former first-round pick Javon Kinlaw, who has not looked the same post-injury, especially during his second stint with the team this season at the end of the year. Kinlaw, however, has a fully-guaranteed cap hit of $4.928 million in 2022, which would force the 49ers to take in that amount in dead cap money if they choose to move on. So, should the



Should the 49ers re-sign RT Mike McGlinchey?

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Jan 30

The San Francisco 49ers are now focused on the offseason, with their season ending at the hands of the Philadelphia Eagles in a 31-7 loss on Sunday in the NFC Championship Game. Which means it's time for personnel decisions, likely coaching staff departures, and of course, quarterback talk. But, one of the biggest questions that the 49ers face come with free agent right tackle Mike McGlinchey, who is likely to earn the most money of any San Francisco free agent in 2022. McGlinchey has faced his ups and downs as a 49er, but has been a valuable run-defender, and the starting right tackle for the past five seasons. However, he is likely to command a hefty salary on the open market, and could look for a fresh opportunity after the amount of


Featured

More by Bobby Horne

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone