Trevor Ruszkowski-USA TODAY Sports
2018 NFL Draft: 49ers taking OT Mike McGlinchey makes a lot more sense now, doesn’t it?
The San Francisco 49ers appeared to pull off something of a shocker at No. 9 in the 2018 NFL Draft, grabbing Notre Dame offensive tackle Mike McGlinchey instead of one of the top-name defenders. But subsequent moves, like trading fellow OT Trent Brown to the New England Patriots, justify the selection a lot.
Raise your hand if you were among those who felt the San Francisco 49ers would take an offensive tackle with their first pick in the 2018 NFL Draft.
Well, that's what they did, grabbing Notre Dame offensive tackle Mike McGlinchey at No. 9 overall. Not Alabama defensive back Minkah Fitzpatrick (No. 11), not EDGE Marcus Davenport (No. 14), not linebacker Tremaine Edmunds (No. 16) and not defensive back Derwin James (No. 17). No, San Francisco elected to go offense and build from the trenches.
Shocking, perhaps. It seemed like a safe pick at the time. After all, it's in the best interests of the 49ers to protect quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo.
McGlinchey appeared to be a reach -- a luxury pick after Round 1's conclusion. That was, of course, until general manager John Lynch pulled off a trade, sending starting right tackle Trent Brown to the New England Patriots and the team's fifth-round pick, No. 143 overall, in exchange for pick No. 95 overall. News of the deal was first reported by
ESPN's Adam Schefter and Field Yates.
OK.
Now we get it.
Brown, who was heading into a
contract year anyway, missed six games with various injuries last year. The most serious was a shoulder injury, which required surgery and likely influenced Brown showing up to the team's first minicamp out of shape, per
DraftAnalyst.com's Tony Pauline. Sure, Brown was among the better pass-blocking tackles in the NFL last season.
Pro Football Focus ranked him No. 8 among qualifiers in this category. Yet Brown's run-blocking abilities, particularly in head coach Kyle Shanahan's outside-zone scheme, weren't particularly great.
49ers Webzone's Rich Madrid highlighted this
in a piece for Niner Noise prior to 2017. It's safe to assume Brown failed to improve his own stock over the course of last year.
So the McGlinchey pick makes sense from this vantage point. He's now the shoo-in starter at right tackle. And with left tackle Joe Staley turning 34 years old this August, McGlinchey may easily wind up being the six-time Pro Bowler's eventual replacement.
But what about all those secondary needs, particularly the aforementioned prospect names at safety?
Yeah, there's a reason behind the Niners passing on them too.
49ers Extending Jaquiski Tartt Negates a Need at Safety
Heading into 2018, the 49ers appeared set at safety. After all, they let veteran defensive back Eric Reid walk in free agency, poised to roll with safeties Jaquiski Tartt, Jimmie Ward and Adrian Colbert competing for the two starting jobs.
But Ward and Tartt were going to hit contract years this season. And with both landing on season-ending injured reserve a year ago, it's not hard to fathom the idea of San Francisco grabbing a safety with its first pick in the draft. A prospect like Fitzpatrick or James would have made a lot of sense, especially looking at the long-term scheme of things.
That was, of course, until the Niners inked Tartt to a
two-year extension, keeping him on the roster through 2020.
Sure, the injury last year is a mild concern. Prior to that, though, Tartt appeared in 30 out of 32 possible games after being selected in Round 2 of the 2015 NFL Draft. So it's not like this is a chronic, repeated issue.
Tack on Tartt's 85.8
overall PFF grade last year -- highest among all Niners defensive backs -- and it doesn't appear safety was one of the team's pressing offseason needs.
True, San Francisco still needs help in the pass rush. Linebacker depth is a concern, and a big-bodied wide receiver to help out in the red zone would be helpful. And while the McGlinchey pickup seemed strange at first, sifting through the aftermath helps it make a lot of sense.
-
Written by:
Peter Panacy has been writing about the 49ers since 2011 for outlets like Bleacher Report, Niner Noise, 49ers Webzone, and is occasionally heard as a guest on San Francisco's 95.7 FM The Game and the Niners' flagship station, KNBR 680. Feel free to follow him, or direct any inquiries to his Twitter account.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
-
AJ Dembroski
I find the number of people using "protect Jimmy" as a justification for taking this guy amusing. Tells me you've done no research.
He wasn't drafted to protect Jimmy. In fact, he probably wouldn't have been taking if Jimmy wasn't so good at protecting himself. He was taken to help the running game. If your primary goal is to protect the QB, you keep Brown, a FAR superior pass blocker. If your goal is to improve the outside zone run game, you take McGlinchey.
McGlinchey was a stupid pick. He's one dimensional, has slow feet, and has his lunch eaten by speed rushers routinely. He's had to publically apologize for costing Notre Dame wins twice during his senior year (Miami and Georgia).
May 1, 2018 at 8:25 PM
More San Francisco 49ers News
SI makes 49ers predictions involving the Super Bowl, Christian McCaffrey, Talanoa Hufanga
Conor Orr continues his annual tradition of making 100 bold predictions for the upcoming season. That's a lot of predictions to sift through. Luckily for you, I've pulled out the San Francisco 49ers-related ones for this article. That doesn't mean the others aren't worth your time, though. So head over to the Sports Illustrated feature to peruse the remaining 96.
For now, here are Orr's 49ers-related predictions.
49ers-Bengals Super Bowl clash
The good news is that Orr predicts the 49ers to be among the Super Bowl participants in February. The bad news is that he has the Cincinnati Bengals handing San Francisco its third
49ers coaches Anthony Lynn, Bobby Turner explain what makes Christian McCaffrey special
Christian McCaffrey arrived with the San Francisco 49ers on October 21, the day after learning the Carolina Panthers traded him. Two days later, the star running back lined up with his new teammates against the Kansas City Chiefs.
McCaffrey ended up elevating the 49ers offense to new heights. He started the next week against the Los Angeles Rams, earning rushing, receiving, and even a passing touchdown against his new division rival. San Francisco won that game and the 11 that followed.
McCaffrey got more comfortable with the offense as the season continued. However, against the Chiefs, the running back's head was spinning. He only had a couple of days with the playbook, after
Brock Purdy vs. Christian McCaffrey: Who is more valuable to the 49ers in 2023?
It's that time of the offseason.
The draft has come and gone, OTAs have just started up, but several months still remain between now and the first snap of the 2023 season. Given the lull in breaking news and big games, it's a good time to get a bit more... philosophical.
Today, I wanted to compare two of the 49ers' biggest playmakers in the 2022 season - rookie QB sensation Brock Purdy and do-it-all RB Christian McCaffrey. The question is simple; given a full, healthy season, who does more to help the 49ers win a Super Bowl this year? Whose talents are the most vital to the annual quest for a Lombardi Trophy, and which one can San Francisco least afford to lose?
These players, of course, play entirely different positions and occupy different roles on
No Huddle Podcast: 49ers Mini-Camp & The Football Movie Draft
(Episode 241) - Brian Renick, Al Saco, and Zain Naqvi react to more Brock Purdy updates, Al has a theory for Trey Lance's future, if we will see a breakout season from Brandon Aiyuk and the embarrassment of riches on offense. Plus, the guys end the show with a football movie draft!
The audio for the show is embedded above. Don't forget to subscribe!
You can listen to the latest "No Huddle Podcast" episode above, from our dedicated podcast page, on
