Jim O\'Connor-USA TODAY Sports

Jim O'Connor-USA TODAY Sports

Cutting Carlos Hyde: A Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Idea

Bret Rumbeck
Jul 25, 2017 at 11:04 AM2

Every February football season dies and every July it is born again. There are just a few short hours left until the polished gold helmets sparkle under the Santa Clara sun. Nary the sound of plastic pads echoing off the glass luxury suites at Levi's Stadium and we're already knee deep in bold predictions on the final San Francisco 49ers roster.

In an article published on July 24, NFL Media Editor Gregg Rosenthal listed 49ers running back Carlos Hyde as a surprise training camp cut.

Coach Kyle Shanahan was going to be "sick" and dreaming of rookie Joe Williams if the team didn't draft him, according to the MMQB's Peter King. So general manager John Lynch wound up trading up to get a guy in Williams who wasn't even on his draft board.

Compare that investment -- emotional and otherwise -- with the team's lukewarm appraisals of Hyde this offseason. A talented and extremely elusive runner, Hyde has one year left on a contract signed three head coaches ago. He's admittedly the biggest long shot to lose his job on this list, but Shanahan and Lynch are just starting their extreme makeover and have proven they are ready to act with conviction.

Naturally, Rosenthal's addition of Hyde set fire to social media news feeds, group text messages, and barroom sports talk.

With any football discussion, readers can find sprinkles of truth among the nonsense, and there's one reason the 49ers may part ways with Carlos Hyde. He's yet to prove he can handle the grind of a full 16 game NFL season due to multiple injuries: an ankle sprain, a concussion, foot fracture, shoulder separation and an MCL tear.

These injuries are concerning because Hyde's entering his fourth year and it sounds like he has the body of a 37-year old running back. 49ers coaches and executives must ask themselves how much punishment Hyde can take before becoming an ineffective back, so it's fair to consider a preseason trade or release.

Enter the 2017 season and a purge and rebuild of the 49ers roster. Right now, there are six running backs and two fullbacks on the roster. Let's assume the team keeps Kyle Juszczyk at fullback, and Tim Hightower, Joe Williams, Matt Breida, and Hyde at running back. Immediately, I see a rotation of these players and finding the right set of plays and situations that maximize favorable outcomes for each.

Additionally, a backfield rotation may result in the 49ers finding the right number of carries for Hyde that allows him to rack up yardage and touchdowns, while saving his body from repeated crashes into linebackers.

A running back rotation may not result in a 1,000-yard rusher, but if the 49ers can rush for more than 1,800 yards as a team, it's going to be a bigger compliment to a passing game that looks to be slightly below average.

Kyle Shanahan is a smart coach. He knows how to tap unknown skills from his players and build confidence in his quarterbacks. Indeed, he will find a way for Hyde to achieve glory in the running game. Don't forget Hyde's played in three different offenses in his career and averaged at least 4 yards per rushing attempt.

Sure, some backs may feel more comfortable in a particular type of running attack. There are running backs who thrive on the grind of lead and power runs, while others may shudder at the slightest thought of hearing "I-Right, 19 Bob" in the huddle. The suggestion that a veteran like Hyde can't make minor adjustments to his running game is illogical.

During the February 9, 2017 press conference introducing John Lynch and Shanahan, Lynch stated that one of Shanahan's best skills as a coach is taking "…players and he plays to their strengths. I think that's what great coaches do. They play to the strengths."

Expect Shanahan to build plays for Hyde that work best for him and in specific situations. Why force Hyde to run plays that Joe Williams or Matt Breida might like more? It's the same with a quarterback who loves being under center. No coach on the planet is going to force that guy to run every pass play out of a gun formation. These kinds of strategies do not set up players for success.

The cold bleakness that blanketed last year's 49ers was equal to the dark side of Pluto, making it hopeless to find any signs of life. However, Hyde finished the year with 988 yards rushing in just 13 games. Thousand-yard rushers do not fall from the sky with winged shoes and abilities enhanced by Earth's yellow sun.

Ultimately, Carlos Hyde's fate is in his own hands. Kyle Shanahan and Bobby Turner need to find a path for Hyde to succeed, and John Lynch needs to retain Hyde at least through this season. A backfield devoid of Carlos Hyde is not the formula for success for the 49ers, not this year and not in the future.
  • Bret Rumbeck
  • Written by:
    Bret Rumbeck has been writing about the 49ers since 2017 for 49ers Webzone and 49ers Hub. He is a Turlock, CA native, and has worked for two members of the US House of Representatives and one US Senator. When not breaking down game film, Bret spends his time seeking out various forms of heavy metal. Feel free to follow him or direct inquiries to @brumbeck.
The views within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • aint chon
    Where did these leaks come from. This shit starting already?? dorks dont ever give up do they...
    Jul 25, 2017 at 11:22 PM
    Response: Thanks for reading. I don't know if it was a leak, but just an 'expert' with a list of possible surprises in training camp. That kind of stuff is the worst part about the off season... endless speculation and stirring pots that don't need stirring.
  • gw2
    I like Joe Williams and Matt Breida, but I would not let go of El Guapo until those guys have done it in this league, behind this line, like Hyde has. So what if he gets hurt again, he can help while he is healthy. I'm a little worried that Joe Williams may be sort of crazy.
    Jul 25, 2017 at 3:10 PM
    Response: Thanks for checking out the article. I'm with you on Williams and Breida.... both guys, along with Hightower, really make me excited to see the running game in action. Plus, I think taking a bit of pressure off Hyde may keep him healthy this year.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Analyst calls the idea that the 49ers traded up for Mac Jones 'a punch to the stomach'

By David Bonilla
Mar 31, 2021

Longtime draft analyst Matt Miller is convinced that the San Francisco 49ers traded up to the No. 3 overall pick for Alabama quarterback Mac Jones, and he doesn't sound too happy about it. He grew up as a Niners fan, and the idea that his favorite NFL team might select Jones over a prospect like Justin Fields of Ohio State disturbs him on two fronts—as a fan and an analyst. "As a lifelong Niners fan, that's such a punch to the stomach," Miller said on the Dan Patrick Show. "I'm trying to trust (general manager) John Lynch and (head coach) Kyle Shanahan, but I remember when they said they didn't need a quarterback and they passed on Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson only to pick up C.J. Beathard in the third round. "I'm still a little gun-shy about

What if? GMFB intrigued by the idea of Kyle Pitts-to-49ers in draft

By David Bonilla
Apr 12, 2021

The San Francisco 49ers traded up to the No. 3 overall pick to select a quarterback. Whether that player is Mac Jones of Alabama, Justin Fields of Ohio State, or Trey Lance of North Dakota State remains to be seen. While one of those three is the most likely target, the Good Morning Football hosts threw out an intriguing scenario. What if head coach Kyle Shanahan really wants the player many see as the most intriguing prospect in the draft—tight end Kyle Pitts of Florida? Now, it is important to note that no one is saying this is even a possibility. It just created an interesting discussion point. When it comes to the three quarterback

Tannenbaum sees Mac Jones as 'very similar' to Matt Ryan, has QB to 49ers in mock draft

By David Bonilla
Apr 6, 2021

Yet another mock draft has the San Francisco 49ers selecting former Alabama quarterback Mac Jones with the No. 3 overall pick. This one from ESPN's Mike Tannenbaum is a bit different, though. While some analysts feel that Jones-to-49ers is the most likely scenario, many feel that the selection would be a reach, especially with potentially higher-ceiling prospects Justin Fields and Trey Lance likely to still be on the board. The latest ESPN mock draft has Tannenbaum, a former NFL executive, playing the role of general manager for all 32 teams and choosing the players he feels are the best fit for

Draft analyst calls Mac Jones-to-49ers speculation 'very premature'

By David Bonilla
Apr 8, 2021

Tony Pauline of Pro Football Network is well-informed when it comes to pre-draft chatter around the league. The draft analyst hears all of the Mac Jones-to-49ers speculation, with many proclaiming the scenario as a near-lock. Pauline wants everyone to pump the brakes on that a bit because he doesn't see it as the certainty that many others would lead you to believe it is. "People, I think, are just under the assumption of belief that it's a foregone conclusion that [the San Francisco 49ers are] going to take Mac Jones with that third pick in the draft," Pauline told Trey Wingo on a recent podcast (h/t to Patrick Tulini). "I'm told that's not the case at all. There are some things that they're looking at with Mac Jones


More by Bret Rumbeck

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone