Can Brian Hoyer Be The Next Alex Smith?

Stewart M. Cockrell
Jul 17, 2017 at 4:23 PM


I know that sounds like an ironic question and in reality many of us would likely wonder why it is even a question worth asking. However, as we are close to the eve of training camp, the idea of the comparison might be a fair one. As most of us 49ers fans will recall, going into the 2011 season there was a lot of uncertainty about Alex Smith and his future with the club. Similarly, in 2017 there is a lot of uncertainty surrounding Brian Hoyer and his future with the team. The question really is whether Brian Hoyer can resurrect his career under upgraded coaching by Shanahan and company.

Leading into the 2011 season, Alex Smith's career had been, for lack of a better term, a train wreck. Smith suffered through six different offensive coordinators and two subpar head coaches who never gave him the pieces to succeed. In 2011, the 49ers brought in Jim Harbaugh and for the first time in his career, Smith began to flourish as he thrived in a system that minimized his weaknesses and maximized his strengths. In addition, the franchise took the burden of success and spread it across a strong running game and a championship-caliber defense. In the 26 games Smith started under Harbaugh and company, he passed for 4,881 yards and 30 touchdowns. In his "injury" shortened 2012 season, during which he was replaced by Colin Kaepernick, Smith was completing 70.2-percent of his passes. While most fans can agree these numbers are not earth-shattering, a look at Alex Smith's career averages up to that point show just how he benefited from the right system and better coaching.

Alex Smith Yrs. 1-5 (Injury Year of 2008 Omitted)
Games Attempts Completions Percentage Avg. TD Avg. Int. Avg. Yds.
54 1,514 864 55.56% 10.2 10.6 1,879.80

Enter: Brian Hoyer, and while his career hasn't been as stable as Alex Smith's, he has had a similar path in the NFL in terms of ups and downs. While Hoyer has been mostly a backup in the league, his 2014 season in Cleveland notwithstanding, there are a lot of similarities between his past five years and Smith's first five years. While the 2014 Cleveland Browns didn't make a ton of noise in the league, it was also the last time they won more than three games, as Hoyer led the team to a 7-6 record as a starter and threw for 3,326 yards under Kyle Shanahan's watch. Looking at the last five seasons in which Hoyer has played, his career stats are actually quite similar to Smith's.

Brian Hoyer Yrs. 2012-2016
Games Attempts Completions Percentage Avg. TD Avg. Int. Avg. Yds.
36 1,156 687 59.80% 8.6 5 1,664.40

While the sample size is admittedly smaller than Smith's, Hoyer has a better completion percentage and TD/INT ratio than Smith did to start his career.

Further evidence proves that Alex Smith has benefited from better coaching and an improved system since his trade to Kansas City. Since his trade following the 2012 season, Smith has played at least 15 games and thrown for at least 3,200 yards and 15 touchdowns each year. He has yet to throw double-digit interceptions in any of his seasons in Kansas City and has averaged a completion percentage of 64.9%. Bolstered by Kansas City's defensive help, Smith and the Chiefs have made the playoffs three times and won their first playoff game in 22 seasons following the 2015 season. In Smith's three playoff losses in Kansas City the margin of defeat is only nine points.

The similarities don't end with just the stats as Hoyer's situation is nearly the same as Smith's in 2011. The 49ers had invested heavily in defense in the years leading up to Harbaugh's hiring and it paid off in 2011, allowing for Smith to not have to shoulder the load for the team. The 49ers have invested heavily in defense over the past three offseasons and while not all of the picks and signings are surefire, there are some gems who could shine if polished right. The 49ers have a strong chance of being a top-20 defense this year, if not higher, if the new scheme works. If Shanahan can use Brian Hoyer much like Harbaugh used Smith during the 2011 season, there could be some bright spots for the 49ers. All signs point towards the 49ers doing just that with a powerful running game and a passing game that takes shots based on the running game's success.

Do the 49ers and their fans really think that Hoyer is the long term answer? I don't think so, but if he can turn into a better-than-average quarterback for the next two years the 49ers can determine if the quarterback of the future is on the team or if more work needs to be done in the draft or free agency. While Smith-like numbers and success can be heartbreaking for fans, as it appears he won't ever be able to get a team over the hump to a championship, winning during the season makes for a more watchable product. And that is something that a lot of fans can probably get behind, at least in the short-term.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


2 Comments

  • Eddd
    No need to insult Brian Hoyer
    Jul 18, 2017 at 6:58 AM
    2
  • Fresh
    Please God no
    Jul 18, 2017 at 6:06 AM
    1

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Alex Mack on 49ers' QB situation: 'I want the guy who's going to win games'

By David Bonilla
Oct 19

The San Francisco 49ers might be approaching a crossroads. Eventually, a quarterback decision will need to be made. Jimmy Garoppolo is the team's undisputed starter right now. However, his injury history made the 49ers uncomfortable to the point that the team drafted Trey Lance this offseason. Lance is the future. He will eventually succeed Garoppolo. When that happens is anybody's guess. Garoppolo sustained a calf injury during Week 4, forcing Lance to start Week 5 — when the rookie suffered a knee sprain. Things are trending toward Garoppolo starting this weekend against the Indianapolis Colts. The veteran passer was out on the practice field with his



Alex Mack says fans shouldn't be concerned about 49ers rookie Aaron Banks' lack of playing time

By David Bonilla
Oct 19

The San Francisco 49ers have played five games this season. Their second-round draft pick, guard Aaron Banks, has been inactive for each of them. That has led many to question the selection. That's a high draft slot for a player who has yet to contribute this season. Veteran center Alex Mack joined KNBR this morning and was asked about his rookie teammate. What does Banks need to do to get on the football field for the 49ers? "Just keep putting the work in," Mack responded on the Murph & Mac show. "You know, he's a good dude. He works hard. He just has a couple of more things to learn and put the work in. And it's a credit to the other guards that it's not easy to break the starting lineup. We have a lot of depth here. "Aaron is



John Lynch 'fully confident' 49ers can rebound from 3-game losing streak

By David Bonilla
Oct 15

The San Francisco 49ers started 2-0 but have since lost three consecutive games. No one inside the organization is panicking, though. Instead, the focus remains on one game at a time. That means looking toward the Indianapolis Colts, not backward at the Green Bay Packers, Seattle Seahawks, and Arizona Cardinals. At 2-3, San Francisco sits in last place within the NFC West. However, general manager John Lynch is confident he and head coach Kyle Shanahan have built a roster that can rebound. The 49ers are in their bye week, and a lot of football remains in this 17-game season. "I'm fully confident [the pieces are in place to turn things around] because of the people in our room and the character of the people in our room, because of the people we have in leadership



49ers great Jerry Rice shares why QB transitions can be challenging for players

By David Bonilla
Oct 21

NFL legend Jerry Rice has witnessed a San Francisco 49ers quarterback transition before — but on a much grander scale. For him, it was watching one future Hall of Fame quarterback succeed another future Hall of Fame quarterback. There is yet another transition taking place in Santa Clara, this time from Jimmy Garoppolo, a quarterback who helped guide the 49ers to a Super Bowl just two seasons ago, to rookie Trey Lance. The topic has been discussed at length. When should it happen? How should it happen? Most of the quarterback discussion is done with an outside perspective. This week, Rice joined the 49ers Talk podcast to share the behind-the-scenes perspective and what a quarterback transition is like for players. "It's kind of hard to


Featured

More by Stewart M. Cockrell

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone