Podcast: 49ers Dominate Dolphins And Lose Jimmy G →
Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports


49ers mailbag: Would a run at Kirk Cousins make more sense in 2018?

Al Sacco
Feb 20, 2017 at 5:01 PM3


Fans of the San Francisco 49ers have a lot on their minds these days, as excitement about the new regime is reaching a fever pitch. With that in mind, we opened the first of many mailbags to the fans, and got some great questions about the quarterback situation (specifically Kirk Cousins), free agency, and the upcoming draft. Enjoy.

Q: Do we wait for Cousins next year if we don't get him (this offseason) and use a stopgap for this year? (Zay Ward)

A: I firmly believe the 49ers are going to do everything in their power to pry Cousins away from Washington this offseason, but the question is: How much are they willing to pay? If/when Cousins is tagged, he would cost any team that wants to sign him two first-round picks. The way I see it, the Niners could take two different approaches here. The first is to wait until after the draft to make Cousins an offer, which would mean they would lose their 2018 and 2019 first-round selections, but still keep the second overall this year. The other option is trying to figure out alternate compensation with the Redskins (say, a couple of second-rounders) and hope Washington is willing to bite knowing they may eventually lose Cousins for nothing down the road.

If neither of these situations come to fruition, or San Francisco just thinks the price tag is too high, then I expect a stopgap at quarterback for this upcoming season would be in play: think someone like Brian Hoyer or Matt Schaub for the time being, and then revisit taking a run at Cousins in 2018 should he become a free agent. To be honest, it probably makes more sense to build the team that would eventually be around Cousins this year, and then put the full court press on him should he hit the open market next offseason.

Q: Do you think free agents will want to come to San Francisco now? I believe the front office dysfunction played a part in San Francisco not landing free agents the past two years. (Kyle LaBouve)

A: I think the presence of John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan, and the fact that each of them has a six-year deal, will be very enticing to free agents. The new power combo has brought a lot of excitement back to the 49ers, and the fact that they're under contract for the foreseeable future shows that there will (hopefully) be stability within the franchise. Also, I think it's very telling that a number of Shanahan's former players who are about to become available are being tied to the Niners in one way or another. Cousins, Hoyer, Schaub, Patrick DiMarco, and Jacob Tamme (to name a few) have all been linked to their old coach, which to me shows that Shanahan made a significant impression on them. In my opinion, the fact that they appear to want to play for him again is a great sign.

Q: Are we making a splash in free agency this year? If so, who's on the list of targets? (Grant Rasmussen)

A: This was such an interesting question to me because inquiring minds want to know exactly how Lynch and Shanahan are going to approach rebuilding this depleted roster. Depending on what happens with the franchise tag, there are going to be some high-impact defensive players who could be available when free agency kicks off, and adding one or two of them would change the fortunes rather quickly on that side of the ball. Names like Melvin Ingram, Eric Berry, Dontari Poe, Brandon Williams, Stephon Gilmore, Jason Pierre-Paul, Kawaan Short, and Chandler Jones would all be big time (and big money) additions, and the Niners could probably afford two of them. Offensively, the list isn't as deep, but a receiver like Alshon Jeffrey or Terrelle Pryor could really help that particular position group and give Shanahan a reliable target in the passing game. Remember though, sometimes it's the role players you add in free agency (someone like DiMarco or Schaub as a veteran mentor) who can make all the difference.

Q: Any chance of (Tony) Romo? (James Leedy)

A: Given his age and where he is at this point in his career, I just don't see Romo being interested in San Francisco. He's 37, injury prone, and probably only has another year or two left in the tank, which means he'll want to go to a team that's ready to win now (unfortunately, that's not the 49ers). A good fit for Romo would be a franchise that's close. Good situations for him would be with teams like the Houston Texans, Kansas City Chiefs or Denver Broncos.

Q: Put your general manager hat on. Do you stay at two and draft Jonathan Allen, or trade down, get another second-round pick, and take Corey Davis late in the first? (Jiggety Jeff)

A: I would love for the 49ers to trade down seeing as this draft is so deep and they have so many needs. What remains to be seen though, is if any team values a player enough at number two overall to want to move up and get him. In an ideal world (for fans of the 49ers anyway), San Francisco could make a trade with the Titans who own the fifth and eighteenth overall picks. That would put the 49ers in a position to land some like inside linebacker Rueben Foster at five, and then take a receiver like Davis at eighteen. It's a dream scenario, but I doubt Tennessee would have any interest in it. Ultimately, I think the Niners stay at two, and draft the top player on their board (whoever that may be).
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


3 Comments

  • Anthony Franco
    If Romo goes to Chiefs, what are your thoughts of a trade for Alex Smith.
    Feb 20, 2017 at 9:12 PM
    0
  • Frank M
    The thought of him leading Shanahan's offense is tantalizing...but there are two factors that make it seem improbable. First, in 2018, he'll be 30. While not old, it's a fairly advanced age to potentially become the highest paid QB in the NFL. Second, the acquisition cost itself...with so many needs, I don't know that paying him huge bucks is in the best overall interest of the team, both short and long term. I'm thinking it may be better to draft the QB Shanahan likes the most this draft and sign a couple of vets like Hoyer and/or Schaub to run the offense 'til the youngster's ready. My vote for QB this draft is Mahomes.
    Feb 20, 2017 at 8:40 PM
    2
  • Lawrence Kramer
    When you have ammunition you battle. Next year you may or may not have the ammo. So IMO pull the trigger on the guys that can help this team. Next year is a new evaluation year with different parameters.
    Feb 20, 2017 at 8:17 PM
    1

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



49ers mailbag: Will Armstead play this week? What's the plan at RB? Will Garoppolo return next season?

By Marc Adams
Nov 29

The San Francisco 49ers are in the home stretch, with only six games remaining. After Sunday's victory over the New Orleans Saints, you'd think 49ers fans have nothing to worry about. But a handful of injuries, and some tough upcoming opponents, have given fans plenty of reasons to fret. We opened up our 49ers mailbag to see what was on the troubled minds of fans. Let's take a peek inside. What do you think is holding back these 49ers on offense? All The tools are there but lack the explosion on plays. - Will D. The 49ers have been inconsistent on offense. A week after exploding against the Cardinals, the offense struggled against the Saints. One reason is that the New Orleans defense is good. In fact, the Saints probably have the



49ers run defense overcomes struggles, absence of Arik Armstead and Javon Kinlaw to become elite

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Dec 2

When Arik Armstead went down with an injury in Week 4 against the Los Angeles Rams just one week after Javon Kinlaw sustained an injury in Week 3, San Francisco had immediate depth concerns alongside the interior of their defensive line, which had been the heart of their run defense over the past few seasons. To begin the 2021 season, the 49ers played Arik Armstead primarily at "big end" and allowed over 100 yards rushing in seven of their first eight games, beginning the year 3-5 and at risk of missing the playoffs. When Armstead was moved to a primarily interior defender, the 49ers allowed 100 yards rushing to an opponent just once, and that was only due to a 73-yard rushing touchdown from Travis Homer on a fake punt in Week 13. Fast-forward to the



Raheem Mostert, Jeff Wilson say Dolphins have more talent than 49ers, a QB 'who can actually sling it'

By David Bonilla
Nov 27

With a big-time matchup between the San Francisco 49ers and Miami Dolphins quickly approaching, two former Niners have voiced their opinions about their new NFL team. While the Niners are focused on this afternoon's game against the New Orleans Saints, Raheem Mostert and Jeff Wilson Jr. have been speaking with Tyler Dunne of Go Long, sharing their thoughts on next weekend's opponent. Mostert was critical of how the 49ers reacted to his Week 1 injury last season. Head coach Kyle Shanahan initially anticipated the knee injury would keep the running back out for about eight weeks. However, Mostert instead opted to undergo season-ending surgery. "He knew how



49ers Notebook: Shanahan happy with backup RBs in Mitchell's absence; 49ers overcome unusual week; Saints' impressive streak snapped

By Kirk Larrabee
Nov 27

It was a strange week for the San Francisco 49ers, who had to work through an unusual schedule that saw them arrive home from their Monday night game in Mexico City in the early morning hours on Tuesday, followed by Thanksgiving on Thursday. Still, they managed to work through it and prepare themselves to play against the New Orleans Saints on Sunday, and in the end they came out on top with a 13-0 win. How did the 49ers work through that schedule? We'll look at that in this version of 49ers Notebook, along with some postgame thoughts from head coach Kyle Shanahan on the running back situation, a look at an impressive streak the 49ers snapped on Sunday, and much more. Let's get it started... (See also:


Featured

More by Al Sacco

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone