Kelley L Cox-USA TODAY Sports

Kelley L Cox-USA TODAY Sports

49ers’ Roster Far More Talented Than National Perception Indicates

Anwar Jamison
Sep 14, 2016 at 1:30 PM

"I know the 49ers are bad." Dan LeBatard, star of Highly Questionable on ESPN spoke those words on Tuesday when the question was posed as to whether Monday night's 28-0 49ers victory over the Rams was because the Rams are a bad team, or the 49ers are a good team. LeBatard seemed to opt for none of the above, asserting that both teams are bad.

Bomani Jones, LeBatard's co-star, chimed in on his on syndicated ESPN radio show, The Right Time with Bomani Jones. "Wow, this roster is bad," added Jones while scrolling through the 49ers' depth chart.

In both of their defense, they are both hosts on national platforms that don't only cover football, but all sports. Even analysts who focus on football can only watch but so much film on 32 teams. How many national sports personalities ever actually watch an entire 49ers football game that doesn't appear on national TV? Why would they have any incentive to do that? Why would they follow the team's progress to see how draft picks are developing?

Look no further than the preseason Power Rankings of most respected national publications to see how the 49ers roster is viewed. They were ranked in the bottom three of all 32 teams in virtually every publication. Do the 49ers have a bad roster? Absolutely not.

Looking at talent alone: the ability to play the game of football at a high level, the 49ers have plenty of talented players. There are other variables that determine whether or not the talent will translate into wins, but a close look at the talent level, or supposed lack thereof, reveals a lot more talent than the average national pundit would have you believe the 49ers possess.

Let's start up front in the trenches where coaches consistently insist that games are won and lost. Right tackle Trent Brown was drafted in the 7th round of the 2015 draft. He only appeared in 5 games last year, and started 2. Why would LeBatard, Jones, or anyone else think Trent Brown is a good player? Why would they pay any attention to him?

The Denver Broncos' Von Miller, one of the most dominant edge rushers of this generation said of Brown, "He's 6'8, he knows how to use his arms, knows how to use his wingspan, he has length. So I feel like, he's young, and people haven't really seen him, but I feel like he's one of the better tackles in the National Football League."

Why would anyone who doesn't watch the 49ers games know that Andrew Tiller is a talented guard? From weeks 6 through 15 last season, Pro Football Focus ranked Tiller as the #4 guard in the NFL. How many people really know that Daniel Kilgore is a talented center?

Starting left guard Zane Beadles is a former Pro Bowler who played well enough in camp and the preseason to keep 1st round pick Joshua Garnett out of the starting lineup. Joe Staley has the respect of all of his peers and has long been considered one of the best left tackles in the NFL. The offensive line is talented enough that you have two first round picks, Garnett and tackle Anthony Davis, who can't even crack the starting lineup.

The 49ers defensive line rotation includes the much heralded defensive end duo of former Oregon draftees Arik Armstead and this year's first round pick Deforest Buckner. Quinton Dial and Mike Purcell played significant minutes in the opener, while the presumptive starter at nose tackle, Glenn Dorsey, fully recovers for a knee injury. By any measure, this is a talented defensive line group.

Behind them, the linebackers include Navorro Bowman, Ahmad Brooks, and Aaron Lynch who's currently serving a 4-game suspension. Outside linebacker Eli Harold has stepped in during his suspension. Ray-Ray Armstrong seems to have emerged as the victor of the three-way competition to start alongside Bowman at inside linebacker. Bowman is still arguably the best in the NFL at his position, and Top 5 at worst. Brooks' best days may be behind him, but he is still a good player, if not always consistently, and an improved defensive line only helps that. Lynch has solidified his place as the team's best pass rusher, and the replacement combination of Harold and Tank Carradine played well in the season opener. That linebacker corps certainly doesn't rival the famed group of 2012, but it is not a group that is devoid of talent by any stretch of the imagination.

The secondary is anchored by one of the better safety tandems in the NFL: Antoine Bethea and Eric Reid. Bethea is a three-time Pro Bowler and Reid made the Pro Bowl his rookie year, before consistently proving to be one of the more talented young safeties in the league. Concussion problems seemed to hinder his aggression a bit, but it returned full force towards the end of last year.

According to Pro Football Focus, starting cornerbacks Tramaine Brock and Jimmy Ward were the highest rated 49ers' defensive players in week one. They will be tested, and with their relative lack of height (Ward is 5'11", Brock is 5'10"), it will be interesting to see how they matchup against bigger wide receivers, beginning with the Carolina Panthers' 6'5" wide receiver Kelvin Benjamin. However, there is no denying that they are talented.

Running back Carlos Hyde is obviously talented. The only question people have about Hyde is his durability and ability to stay on the field. Backup Shaun Draughn is a journeyman who seems to have found his niche with the Niners, but it is understandable that people question his ability considering that the Niners are his 6th team in 5 NFL seasons.

The two position groups that are probably the least talented overall are the quarterbacks and wide receivers, and that may be where much of the perception that the 49ers have an overall lack of talent comes from. They are the glamour positions in the NFL, and if you don't have players putting up big numbers at these two positions, especially in today's fantasy football-crazy climate, casual observers will take that as a reflection of the overall talent level of the team as a whole. There are players in both of those groups looking to dispel that notion, and in Chip Kelly's offense they might, but it is fair to question the talent level of those two groups as compared to the better teams in the NFL.

However, as a whole, upon closer observation, the 49ers clearly have a lot of talent on their team. Again, talent has to be realized, players have to be coached, and they have to work hard to see the desired results from the talent. How far this group can go remains to be seen, but if the 49ers do finish with a poor record, it will not be because of an overall lack of talent.

There are several teams who are considered Super Bowl contenders with glaring holes at key positions, and starters who would not even be on their team if they could help it. The 49ers had that situation last year in a couple of instances. This year they don't. Observers who think the 49ers have very little talent might be surprised if they take a closer look.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Arturo Bradley
    I know Blaine Gabbert is bad but these people who actually comment such as Bomani and Batard probably are casual fans at best. They may say the players are bad because many of them are from the 2013-2016 draft classes, so unfamiliarity equates to bad team in their minds and perception. In my opinion if SF was REAL BAD, then Monday game would have been much closer and probably much more low was not! I also recall LA Rams were favored in this game too. For what its worth, SF OL did phase out the Rams DL in which most teams around the league struggle with. I do not think SF will have a winning record this year because of the lack of a good QB, good WRs, and a primary pass rusher...but I think the rest of the team and other units are very good and they will be a much better team than last year. Progress will be made this year but still couple more years from being competitive.
    Sep 15, 2016 at 11:56 AM
  • KezarVet
    Great article. Finally someone who knows the 49ers. No more Cohen or Kawakami, the make believe writers...
    Sep 15, 2016 at 6:06 AM
  • Steve
    Really good article, but I can understand where the media are coming from. The team last year was much worse than a 5-11 team, they are playing one of the toughest schedules (on paper) and have question marks all over the squad (from a non-niner fan perspective) and at the coaching position. I'm quite happy where the media sees us right now, it's like when we were underdogs throughout the 2011 season. Again we had a new coach (lots of questions), a former bust at QB, a RB coming of an injury, 1 good WR and a young defence and o-line. This season won't be as magical as 2011 (there are too many good teams in the NFC, and we're playing the AFC east), but we'll surprise a number of pundits and build upon this turn around season.
    Sep 15, 2016 at 5:03 AM
  • Scott
    I suggest getting over it and let the haters hate. We will see in the nest 2 weeks where we stand reevaluate and then see what everyone is saying. We get destroyed in both they are right, we win just one and they will change their tune. Frankly the media BS is like water on a duck with me unless it is local guy's, then it pisses me off.
    Sep 15, 2016 at 4:34 AM
  • Dietrich from maui
    Everyone laughed at me when I tried to explain this to them.. look at us now
    Sep 14, 2016 at 9:49 PM
  • Micah
    The problem is the quarterback makes the biggest difference in games. We have a QB ranked between 25-30 and not many teams can do better than 8-8 with a QB situation like that. Yes, it's been done before, but statistics show you have to have a good QB in this league to have success. I agree with your article that were better than people think, but we will still probably have the record many predict
    Sep 14, 2016 at 3:13 PM
  • Kurtis
    Great article. Teams are usually graded on quarterback talent. Not a lot of consideration is given to the make up of the roster outside that position. It's a fair assessment, as teams like the Packers and Patriots have won or got to Super Bowls with limited rosters. I think most pundits agree you can go as far as your quarterback will take you.
    Sep 14, 2016 at 2:38 PM
  • RishikeshA
    Thanks Anwar, the news is starting to trickle through, the Niners have some talent on Defense and an OL that will only get better. The team plays fast on both sides of the ball, speed is something you can't teach. At the very least they won't be pushed around. The next two weeks will give us a clearer window into this year. Chip Kelly is just steps ahead of these old line NFL coaches.
    Sep 14, 2016 at 1:43 PM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

NFL approves roster exemption for 3rd active QB on game days after 49ers' playoff woes

By David Bonilla
May 22

The NFL has reportedly approved a bylaw allowing teams to have a third quarterback active on game days without teams needing to use a roster spot for them. The NFL bylaw on allowing a third QB to be active without burning a roster spot was approved, per source.— Ian Rapoport (@RapSheet) May 22, 2023 This would have helped the San Francisco 49ers in the NFC Championship Game last season. The team's starter,

49ers' Dre Greenlaw recovering from finger procedure, hopes to be a more involved blitzer under Steve Wilks

By David Bonilla
May 25

Dre Greenlaw underwent a minor procedure after last season on his finger. The San Francisco 49ers linebacker is still working his way through the recovery process. That's why he's not with his teammates during organized team activities (OTAs). "Yeah, nothing major," Greenlaw said Thursday on KNBR's Papa & Lund show. "Just a little clean up in the thumb. [It] was giving me some problems, just whenever I was punching at the ball or whenever I had to use my hands on O-linemen. [My] finger was just really jammed up, so I just had to get it cleaned up and fixed. "It's going really well right now, so I'm just waiting, I guess. Now, I think they're going to keep me out of OTAs for the most part, just because you don't want any setbacks right now. But it's

5 breakout candidates for the 49ers in 2023

By Rohan Chakravarthi
May 21

The San Francisco 49ers experienced some significant change this offseason, as key contributors like Mike McGlinchey, Jimmie Ward, Samson Ebukam, Charles Omenihu, and Azeez Al-Shaair all departed in free agency, amongst others, leaving holes to fill on the roster. Some areas of need, such as defensive tackle and nickelback, were filled in free agency via the signings of Javon Hargrave and Isaiah Oliver, but several contributors are players on the roster that will have to step up in 2023 with expanded roles. With the 49ers still amongst the NFL's most competitive rosters in 2023, who could break out for San Francisco this

Ravens signing ex-49ers QB Josh Johnson

By David Bonilla
May 22

According to ESPN's Adam Schefter, the Baltimore Ravens are signing journeyman quarterback Josh Johnson, who spent the end of last season with the San Francisco 49ers. Free-agent QB Josh Johnson, who has played for a record 14 NFL teams, is returning to the Ravens for the third time in his NFL career, per source. Johnson was with the Ravens in 2016, 2021 and now will be back again in 2023.— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) May 22,


More by Anwar Jamison

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone