Colin Kaepernick. Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

Colin Kaepernick. Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

Preseason Games Shed Light on Leadership Dynamics, Positive Growth

Jesse Dumas
Aug 24, 2015 at 6:26 PM

I've watched too much football over the years to put much faith in pre-season performance as an indicator of actual success. There are simply too many variables in play to ever truly know what it will translate to when the games start counting and records are kept. Nevertheless, these 49ers probably had the most psychologically beneficial (for the fans anyway) preseason victory in team history this past Sunday and some questions are finally being answered.

For essentially 8 long months, it's been nothing but bad news for this team. Public perception has been that if it can go wrong, it will for San Francisco and probably in pretty spectacular fashion. It had gotten so bad by the time Aldon Smith made his fateful decision to once again take his chances behind the wheel that the general public, previously delighting in the team's misfortune, actually started to feel a little sympathy for the 49ers and their beleaguered first-year coach, Jim Tomsula.

The first preseason game wasn't terrible by any means, there were definitely some bright spots (See: Hayne) and it was good to see the team finally play some football. Still, it ended in a loss and moral victories aside, that's more or less what the rest of the league expects at this point and the starters did little to quell and fears that we're in for a long season.

Even after a solid game number 2, there's still far more questions than answers. Kaepernick still hasn't shown much in his limited opportunities, the offensive line is still very unsettled, and the secondary has a lot of sorting out to do, but the bright spots are shining light on how deep this roster has been over the past few years, a credit to Trent Baalke's draft strategies and a hint as to why Jed York believed he could get by without the agitation of the previous head coach, as successful as he might have been.

With talent still present, the storyline most interesting to watch develop has been the development of new leadership within the locker room and amongst the players. Kaepernick has been reported to have been much more vocal in this training camp than in years past, to be expected as the roster turns over and he gains more seniority, and that generally bodes well when your quarterback gains confidence. But it would seem that on the offensive side of the ball, all eyes turn to Anquan Boldin in terms of emotional leadership.

Boldin has done it all in this league, he's outspoken, and nobody can argue with his approach to the game. He seems supportive of his quarterback, but he answers to nobody save for his coach. Few will argue that this team will only go as far as their quarterback takes them, but he still has much to prove in the leadership department and that will largely be dictated by his production on the field.

On the defensive side, and perhaps on the team as a whole, it became crystal clear that Navorro Bowman has ascended to the highest level of locker room respect as he's battled back from injury, and that could be the most pivotal development to keep an eye on. His immediate impact on the field (3 plays, 3 tackles, 2 for loss) and the rest of his team's response to that, spoke volumes about what he means to this season and to the franchise as a whole. No longer does he have Patrick Willis and Justin Smith to defer to in terms of seniority and talent, a healthy Bowman is probably the most talented player on the roster, and his stoic and steady nature could be a tremendous asset to the steadying of a shaky organization. The havoc he creates on the field doesn't hurt either and he may go on to supplant his mentor and friend Willis as the greatest MLB to ever suit up for San Francisco.

As the team's outlook comes more into focus, a season that many would regard as a disaster in the making could go much, much better than expected should Kaepernick become the unquestioned leader on offense and Bowman stays healthy and returns to form on defense. The Niners are so far looking pretty smart on some of their rolls of the dice on the likes of Jared Hayne and Arik Armstead plus a few other rookies, 2nd, and 3rd year guys that have been in development and the roster seems to have shown strong support for Jim Tomsula, particularly after the Aldon Smith incident.

The doom and gloom surrounding this offseason is not to be ignored, a losing culture is extraordinarily difficult to reverse, but the conventional wisdom that is saying this team will be a pushover is seeming somewhat misplaced considering the talent that still exists here. That perception in and of itself could be one of the 49ers' greatest advantages, sleeping on a prideful team is ill advised, but nobody will really know for sure until the Vikings show up at Levi's Stadium to provide the first real test of what this team is made of.

Minnesota is considered a team on the rise, but from what I've seen so far, I like the direction Tomsula's taking and I definitely like the chances of starting 1-0 against a young Minnesota at home in front of an edgy, hungry, and Faithful fanbase.

Monday the 14th simply cannot come soon enough.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Al Wharton
    I don't care how good we feel about the team, after a win by the D and Special team play carried the day, all goes back to Kap, if he doesn't play well we are going no where this year or any other year . enough excuses of JH being in the huddle or up his you know what , he needs to play or get rid of the ball instead of taking sacks !
    Aug 25, 2015 at 12:11 PM
    Response: You're not wrong, Al. If everything goes right and Kap is still a mediocre performer or worse, the best this team can hope for is 8-8. If he performs well, then he covers up a lot of smells.
  • Gary Mialocq
    Growing up at Kezar and watching my favorite 49er RB of all time, Hugh McElhenny, the greatest open field runner and screen pass receiver the Niners ever had I was spoiled. Watching Jarred Hayne 60 years later it was Deja Vu. Hayne possesses the same ability to make the first man miss and his upright shake and bake style of running is so similar to McElhenny. This should be fun.
    Aug 25, 2015 at 6:20 AM
    Response: Pretty cool, thanks for sharing!
  • JR San Diego
    I saw leadership from other players as well - Bathea and Reed seemed to be a go to guys on the sideline for example. But for Kap, I think it was big that JH isn't in the practice huddles calling plays. And for team confidence, I think it is huge that they are actually looking more like an NFL caliber offense for once, instead of a discombobulated, shifting happy, delay of game getting oddball offense. Geep seems to have a smooth offense in mind - YAY.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 7:02 PM
    Response: I'm looking forward to re-watching the game soon to key in on more details. Just good to see them having fun and enjoying a win.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Joe Staley hoped to 'pass the torch' to DeForest Buckner, says 49ers miss his leadership

By David Bonilla
Oct 24

Former San Francisco 49ers tackle Joe Staley, now an analyst with NBC Sports Bay Area, shared the story of how he learned about the DeForest Buckner trade last year. Needless to say, he was shocked. Staley had hoped for Buckner to carry on the leadership role after the offensive lineman decided to retire. "Back in March, I had made the decision with my family that I was going to retire and step away from the football field," Staley said during the 49ers pre-game show. "And DeForest was one of the first players that I wanted to go talk to. I kind of wanted to pass the torch a little bit, [say], 'This is going to be your team now,' because he's looked at and viewed on that team as being the culture set or the leader of that squad. "He flipped it on me when I

Matt Nagy tests positive for COVID, uncertain for 49ers-Bears

By David Bonilla
8 hrs

Chicago Bears head coach Matt Nagy announced today that he has tested positive for COVID-19. "Unfortunately, this morning, it came back that I was positive for COVID," Nagy told reporters via a Zoom conference call in place of his typical Monday presser. "I will not be in the building. This is something that, for us, it's a reminder to all of us to be extremely cautious and to understand where we're at. We've seen it, obviously, with other teams in the league, and society in general, so we're working through all that." Coach

John Lynch optimistic that 3 games off will give 49ers a George Kittle 'at full strength'

By David Bonilla
Oct 12

San Francisco 49ers general manger John Lynch joined KNBR today and provided a bit of an update on the team's injured tight end, George Kittle. There had been hope that Kittle might be available for this past weekend's game against the Arizona Cardinals. However, the 49ers ended up putting their star tight end on injured reserve the day before kickoff. That means Kittle will have to miss three games. The first was this past Sunday's game. He will also have to sit out the matchups against the Indianapolis Colts and Chicago Bears. Kittle will be eligible to return on November 7 when the 49ers host the Arizona Cardinals. While there is always the possibility of a setback, Lynch feels optimistic that Kittle will be back for that Week 9 contest. "That was

Happy birthday to a 49ers legend: Reliving Jerry Rice's greatest games

By Sasha D. Robinson
Oct 13

San Francisco 49ers legend Jerry Rice celebrates his 59th birthday today. Rice was drafted in 1985 with the 16th overall pick, and throughout his Hall of Fame career, he set records that may never be broken. For example, the all-time touchdown and receiving record. 🎂🎁🎉Happy birthday to the legendary #49ers and NFL icon, Mr. @JerryRice!—


More by Jesse Dumas

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone