The Jarryd Hayne Effect: Is Kendall Hunter on the Way Out?

Aug 24, 2015 at 4:19 PM19

Prior to the start of the 2015 preseason, running back Jarryd Hayne was viewed as a long shot to make the San Francisco 49ers' 53-man roster. After just two exhibition matchups, the former Rugby League superstar has rebranded himself as a fan-favorite member of the 49ers.

In Sunday's 23-6 victory over the Dallas Cowboys at Levi's Stadium, Hayne had 138 all-purpose yards. He showed that he can be an explosive player on special teams. It was always on special teams where he would have the best shot at making this team. "Jarryd Hayne can change direction on a dime without sinking his hips. That is rare. There are maybe 3 or 4 guys in the entire league that have that ability," says writer AJ Bolino. His raw skills and physical abilities have him right where he needs to be — on the cusp of locking up a roster spot.

Hayne's surprising grasp of the game, in what is the rookie season for the 27-year-old, will cost someone else a roster spot. The player that may be most in danger of no longer being needed is running back Kendall Hunter, who has been a member of the 49ers since being drafted in the fourth-round of the 2011 NFL Draft. While Hayne is exciting coaches and fans alike, Hunter has yet to see any live action with the team. He is attempting to come back from a torn ACL suffered on the second day of the team's 2014 training camp.

Kendall Hunter. Bob Stanton-USA TODAY Sports

In the past, he has proven himself to be a productive back for the team. In 2013, he played in all 16 games, carrying the ball 78 times for 358 yards, a 4.6 yard-per-carry average, and ran into the end zone three times. In 2012, he averaged 5.2 yards in 72 carries, the largest season average of his career, before being placed on injured reserve after an Achilles tear that he suffered against the New Orleans Saints.

However, that was then and this is now. We simply do not yet know what he will look like in live action following his injury. Let's assume that Hayne, who had 54 yards on 8 carries at running back against Dallas, has shown enough to make the team. After all, aside from his special teams contributions, Hayne has 117 rushing yards on 13 carries in preseason. Yes, you read that correctly. That is a 9-yard average. His skills of breaking tackles in the Rugby League have translated well into the NFL. While he is a bit aggressive in his running, refusing to go out-of-bounds and tending to run a little too upright, he runs strong and has proven that he can bully defensive backs for extra yards.

Carlos Hyde will start at running back when the 49ers offense takes the first snap against the Minnesota Vikings on September 14. He averaged nearly 4.9 yards-per-carry against the Cowboys. Reggie Bush is seen as a big free agent acquisition by the team and they have already expressed enough confidence in him to limit his preseason playing time. Like Hunter, rookie Mike Davis was a fourth-round selection. He looked good against the Cowboys, averaging nearly 4.3 yards on 8 carries. "GM Trent Baalke has never released a fourth-round pick his rookie season," says Ryan Sakamoto of, who believes Hunter is on the bubble.

Sadly, like many others, he may be correct in that belief. The fact that we have yet to see anything from him since his injury does not help his case. What he has done in the past does not matter when the team cannot see what he can do for them now. Hunter was penciled in as Frank Gore's backup last year. His injury put the spotlight on rookie Carlos Hyde, who unofficially became the replacement for Gore once he left for the Indianapolis Colts. If Hunter had not gotten injured, that job may have become his. Now he is on the outside looking in. That's life in the NFL.


  • If the 49ers keep four running backs, who is the odd man out?
  • Kendall Hunter
  • Mike Davis
  • Reggie Bush
  • Jarryd Hayne
  • Carlos Hyde
  • 1,478 votes
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Don
    Hunter looked sluggish Saturday. He would need to make significant improvement this Thursday otherwise I release him.
    Sep 2, 2015 at 3:38 PM
  • Luis contreras
    Mike Davis hasn't even been impressive with 3rd stringers. Kendall Hunter is a great back and Davis hasn't earned his spot. Hayne is versatile with a high ceiling. My issue with Davis is the inability to break arm tackles while playing with back ups.
    Aug 29, 2015 at 10:52 AM
  • Lucky Phil
    Navorro Bowman you have earned it! You get the Big Swinging Stick of the week award. What do you think? Who will carry the Big Stick to Denver this week?
    Aug 25, 2015 at 6:08 PM
  • RishikeshA
    Thanks David, Hunter was always one of my favorites, he gave everything all the time. His only drawback was bad luck. He had to have an outstanding camp to stick. As far as Hayne is concerned, this is a world class athlete. The first man down on punt returns grabs air not Hayne. It may be a bit premature but it wouldn't surprise me to see him get PT at running back sooner rather than later. This guy has star written all over him, and the reality is that outside of the U.S. it's no secret.
    Aug 25, 2015 at 3:04 PM
    Response: Yeah, Hunter is one of my favorites too. I really hope the team can figure out a way to keep him. Matt Maiocco came out with a roster prediction today that had the 49ers keeping five RBs, Hunter included.
  • Darrel Peaton
    Hunter can't stay healthy. Hayne will run kicks back and fill in for Hunter when he is hurt the 3rd time.
    Aug 25, 2015 at 2:13 PM
  • mbniner
    I agree that Mike Davis will not be cut. If he was, he would be scooped up by another team. I see Hayne as the No. 3 RB next year, replacing Reggie Bush. He has the receiving skills and open field ability to fully suit that role. This year he will be our featured return man. Baalke builds for the future.
    Aug 25, 2015 at 9:01 AM
  • Edd
    Jarryd Hayne is a beast at returning the ball. But RB? Not all that impressive. Let's see Kendall play before giving up on what is probably a better RB.
    Aug 25, 2015 at 7:00 AM
  • rob
    I like Hunter a lot but too few spots. He's going to find himself starting in another city if the 49ers release him but either way, both win. I believe Hayne is the real deal and agree that you can't cut the rookie 4th rounder if thus far his up side potential is high. This one is going to be an incredible tough call for the coaching staff and I would miss Hunter, especially if a RB goes down.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 10:39 PM
  • Tyler
    At Al Soprano....kendall Hunter has Super Bowl Expericance???? HE WAS ON INJURED RESERVE IN THE SUPER BOWL HE DIDNT PLAY A SINGLE DOWN!!!
    Aug 24, 2015 at 10:04 PM
  • Al Soprano
    Kendal Hunter has playoff and Super Bowl experience. He is an excellent pass protector and has great speed to the outside. He is a proven performer who has averaged over 4.6 yds per carry with 7 TDs. If he is 100%, Mike Davis goes to the practice squad. End of story.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 8:40 PM
  • mbniner
    Sadly, I have to agree with you. No fault of his own that he hasn't had a chance to display his talents and Hayne has been fantastic. I don't see how the Niners can cut him with all the international attention (and potential economic opportunities for the team) without causing a huge fan backlash. The team will probably showcase Kendall in the last couple of games to try to maximize his trade value. And then, barring an injury to another RB, he's gone.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 8:07 PM
  • Lucky Phil
    Bonilla whose the "BSD" this year?
    Aug 24, 2015 at 7:30 PM
    Response: lol. You abbreviated it this time. I'm ok with that.
  • JR San Diego
    I still haven't been able to find out anything about Kendall's status during training camp - Is he practicing at all? If not, maybe he goes on PUP list? I think he would have to get some preseason game action - and look good - to get a decent trade offer for him.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 7:12 PM
    Response: Hunter joined team drills on August 18. He had his practice reps limited and monitored by the team prior to that. Since he has practiced with the team during training camp, he can't be placed on the PUP anymore. Thanks for the comment. Probably important info worth noting.
  • Joe
    Come on man, Kendall Hunter is a proven NFL running back. I'm glad you getting clicks, but stop already.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 6:45 PM
  • Jay
    Do you think it's possible Hunter gets traded? Maybe a 5th-7th round pick in 2017 to a RB needy team?
    Aug 24, 2015 at 5:48 PM
    Response: Given that Baalke somehow got a similar pick for a TE that wasn't even going to make the roster, I would not put it past him. However, I'm not sure how much a backup RB coming off an injury and that hasn't shown much since that injury is worth to other teams. It would be nice to figure out a way to keep a player of Hunter's caliber, who has proven before his injury that he can make an impact, but at some point it becomes a numbers game.
  • Joe from Australia
    must get tense all these guys fighting for spots I think throwing in the rookie Hayne has lit a fire around the group and its a good thing time to turn down the hype on Jarryd and let the coach do his job it might be hard for some NRL fans given The respect he's earned as a footballer and a human being in the NRL .so calm down Australia step back let Jarryd write his own case on the field.its a big step on a bigger stage enjoy the ride
    Aug 24, 2015 at 5:25 PM
  • trey
    Kendall Hunter sign a one year deal.. his rookie deal is over and with the article you can say the same for reggie bush ...
    Aug 24, 2015 at 5:10 PM
    Response: I didn't mention anything about contract status, but yes, Bush is on a one-year deal. While it is not an impossibility that Bush is the one to go and it would not overly shock me given the depth at RB, I just can't see it happening given what has been said about him in practices and what he can bring to the team. Thanks for the comment.
  • Captain Critic
    LOL, SMH Can't wait to read your "Kendall Hunter, possible comeback 49er of the year"? when Hunter has a great season. Bonilla=Vanilla in the Zone
    Aug 24, 2015 at 4:45 PM
    Response: Always a pleasure Captain Critic. I'll call Baalke and let him know you want five RBs on the roster ASAP. As always, thank you for the entertaining comment.
  • Don Julius
    Besides Kendall Hunter is in his final year of his original rookie contract.
    Aug 24, 2015 at 4:29 PM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers set tone of dominance with long opening drive against Jaguars, even if it didn't end the way they wanted

By Kirk Larrabee
Nov 21

As was the case against the Los Angeles Rams last week, the San Francisco 49ers sent a loud, and clear message right off the bat in their 30-10 win over the Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday with a long opening drive that quickly established their dominance and set the tone for what would take place the rest of the game—even if what happened at the end of the drive felt somewhat disappointing. Whereas last week's opening drive in the 49ers' 31-10 win over the Rams came off a turnover and ended in a touchdown after lasting 18 plays, 93 yards, and eleven minutes and three seconds, this week's opening drive came after the opening kickoff and took up thirteen minutes and five seconds while spanning 20 plays and 87 yards before the 49ers took a 3-0 lead on a 20-yard Robbie

49ers-Vikings Injury Report: Elijah Mitchell returns to practice, reinforcements could be on the way

By David Bonilla
Nov 24

The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Week 12 contest against the Minnesota Vikings on Sunday at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California. A look at new 49ers practice squad WR Devin Funchess, No. 14. (He missed his first target in an SF uniform, though the throw seemed a tad off)— Matt Barrows (@mattbarrows) November 24,

Kyle Shanahan explains why he didn't hand out game balls after 49ers trounce Rams

By David Bonilla
Nov 15

Head coach Kyle Shanahan usually hands out game balls after a victory. However, he didn't do so after his San Francisco 49ers trounced the NFC West-rival Los Angeles Rams 31-10. The coach explained why after the game. "We didn't give any game balls out," Shanahan told reporters. "I would have given one to everybody, if we did, but we need to start to expect some more games like that. We've got to be sure that -- we can be better or worse next week, and we've got to make sure we're better." San Francisco improves to 4-5 and prevents falling back into last place in the NFC West. That dishonor belongs to the Seattle Seahawks, who are 3-6. Shanahan and the Niners have won five straight against the Rams, and earned their first home victory in 393 days. That last home

49ers-Jaguars: Kyle Shanahan 'holding out hope' that Elijah Mitchell could play, discusses Jeff Wilson, Trey Sermon

By David Bonilla
Nov 19

San Francisco 49ers rookie running back Elijah Mitchell is officially listed as "doubtful" for Sunday's game against the Jacksonville Jaguars. Head coach Kyle Shanahan is still hoping that the rookie could play, but the odds are against him. Mitchell suffered a finger fracture during Monday night's win over the Los Angeles Rams. The next day, he underwent a procedure to repair the damage. As a result, Mitchell has not practiced at all this week. The coach had hoped the team's leading rusher would get some work in during the three practices, but that never happened. "It's just how he feels with it," Shanahan explained. "And we thought it would be a little further along now. But obviously, it isn't. That's why he couldn't go today. We're holding out hope because


More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone