LISTEN: The 49ers' Secret Weapon On Defense →
Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

McDonald Story Tying a Bow on a Doomed Season

Jesse Dumas
Dec 18, 2014 at 7:27 PM

Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Well, we can finally put this story to rest, at least in the context that this is a San Francisco 49ers-centric website and Ray McDonald is no longer a member of the team. Obviously, more will come to light as this new situation unfolds, and it will at least let us cast a final narrative about what went on with this player and his strange season, though little of it matters now. Regardless of what happens going forward none of the potential outcomes at this point are any kind of happy news to 49er fans.

It would seem that the front office knows more about McDonald than they're letting on, hence the hasty decision to separate him from the organization. One would hope that's the case anyway and this isn't just a knee-jerk reaction to more bad press. This is also decidedly more negative press, carrying rape allegations and a hospital visit by the alleged victim, and things are already not going great in Santa Clara on a number of other levels as we all are well-aware.

No matter their intentions, the 49ers have made their decision and the best that they can hope for is that it sends a message to the rest of this team that maybe you don't get the benefit of the doubt and the allowance of "due process" if you make the team look bad. Ray McDonald was definitely making the team (the struggling, drama-filled team), look even worse than they already did on and off the field and regardless of his role in the most recent events that took place, his head was on the chopping block and an example was made. There's certain to be many new faces in many new places for San Francisco next year, and messages are getting sent now about how business is intended to be run. At least, that's what Jed York is messaging to the world right now anyway.

It seems unlikely any other team would pick up McDonald, though still a talented player, until his newest legal matters are resolved. Given the pace of his last run-in with the law, that would project to be well after the postseason has started and probably after the final games are played this season. Should things get resolved more quickly and again McDonald is not charged, McDonald would be free to sign with any team. This of course would make the 49ers look completely reactionary and foolish, not out of the question with all that's going on right now, but given the timing they should not have to deal with that press for at least several months.

If McDonald is found to be in violation of NFL conduct, and more importantly of United States Criminal Law, then he'll either serve a suspension or jail time and could likely resume his NFL career elsewhere, depending on the seriousness of the charges. In a morbid sense, this is what the 49ers are hoping for at this moment. Few details of the situation have emerged that shed any light on what McDonald is being accused of and the tumultuous relationship between he and his significant other means truly anything could be possible.

The bitter irony of this story bubbling up again shortly after the 49ers competitive season officially ended is fitting in regards to how the whole season has played out up to this point. Every break that could have gone their way has done the opposite and a negative energy dogged them throughout the season. Every Super Bowl season requires a lot of best-case-scenarios to play out, and whatever magic the 49ers had over the past 3 seasons looked completely spent. Injuries, drama playing out behind the scenes, and again drama playing out in the media have ruined the essence of the team and are now carrying on through its impending demise.

Finally, it's important to note that Ray McDonald ended up never getting charged for the domestic violence situation that came up at the start of the season, but never was he truly cleared of his accusations either and no story really came forth. The big reveal of that storyline was that the 49ers had San Jose Police officers on their payroll and it was becoming evident that their involvement in that case clouded things significantly as to whether McDonald was going to be charged.

It becomes a legitimate question now, in light of the 49ers recent decision with McDonald, did the team know that he was not guilty at that time because of their involvement with SJPD or did they know that he just couldn't be implicated because of the evidence (or lack thereof) they presided over? Now that the SJPD is prohibited from working with the team, McDonald certainly didn't have a team-friendly officer to call in this situation and help sort out the details. Knowing this and knowing whatever they knew about the first incident, the 49ers may know that this story is going to get a whole lot worse. It may also mean they knowingly played and protected a player they knew to have broken the law, an ugly but not unrealistic concept considering the stakes in play for this year.

For the team that bellowed the question of who could possibly have it better than them, things just seem to be getting worse and worse.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • dawgman
    The only drama is being caused by the media.This season hasn't been unsuccessful because of drama it's because of injuries but the relentless non stories of drama in the lockerroom is fictional and thus pirrahna like reporting is sickening never have I seen a reusing coach be hounded about other jobs and the pure speculation like you know what Harbaugh and the front office is thinking is sickening .If Harbaugh does leave then I hope you media types can sleep at night but I hope we hire a coach that the media hates even more just in spite!
    Dec 20, 2014 at 6:58 AM
  • Ron
    My dad taught me "What you do is a reflection of what you are." You do a whole bunch of stupid things and people start to think you're stupid. Mr. MDonalds' record is hardly pristine. The Niner organization has been and is one of the class organizations in the country. And I'm sure the Patriots will be happy to pick him up.
    Dec 19, 2014 at 4:17 PM
  • Daniners
    Once again, a pseudo-journalist, yourself, jumps to conclusions. Other than the media's efforts to create something, there has never been any evidence that links the District Attorney's decision not to proceed forward with charges against McDonald, to the 49ers having a reltionship with the San Jose Police. I am so tired of lazy, irresponsible journalism. Gather evidence to support your supposition and then provide the information to your readers. This is just 1 1 =2 so it has to be correct. Nonsense.
    Dec 19, 2014 at 7:24 AM
    Response: I posed plausible explanations for the actions taken in the past few days and months. If I had any more evidence than any other "pseudo-journalist" then I would certainly use it, but how can anybody get facts when all parties are mum on the subject? BTW, 1 + 1 does equal 2, where there's smoke, there's fire, and if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and sounds like a duck, I'm pretty sure it aint chicken. The officer that arrived on the scene before any on-duty police units wasn't there to eat birthday cake.
  • Niner
    Kinda reminds me of the bombing in Atlanta. The fbi said they knew who did it but they needed evidence to arrest him. It wasn't the security guard they said it was. If they have evidence they will charge McDonald everyone knows that. If somehow it's all bogus or wasn't him jed York looks like a dumb azz again. But what the heck, they must be used to it by now.
    Dec 18, 2014 at 10:35 PM
    Response: This season kinda reminds me of a dumpster fire.

More San Francisco 49ers News

No Huddle Podcast: The Brock Purdy Hate Ends This Season

By Site Staff
Jun 4

(Episode 343) — Brian Renick and Al Sacco react to Justin Jefferson's new contract and how it impacts Brandon Aiyuk's future in San Francisco and reaction to Phil Simms ranking Brock Purdy as the 17th-best QB in the NFL. Plus, the guys make their own QB tiers and where ranks amongst other franchise QBs. The audio for the show is embedded above. Remember to subscribe! You can watch the show


More by Jesse Dumas

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone