49ers: They are Who We Thought They Were

Oct 14, 2014 at 6:33 PM

Coming into 2014, many thought the 49ers would struggle during the early part of the season while integrating new starters and waiting for the wounded/suspended to return. It's easy to pick against the consensus. Some folks make a living at it. Only, this time, the consensus seems right. The 49ers have struggled, and yet they remain within striking distance of a playoff berth, as fans have hoped. In other words, to quote Dennis Green, the 49ers pretty much are who we thought they were, or would be, come this point in the season.

However, for such a predictable season, the current one has certainly not bored. Nor has it lacked hopeful signs for the faithful. While Jim Harbaugh has recently dominated most of the press coverage, I want to give a shout-out here to the position coaches. This season reminds me of 2011, when little-known players previously buried on the depth chart morphed into solid contributors. After a shaky start, Ed Donatell has worked with the secondary through roster turnover and injuries to field a competitive unit. How about Perrish Cox and Antoine Bethea? Even rookie Dontae Johnson has stepped up when needed. Yes, Peyton Manning will more thoroughly test this bunch. Nevertheless, the defensive backfield shows promise.

Likewise, linebackers coach Jim Leavitt has maneuvered around injuries and new faces to mostly put his charges in position to make plays, with noteworthy contributions here from Skuta, Lynch, and Wilhoite, none of them household names or high draft picks. When and if the former starters return, expect these guys to remain in the rotation.

Geep Chryst, meanwhile, continues to coach away at the finer points of quarterback play with Colin Kaepernick. While Kaep may never be John Brodie, let alone George Mira, the young signal caller does have his own well-known strengths. No, Colin has not made the great leap forward that many fans had sought, but he continues to work at his craft and has made incremental adjustments to his game. He has improved his touch on short and on loft passes. He doesn't lock in so much on one receiver. And, against the Rams, he didn't bolt as often or as early from the pocket. We'll see how these incremental improvements hold up under greater duress.

Trent Baalke certainly deserves credit for assembling a deep roster. And Harbaugh deserves some kudos for assembling this staff and then letting his coaches coach. But one should also never forget that the assistant coaches themselves remain a bulwark of this team. They must mold the talent and then implement the on-field results, while usually toiling in anonymity. Bravo for them.

A Gift from the Rams

I don't mean the victory. The 49ers deserved to win Monday's game. I mean the stone-cold stonewalling of several 49er running plays late in the fourth quarter. Nor do I disagree, given the game situation, with the fourth-down tries. Heck, the 49er coaches know their team better than I do, so I won't even grouse much about the individual play calls. I merely point out the Rams gifted the 49ers, for all the world to see, the realization that the Prospectors can no longer impose their smash-mouth will as once they could. Against some teams, maybe. But not on all teams at all times in all situations.

This 49er team, deprived of their once-great offensive line, must use the running game judiciously and creatively, while continuously adjusting for game situations and opponents. Also, teams in the NFC West have built defenses, in part specifically, to stop past iterations of the Niner run game. Rams coach Jeff Fisher has long been a leader in thwarting the power-run offense of the 49ers. His defenses combine stout personnel, strong gap discipline, and a willingness to commit extra bodies to curtail the ground attack. Let Kaepernick beat them if he can. Monday night, Colin, and the passing offense, did.

Should the 49ers abandon the running game? Of course not. But they will need a more balanced approach. And they must be wary of abandoning the balanced offense too early when they lead by only ten points. Coaches, like the rest of us, want it both ways. They want to run the clock out in the fourth quarter while simultaneously gaining low-risk first downs. But, if you can't run the ball at will, then trying to do so may contribute to your demise. Against mistake-prone teams with inexperienced quarterbacks, you may get away with this. Against teams like, say, the Denver Broncos, beware of playing too safe too early. And as the season wears on, don't forget the gift the ever-magnanimous Rams gave you: exposing the myth of Niner ground-game invincibility.

Someday when all the injuries have healed and the offensive line re-meshes, circumstances may warrant a return to consistent smash-mouth running. Until then, the faithful may take some solace in the revamped receiver corps and the welcome emergence of a more varied passing attack.

On the Verge

Are the 49ers on the verge of becoming a genuine Super Bowl contender again? Well, the Prospectors certainly have a severe challenge in their next game: a banged-up Niner squad coming off a road game, going on the road again on short rest to play against a splendid team with a great quarterback. Daunting. Some will regard the upcoming Bronco contest as a marker game for the 49ers. Let's review some possible outcomes and what they might tell us:

1)The 49ers handily beat the Broncos by a wide margin. If the 49ers defeat the Broncos by a wide margin this probably means that Jim Harbaugh has gone bonkers. Harbaugh simply does not like to win games by wide margins, even when his own team dominates. Then, again, maybe he'll show up on the sidelines Sunday night sporting a tuxedo, a prospect just as likely as a multiple-touchdown victory.

2)The 49ers beat the Broncos by a narrow margin. Unless extraordinary luck plays a role, we'd have to say the 49ers are back as championship contenders.

3)The Broncos beat the 49ers by a narrow margin. Given the circumstances, ditto, despite the Niners' record.

4)The Broncos beat the 49ers handily, and Mr. Manning demolishes Mr. Farve's record for career touchdown passes. Uh oh. Back to work, 49ers, and back to wild-card aspirations.

So, after all the drama, we're just about where the consensus expected the 49ers to be: hanging on to a good-enough early-season record while the youngsters take hold and the missing creep ever closer to their returns. Of course, other injuries will ensue (injuries to the d-line or Colin would devastate) and the returning players will require time to get up to game speed. But the victories already secured against the Cowboys and Eagles, with regard to possible future tie-breakers, look better, as one of those two teams may well contend for a wild-card slot. And if the 49ers heal and improve, they can still capture their own division. But there aint much room for backsliding, and any major regression will surely spell their doom.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Ruach Hokadesh
    Wow, Geoege Mira?? I would say Colin has already surpassed him. Now John Brodie? Whats the point of signing Kap to that huge deal if he's not going to be the next Steve Young
    Oct 15, 2014 at 2:50 PM
  • 49ers F8tful @ any timeline
    The 49ers players will overcome because what doesn't kill you makes you stronger, right!?! Can you imagine what they'll be like with all their players ready, willing and able to play, think about that NFL?!? Go 49ers all the way to SB victory!!!
    Oct 15, 2014 at 12:02 PM
  • DaNiners
    If the Niners get demolished by the Broncos, it means little. It means that a HORRIBLY depleted team cannot go to Denver, with the altitude, and beat a top 3 team in the NFL (when we are complete, we are a top 3 team). It doesn't matter if it is by 21 or 3, the reality is the same. The Seahawks and Cardinals are going to continue to lose games. Outside of us, the Cardinals have beaten one good team (it's the Chargers. Anyone want to bet they are not in the SB?). Cards defense is in shambles; these guys are one of those teams that falls apart in the second half of season. Watch the wreckage. Seahawks have real problems. On offense, they bet on a bunch of subpar WR's and it is clearly not working. No one is afraid of their WR's and there is no quick fix to that. The winner of the NFC is going to be the Niners or 'Hawks and possibly the winner could be 10-6. Just like last year, assuming we get healthy and our jailbirds stay/get on field, we will be fine. We know how to win in the playoffs and a lot of teams don't (hello, Green Bay).
    Oct 15, 2014 at 7:10 AM
  • Ladale
    Their most physical run blockers are on different sides of the line. Mike Iupati and Anthony Davis should be a tandem like Dallas uses their power tandem to run behind.
    Oct 15, 2014 at 3:26 AM
  • Monsterniner
    With Harbaugh/Roman we always have been bad in the red zone but this season we´ve been worst than ever. For 3 games in a row the offense couldn´t kill the game with a late TD and we have to wait one last stop of our defense. The offense in the red zone looks uninspiring and the play-calling is predictable. We lost the Super Bowl and the last Championship Game because we were bad in the red zone and now I´m seeing that we aren´t getting better. In fact I think that we are worse than the last 3 years.
    Oct 15, 2014 at 12:14 AM
  • BJ
    Good article, and maybe this is just nit picking, but describing team as "remain[ing] within striking distance of a playoff birth" after 6 games sounds a little preemptive and somewhat sensational. How many teams are a) locked into a playoff birth or b) dead in the water at this point? Maybe a few more of the latter, but again... 6 games. Again, good article, but maybe avoid feeding the frenzy.
    Oct 14, 2014 at 9:09 PM
  • Craig
    "let alone George Mira" The George Mira that had a total of 8 NFL starts?
    Oct 14, 2014 at 9:04 PM
    Response: Yes, I believe he's the very same.
  • Greg
    "The Gift from the Rams" This is spot on. Hopefully this will have the coaches re-examine their short yardage strategies. We are getting no push and no holes for the RB in short yardage situations. Kilgore has looked very good in pass blocking but him, Boone and J.Martin have not pushed the pile enough on 3rd and short oppurtunities. Both 4th down runs ended up being behind Looney(filling in for Iupati) and he stood in the way of the RB at the goal line and then didn't connect on his block on the last one. Our best hope is Marcus Martin comes back and can sub in the interior on short yardage runs.
    Oct 14, 2014 at 7:17 PM

More San Francisco 49ers News

Will the 49ers sign Brandon Aiyuk? Schefter weighs in

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

The San Francisco 49ers hold significant leverage in their negotiations with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. Aiyuk is under contract for the upcoming season, and the team can use the franchise tag to retain him in 2025 and 2026. Despite this, both parties would benefit from...

Why CBS Sports named Brandon Aiyuk the 49ers' most underappreciated player

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

Brandon Aiyuk has dominated San Francisco 49ers-related storylines this offseason as the star player seeks a contract extension that will make him one of the NFL's highest-paid receivers. Given his consecutive 1,000-yard seasons, it's surprising to see Aiyuk listed among...

Former NFL exec ranks 49ers' Brock Purdy among NFL's best young players

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

ESPN isn't alone in its high regard for San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. Former NFL executive Jeff Diamond also ranks Purdy among the best NFL players under the age of 25 on his list for The 33rd Team. Purdy comes in at No. 6, behind only Justin Jefferson, Micah...

De'Vondre Campbell ready to impress 49ers, fill in for Dre Greenlaw

By David Bonilla
Jul 5

De'Vondre Campbell wasn't the San Francisco 49ers' first choice this offseason when it came to adding linebacker help. Dre Greenlaw is still recovering from the torn Achilles he suffered in February's Super Bowl and will likely miss at least a few weeks at the start of the...


More by D.C. Owens

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone