Podcast: 49ers Offseason Stories with SI's Conor Orr →
Kim Klement-USA Today Sports

Kim Klement-USA Today Sports

Who to Pay? The Answer Might Be Neither.

Stewart M. Cockrell
Aug 27, 2014 at 3:57 PM

The growing dilemma of Alex Boone seems to be a central story line of the offseason and as the 49ers near the end of training camp there has been no real progress made. There were reports that a contract offer was made to Boone that would have made him one of the top 15 paid guards, but this was rejected. Meanwhile, Pro-bowl guard Mike Iupati is entering a contract season and looking to bounce back from a devastating ankle injury sustained in the NFC championship game in Seattle earlier this year. The big question now sits with the front office on who do the 49ers decide to pay or is the answer to this question neither?

Boone is one of those guys that you have to just love. Blue collar type guy from Ohio State, he had great talent coming out of college, but Boone went undrafted in the 2009 NFL Draft, at least partially due to concerns about alcohol abuse. Once he put those issues aside, the 49ers recognized the talent he brought to the team not only at guard, but as the backup tackle spot. This caused the 49ers to offer a nice 6.5 million dollar contact to Boone in 2011 as a way to lock him up for a few years at an affordable price. Did the 49ers know he would work into a full time starter and help anchor right side of the line once Adam Snyder left town? The answer is probably not. Either way, Boone has been a bargain on an offensive line that features three first round picks.

Iupati has done everything and more to justify his draft status. Taken by the 49ers with the 17th pick in the 2010 draft, Iupati has helped Joe Staley make the left side of the 49ers offensive line one of the most steadfast parts of the team. Iupati is in the final year of his slotted rookie deal which has paid him 15.1 million dollars. Many would have thought that Iupati was a shoe in to get an extension from the 49ers when the time came in 2013, but that honor actually went to his fellow draft mate Anthony Davis who inked a 33.2 million dollar extension in 2013 that keeps him a 49er until 2019.

Ideally the 49ers would like to keep both Boone and Iupati past 2014, since they are home grown players that fit the team's identity to a "T". However, with top ten guard salaries average about seven million a year, the 49ers might be content to let Iupati walk and trade Boone this offseason (assuming he never reports) for 3rd or 4th round pick. The reason is they have Joe Looney, who the team feels can be a serviceable starter for them at right guard who also has a very cap friendly deal of only 1.2 million dollars over the next two years. A starting guard in the NFL for a shade under 600 grand in the NFL is a dang fine bargain.

Daniel Kilgore is another factor in this equation as well. Currently Kilgore is the 49ers' starting center, but can also play guard. Recently signed to an extension after Jonathan Goodwin left town, the starting center will be making a little around a million a year until 2017. With the drafting of Marcus Martin (4 years, 3 Million) in the third round of the 2014 draft, the 49ers more than likely see him as the future center (assuming he can stay healthy) and possibly moving Kilgore to either of the guard spots.

There might be some history to support this line of thought in the Baalke era. In 2011 the 49ers let starting center David Baas leave for New York instead of paying him starter money. This coming just one year after the 49ers drafted Iupati and Davis, as well as locking up Boone to his current deal. The 49ers replaced Baas with Goodwin on a three year 10.9 million dollar contract. A steal compared to the 5 year 27.5 million dollar that Baas chocked out of the Giants that offseason. The history says that the 49ers will look to pay premium dollars for the tackle spots, while making wise, short term investments at the guard and center spots. This allows the team to spend to spend the money elsewhere such as all four starting linebackers which average 7.4 million dollars a year. On a team deep with talent, you have to find savings somewhere. The 49ers have looked to do that with the secondary in recent years and now it seems they are looking to do that on the interior offensive line as well.

It appears, in this instance the answer to the question of which guard to pay is...neither.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Donnie
    Also remember that the 9ers have Brandon Thomas stashed on IR this year. He certainly looks to have starter ability at guard once he recovers from his injury. Iupati looks like he will be elsewhere next season. And it is up to Boone if he wants to sit out the next 2 years.
    Aug 28, 2014 at 8:18 AM
    Response: I forgot about Brandon Thomas. There are so many guys the 49ers are "red-shirting" that it is hard to keep them straight. I'm sure he will be in the mix next season if both Boone and Iupati are gone. Especially if Looney or Kilgore are unimpressive this season.
  • Slapstick49
    If the niners want sub par o-line play and quick pocket collapses then yes, pay neither. This line has so far been horrible and inconsistent with out boone. Looney is not starting caliber and kilgore is average at best. I really hope this issues gets resolved before kap ends up getting hurt and then our season is really lost.
    Aug 27, 2014 at 6:59 PM
  • scarecrow
    It gives me no pleasure to agree here. Love them both, but wouldn't be surprised if both walked. My only concern: special emphasis to th o-line was a priority of Nolan & Sing. Harb inherited that - would hate to see one of our recent strength groups crumble...
    Aug 27, 2014 at 6:36 PM
    Response: You are right, Harbaugh did inherit a great Offensive Line. Davis and Iupati both came from a Sing draft.
  • Joe
    Agreed, the 49er's are not going to pay either of them.....but could use the extra money of not paying Boone to sign a pass rusher now that ESPN is reporting that Aldon Smith is going to be suspended for the entire 2014 season.
    Aug 27, 2014 at 5:16 PM
  • Gib Robinson
    Good column! I have been surprised that Boone decided to hold out and I wonder whether he feels his agents misread the situation. The 49ers might choose to let him hang out there for one or maybe even two years, if he doesn't choose to return. It would certainly set an example that other players would notice. Does Boone really want that? If not, does he have a return date in mind -- say next week? We'll see.
    Aug 27, 2014 at 4:42 PM
    Response: I think the 49ers have drawn a line in the sand for Boone by extending Staley and Doresy this training camp. I'm actually very surprised that they even made an offer to Boone to get him back.
  • 9erz4Life
    Agreed that is exactly what they do. No mention of what you think about that. Do you believe it's a wise strategy??? I just can't see paying a player premium money if he can't do everything at a premium level. Iupati for example is an excellent run blocker but has regressed when it comes to pass blocking. I thought he was ok in 2012 and not very good last year. Boone on the other hand is the same way although he had an excellent pass blocking season in 2012 and not good last year. Why over pay for a name which I believe Mike is right now more name than play. Niners have been getting raked over the coals for not giving into Boone and although I think he holds more value than Iupati because he can play T the fact is he doesn't for us. Stupid to pay a player who's playing out of position a bunch of money who doesn't have a long track record of playing there.
    Aug 27, 2014 at 4:14 PM
    Response: As a 49er homer, I want us to keep all of our guys, especially the ones we draft or develop. But as a realist, I know that just isn't possible in today's NFL. Teams have to look for savings somewhere. If I was a betting man, I would think that they eventually get something done with Boone and Iupati will be the one that leaves town. With all the other looming contracts we have coming up, we are going to loose some talented guys.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Carr: Sam Darnold might have more ability than Brock Purdy, could be 49ers' Week 1 starter

By David Bonilla
Mar 30

On Tuesday, NFL insider Ian Rapport, one of the NFL's most plugged-in reporters, made headlines declaring that, given the situation with the San Francisco 49ers, Sam Darnold would be the team's most likely Week 1 starting quarterback. "We do not know what Trey Lance is going to be if he continues the trajectory that he's been on," Ian Rapoport said on NFL Network. "And I think, certainly, it seems Sam Darnold will more likely than not be the starter going into the season, but there is an opportunity for someone to step in there and start [the] first couple of games of the regular season for the 49ers." Lance, the No. 3 overall draft pick in 2021, and Darnold, added


More by Stewart M. Cockrell

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone