Photo by Mitch Stringer of USA Today Sports
Are the 49ers wasting their time with Blaine Gabbert?
Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Jim Harbaugh has a reputation for being a quarterback guru.
The head coach has helped mold the likes of Colin Kaepernick and Andrew Luck, and both have ultimately become franchise signal callers in the NFL. Harbaugh has also been able to revive the career of Alex Smith, who looked to be headed for life as a career backup before he teamed up with the quarterback whisperer in 2011. Smith has since gone 30-9-1 in his last 40 regular season NFL starts with the 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs.
With a track record like Harbaugh's, it not crazy to think that the 49ers can take a chance on a passer who may have not yet reached his potential, with the hopes that their coach can bring the best out of that player.
That was most likely the thought process when the 49ers traded for Blaine Gabbert this offseason, who was the number 10 overall pick in the 2011 draft by the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Gabbert, who the Jaguars hoped would be the savior of their floundering franchise, was a train wreck over his first three seasons.
He started 27 games in Jacksonville, and posted a record of 5-22. 2013 was especially bad, as he seemed to regress across the board. In three starts (all losses), Gabbert completed less than 49 percent of his throws and was picked off seven times.
Overall, the embattled quarterback threw 22 touchdowns to 24 interceptions during the forgettable three year run.
Those in Gabbert's corner could argue that he was thrown into a bad situation, being forced to try and win with limited talent around him. Those same supporters would argue that Gabbert might be a better performer with a stronger supporting cast.
With his trade to the 49ers, Gabbert now has a talented roster around him. While he was in no way ever considered to be a threat to Kaepernick's starting job, the hope was he could show enough to be a quality backup.
Despite the optimism, if Gabbert's first preseason game was any indication, San Francisco might be better off going in a different direction.
Gabbert was flat out awful in his 49ers' debut against the Baltimore Ravens. He looked inaccurate, sailing passes and throwing behind receivers. For the night, he completed only three of 11 throws (27 percent) for 20 yards and an interception.
For a team with Super Bowl aspirations, that kind of performance is beyond worrisome.
Now in a perfect world, Gabbert (or whoever ends up being the backup) would never see the field anyway. The 49ers' championship hopes rest on the back of Kaepernick, and if he were to miss an extended period of time the results could be catastrophic.
But when you consider the fact that the Niners were only one win away from having the NFC Championship game in San Francisco last season, even losing Kaepernick for a game or two could set the team back considerably. If Kaepernick were to miss even one start, do the 49ers have a reliable replacement?
Gabbert still has time to turn things around, after all there are still three preseason games to go. Harbaugh and the 49ers still have an opportunity to try and get Gabbert up to speed. However, if he doesn't adjust quickly, they may be better off going with Josh Johnson as the backup.
Moving forward, it might even make sense for San Francisco to draft a quarterback to develop behind Kaepernick. If that player proves to be competent, they could always use him as trade bait down the line similar to what the New England Patriots have done with Ryan Mallett.
That thought's for another day though, and right now the team has to play the cards they have. That may mean holding their collective breathes every time Kaepernick takes a hit in 2014.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
-
David
Dont plan on seeing any Gabberts or Josh Johnsons anyway. Niners just wanted a player who has been in the several years ala Colt McCoy. I have no problem with that, except I hate he gets paid so much. Why didnt we draft a rookie Qb in the 5th or 6th round?
Aug 13, 2014 at 11:20 PM
-
Marty
48ers QBs all struggled, even Kaepernick. Kaepernick threw 2 passes, force incomplete pass to Johson & a 5 yard pass to MacDonald who ran for 17 yards. Offense ran the ball effectively, but again had to settle for a FG in the red zone.
Yes, just a preseason game the offense had the same problems. Can't score TDs, can't get first downs, terrible play calling, game management, mistakes & turn overs.
The performance by the offense is just a repeat of the last three seasons. If it says anything, it says the 49ers still haven't figure the out their problems.
Aug 10, 2014 at 7:34 AM
-
Mark
It took more than one preseason game to fix Alex Smith and it will take more than on here as well. If after all 4 he's made no improvement then we can call it. McCoy never seemed to get it either.
Aug 9, 2014 at 10:51 AM
-
DK
All I have to say is Why? Jacksonville dump it on Niners
Aug 9, 2014 at 8:41 AM
-
Mike
Gabbert was inaccurate and also looked like a one read quarterback. That's also how he looked in Jacksonville. The 2nd spot is definitely up for grabs. Hope somebody earns it.
Aug 8, 2014 at 1:37 PM
-
Jeff Garcia
Yes, he's a waste of time. Put me in there coach!
Aug 8, 2014 at 9:56 AM
-
Daniners
Dude, give it a rest. It's one preseason game. All these no nothing's complaining about the team. Preseason is meaningless to everyone but young players needing to learn. Each game, our young players will improve and gain confidence. Normal. The rest of them, they are just trying to stay healthy. That's it, that is all there is to read into preseason. The most important young players flashed their ability tonight, Hyde, Dial, Carradine, Okoye, McDonald, Lemonier, Ellington, Wilhoite and Ward.
Gabbert? He probably sucks, so did McCoy. If we lose Kaepernick, it won't matter who the backup is 'cause we aren't winning the West or SB without him. If we need some clown to win two games, the niners will go find a guy whether it's Gabbert or not. Beyond that won't matter and I would rather get the #1 pick than watch some perennial backup go 7-8.
Aug 7, 2014 at 8:49 PM
-
Michael Crabtree
By: Michael Crabtree
Comment: Hell Yes!
Aug 7, 2014 at 8:34 PM
-
Jim Harbaugh
Yes
Aug 7, 2014 at 7:41 PM
More San Francisco 49ers News
49ers keep SoFi their house: 17 quick observations from the game
It wasn't the blowout many San Francisco 49ers fans believed it would be, but in the end, the 49ers outlasted the Los Angeles Rams in a week two divisional matchup. With the win, the 49ers start the season 2-0 and currently sit one game up in the NFC West.
Although it may not have been a blowout on the field, it was in the stands. The fanbase ratio wasn't even close. There were many more 49ers fans in the stands than there were Rams fans. But that didn't surprise anyone, except the Rams content creator I interviewed last week. He thought it would be 50/50. He was wrong. It was more like 70/30—if even that close.
Every week during the season, I share my
John Lynch: Brandon Aiyuk's status for 49ers-Giants remains "very fluid," could be game-time decision
This week's focus remains on San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. The team has a short week to prepare for its next opponent—the New York Giants on Thursday night at Levi's Stadium. The matchup comes just four days after the Niners' 30-23 win over the Los Angeles Rams.
Aiyuk suffered a shoulder injury on his first catch, a 13-yard reception during San Francisco's opening drive. He was in and out of the lineup throughout the game and was limited during the 49ers' light Tuesday practice.
On Tuesday, head coach Kyle Shanahan said that the decision will come down to how Aiyuk feels and the evaluation from the training staff. It sounds like the receiver may end up being a
No Huddle Podcast: 49ers Beat The Rams (Again)
(Episode 269) - Al Sacco and Brian Renick dive into the 49ers' impressive victory over the Rams, appreciating how calm Brock Purdy is in the pocket, how to look at this team from a macro perspective, if Christian McCaffrey is getting too many touches, and which game they are looking forward to the most.
The audio for the show is embedded above. Don't forget to subscribe!
You can listen to the latest "No Huddle Podcast" episode above, from our dedicated podcast page, on
PFF's highest- and lowest-graded 49ers players vs. Rams, plus snap counts
The San Francisco 49ers improved their record to 2-0 after a 30-23 win against the Los Angeles Rams in Week 2. Today, Pro Football Focus released its grades from the game. Which Niners played well, and who has more work to do?
Below are Pro Football Focus' five highest-graded 49ers players on offense against the Rams.
George Kittle, TE, 84.8, 55 snaps
Trent Williams, LT, 83.4, 57 snaps
Jauan Jennings, WR, 77.5, 27 snaps
Brandon Aiyuk, WR, 72.3, 30 snaps
Deebo Samuel, WR, 71.7, 51 snaps
Below are the five highest-graded 49ers players on defense.
Nick Bosa, DE, 93.0, 63 snaps
Javon Kinlaw, DT, 83.8, 29 snaps
Fred Warner, LB, 74.7, 80 snaps
Tashaun Gipson