LISTEN: The 49ers' Secret Weapon On Defense →

49ers Monday Morning Chatter Week 14: Season defining moments, frustrating play calls, and one hell of a win

Al Sacco
Dec 9, 2013 at 9:12 AM5

Steve Young often says that he hated settling for field goals when he played, because to him that means you were three points closer to losing. He has a point, but when you have a defense like the Jim Harbaugh era 49ers do, three points can go a long way. San Francisco's 19-17 win over Seattle in Week 14 marked the fourth win in six tries for Harbaugh against the Seahawks. Believe it or not, in those four wins the Niners have scored a total of four offensive touchdowns (one in each game). Here is what 49ers fans are talking about after Week 14.

Greg Roman

This was a great win for the 49ers so I don't want to spend too much time on the negative, however, Roman has to be addressed. The best analogy I can come up with is he looks like a person who has a high end sports car, but is afraid to drive over 30 mph because he might dent it.

I say this because his conservative approach almost cost the team this game as he once again looks afraid to (or may just not be able to) utilize his talent correctly. It's maddening to see a quarterback with the skills of Kaepernick play with handcuffs on. He's turned an athlete the likes of which the NFL has never seen into a drop back passer who is averaging 191 yards passing a game. What can he do differently? Take the 3rd and 1 play in the first quarter from Seattle's 5 yard line. He could have run his quarterback, used a play fake, rolled him out...anything to think outside of the box. Instead, he gave to ball to Bruce Miller, who was stopped. The 49ers had to settle for three points.

Maybe the team feels like they can win with a conservative approach during the season and then open it up in the playoffs. They did that last year by keeping the read option under wraps down the stretch. That remains to be seen, but the reality of the situation is the 49ers are invested in Kaepernick. If Greg Roman can't utilize his talents, Harbaugh may want to think long and hard this offseason about someone else who can.

Back to the future

This game felt a lot like 2011 and with good reason. In Week 1 of that year, the 49ers had a 19-17 lead late in the 4th quarter before Ted Ginn broke the game open with a kickoff and punt return for touchdowns. In Week 16, the 49ers beat the Seahawks 19-17 on Christmas eve with the help of a fourth quarter David Aker's field goal. In each of those games, San Francisco moved the ball but could only get one touchdown. The offense settled for four field goals, put up 19 points, and the defense kept Seattle in check. Sound familiar?

Championship defense

You can't say enough about how well the 49er defense has played since Week 3 and they more than did their part on Sunday. NaVorro Bowman set the tone early when he sacked Russell Wilson for an eight-yard loss, knocking the football out of bounds in the process. San Francisco did a tremendous job containing Wilson, who was 15-of-25 for 199 yards. He was only 7-of-14 for 55 yards in the second half. Even more impressive is they kept Wilson in the pocket and didn't allow him to extend drives with his legs. His two yards rushing was the lowest total in his career. If the defense continues this type of play, the 49ers can beat anyone on any given day.

Quietly, Mr. Dawson is Mr. Reliable

Phil Dawson had his best game as a 49er, drilling four field goals including the game winner. He has now made 20 consecutive kicks which broke Joe Nedney's franchise record of 18. Dawson is now 23-of-26 on the season. The only kicks he has missed have all been from long range (48, 53, 71). As good as David Akers was in 2011, he was equally as bad in 2012. It's comforting to once again have a kicker that can be relied upon week in and week out.

Seahawks style of play finally catching up to them?

It's no secret that the Seahawks play physical football that is sometimes borderline legal. Richard Sherman is a perfect example of that. He uses his arms and grabs receivers, often holding them in process. Seattle gets away with this for the most part but it may have finally caught up with them. The Seahawks were called for nine penalties in the game, some of which helped the 49ers extend drives. Sherman went as far as to say that the officials were the reason his team lost.

"We expected to blow them out but they got the benefit of a few calls tonight throughout the game and that helps you especially on 3rd down, we will see them again and it will be different result."

When asked if Michael Crabtree's presence made a difference, Sherman was just as defiant.

"It didn't make a difference. It didn't make a difference at all...The penalties, that is what made the difference today."

But seriously, is Crabtree helping?
Is Crabtree 100 percent? No (and it's obvious he was laboring a little at times), but Crabtree at 70 percent is far better than anyone else the 49ers have at wide receiver. His presence is opening up more for Anquan Boldin, who has 15 catches and 191 yards in the two games since Crabtree has returned. Vernon Davis will also benefit from having Crabs around (when the 49ers remember he's on the field). He caught his 11th touchdown pass of the season, which is only two behind his career high of 13. His 51 career touchdown receptions puts him eigth all time in NFL history amongst tight ends.

Season defining drives

While the 49er offense was frustrating for much of the game, they put together two huge season defining drives when they needed to. Each of the drives came at the end of the half and each answered a Seahawks' score.

In the second quarter, Seattle had taken a 14-9 lead with 3:20 remaining in the half. While the 49ers were going to get the ball back to start the third quarter, it was imperative to get some momentum back. Kaepernick responded with his best drive of the game, going 5-of-6 with 69 yards and the touchdown throw to Davis. It was the quarterbacks finest moment of the day, as he was 10-of-23 for 106 yards and an interception separate of that drive. It was no coincidence that the 49ers best sequence of plays throwing the football were the ones in which they involved Vernon Davis. He had his only two catches of the game on the drive but was only targeted one other time in the game.

The second statement making drive may have saved their season all together. Highlighted by a 51 yard Frank Gore run, the 49ers went on a 10 play march that took 5:43 off the clock. San Francisco ran the ball on nine of the ten plays and took the conservative approach in the red zone, making sure they were able to get three points. While that type of play calling was frustrating for most of the day, it was the right call at the end of the game. The Seahawks got the ball back with about 20 seconds and no timeouts, which made it very difficult to answer back. It was a defining moment because if the 49ers did not answer the bell, the whole season may have been lost.

What's next?

The 49ers will travel to Tampa Bay to face off with a Buccaneers team that has won four out of it's last five games. As hot as they have been, the Bucs are no match for the 49ers and this should be a very winnable matchup. There is some risk of a let down after the big win, but if the 49ers have any real Super Bowl aspirations, they can't stumble in games like this.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Kevin
    You guys need to chill out with the Greg Roman bashing. There's a reason the guy was a head coaching candidate last offseason and will be again this offseason. Stretching back to 2011, he's proven time and time again to be able to make the right calls at the right times, and he's not the one out there running routes and catching passes. You need to think about who he's got to work with, Vernon Davis, who commands double teams constantly, Michael Crabtree, who can't possibly be playing at higher than 80%, and Anquan Boldin, who is going to struggle to get open unless you put it up and give him a chance to box out the defender and make a contested catch. You have to be conservative when playing Seattle, you don't want to challenge their corners consistently because it's a battle you'll must likely lose. Bottom line, the Niners identity is a power run game, they established that from the very beginning, stuck with it, and it ended up getting them the victory against a tough team. You really want to go back to an offensive coordinator carousel that we had to put up with for 8 straight years? I sure don't.
    Dec 10, 2013 at 8:35 AM
    Response: All good points. I think the main issue is the development (or lack there of) with Kaepernick. Then again, Kaep could have a lot to do with all of this. Maybe he'll make a big jump in year three like Newton did
  • Marty
    After watching the 49ers offense on Sunday, than watching Chicago's offense on Monday you have to wonder what is going on. Its like the rolles are reversed. Can you ever remember Chicago's offense being so explosive. At the same time, can you ever remember the 49ers offense ever being so bad. Why do the 49ers even draft offensive players, they have no idea how to use them, or how to run a offense.
    Dec 10, 2013 at 4:07 AM
    Response: I think you hit the nail on the head, Marty. There is talent's just not being used properly. Can you imagine Vernon Davis in the Saints offense or playing with a Brady or Manning?
  • Brian Augustine
    You seem to miss the point of your own analysis. The Seahawks committed 9 pass interference penalties (it should have been 10 I think). Ask yourself is this the only way the Seahawk secondary could stop the 9ers receivers, especially Crabtree who garnered 2 of those penalties and as I recall one resulted in a 1st down and it in retrospect was a big play. Factor that in when you assess Crabtree's contribution yesterday.
    Dec 9, 2013 at 1:13 PM
    Response: I believe I did when I alluded to how much he opens up for other players. He's not himself yet (nor should he be). We may not see a 100 percent Crabtree until next season.
  • James
    GoRo has to go,The Niners should have beaten the Hawks by at LEAST 10 points,It is just SAD that Romlan is our OC,I hope JED addresses this position during the OFF-SEASON.
    Dec 9, 2013 at 10:39 AM
  • Fresniner
    I find it hard to believe that Roman wouldn't know what to do with the weapons he has. I think there is something else going on. I don't know if it is Harbaugh making Roman be conservative or what. Do we have the personnel to open it up? I think we do. We may not have a vertical threat like Calvin Johnson, but I gotta believe that we can do some serious damage. I don't get the whole "opening up the playbook for the playoffs" thing. As long as you execute well, who cares what the opposing defense sees.
    Dec 9, 2013 at 9:49 AM
    Response: I remember reading once that the Dallas Cowboys of the early 90 had something like 4 running plays (or some really low number) and just ran them over and over again. Sometimes these coaches over think themselves.

More San Francisco 49ers News

Mina Kimes praises Christian McCaffrey deal, calls 49ers RB 'one of one'

By David Bonilla
Jun 7

Most San Francisco 49ers fans were thrilled to hear that the team had signed star running back Christian McCaffrey to a contract extension, ensuring his time in the Bay Area continues for years to come. ESPN journalist and on-air personality Mina Kimes recently praised the signing, feeling that it is well-deserved considering how accomplished McCaffrey has been with the 49ers. Last season, McCaffrey racked up 2,023 scrimmage yards and 21 total touchdowns, earning NFL Offensive Player of the Year, Pro Bowl, and All-Pro honors. Kimes noted that McCaffrey's arrival in the Bay Area made stopping the 49ers offense even more challenging. "I think with McCaffrey, the reason why we all agree he deserves this and why we talk about him like he's a unicorn is not just that

49ers' Kyle Shanahan calls Brock Purdy to Ricky Pearsall connection 'fun to watch'

By David Bonilla
Jun 5

Ricky Pearsall wore a blue non-contact jersey during Tuesday's practice, the first of the San Francisco 49ers' only mandatory minicamp during the offseason program. Head coach Kyle Shanahan explained that the rookie wide receiver had a "little soreness" left over from organized team activities (OTAs), and the jersey was a precautionary measure. "When it's like that, we still want him in there, but it allows guys to avoid him as much as possible," Shanahan said. Despite the minor soreness, the coaching staff has been pleased with Pearsall's early development. The 49ers selected him with the No. 31 overall pick in April's draft, seeking to boost an already talent-filled receiver room. The team's leading receiver from last season, Brandon Aiyuk,

ESPN's Louis Riddick calls 49ers WR Jacob Cowing "lightning in a bottle"

By Marc Adams
Jun 8

When the San Francisco 49ers selected Arizona wide receiver Jacob Cowing in the fourth round of the 2024 draft, many of the team's fans loved the pick, especially after former 49ers GM Scot McCloughan endorsed the selection. "Damn good football player," he said. "He's quick, fast. He's instinctive, he's competitive. He scored a lot of touchdowns, too, and can get down the field and go. He's cool. He's really, really cool." Cowing is a bit undersized (5'8, 168 lbs.), but he's tough. And he's a willing blocker, which the 49ers demand from their wide receivers. Two of the league's best blockers at the position, Jauan Jennings and Brandon Aiyuk, are already on the team. Although McCloughan believes Cowing is tough enough to block, it's his work as a receiver that the former GM

The Least Appreciated Impact Play in 49ers History

By Jon Opelt
Jun 6

Football historians cite Dwight Clark's soaring, back-of-the-endzone touchdown grab in the waning moments of the 1981 NFC Championship as the singular play that launched the 49ers dynasty and propelled San Francisco to its first Super Bowl appearance. Forty-Niner fans went berserk as Clark came down with the ball inbounds or as TV play-by-play announcer Vin Scully declared, "It's a mad house at Candlestick." Ray Wersching's extra-point kick thrust the Niners into a one-point lead. The Niners defense would need to take the field and hold the lead. Dallas had never lost to the 49ers in the playoffs, but there was a sense that this was about to change. The players were hugging and high-fiving. Meanwhile, the defensive coaches were hyping their troops,


More by Al Sacco

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone