Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports
49ers-Eagles: Kyle Shanahan explains why he didn’t challenge WR DeVonta Smith’s fourth-down catch
Jan 29, 2023 at 4:28 PM
•
It didn't wind up making a huge difference in the end, but the decision on the 49ers' end to not challenge what was incorrectly called a catch by Eagles wide receiver DeVonta Smith on the first drive of Sunday's NFC Championship game could have resulted in a healthy amount of second-guessing towards 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan, had the game wound up being much closer than it was.
But, as Shanahan explained after the game, the 49ers didn't see the angle of the play that would have overturned the original call, and the Eagles were able to get their next play off before anyone had a chance to review the play.
Smith made what originally looked like a dazzling one-handed 29-yard catch on a 4th-and-3 play of the game's opening possession, setting up the Eagles with a 1st-and-Goal. The Eagles scored a touchdown two plays later to go up 7-0, but televised replay of the catch showed the ball hit the ground and should have been ruled incomplete.
The Eagles went on to win 31-7, but the call was still a popular topic of discussion following the game. Shanahan told reporters he was thinking of challenging the call but decided not to based on what he saw at the time.
"The replay we saw didn't definitively show that," Shanahan said. "We saw one up on the scoreboard. I was going to throw one anyways just to hope to take the chance, but they showed one up on the scoreboard that didn't have all the angles you guys saw, and that looked like a catch. So we don't want to waste the time out, which we definitely would have if we didn't see that. But then I heard they got a couple of other angles and you guys end up seeing later that it was not a catch."
49ers defensive back
Jimmie Ward, who was in coverage on the play, didn't know the pass was incomplete until informed by reporters after the game. Ward responded by saying that his performance against the Eagles should get a good grade once the missed call on the catch is taken away, along with a pass interference call on him later in the game that he thought was unwarranted.
"Was it incomplete? It was?" Ward said. "So you're telling me they hit me with a PI that was a good play and they said he caught the ball? Oh man. I had a good game then."
Shanahan went on to say there are a number of eyes looking at a play when considering whether or not to issue a challenge, but the definitive angle that was shown after the fact wasn't available to anyone until it was too late. He was then asked if he felt that angle should have been shown earlier based on league protocol.
"I wish... I think the NFL can do that, if they see it. They're supposed to do it, but we didn't see it. So there's a play clock. You got 40 seconds. They're going to get it off. And they got it off. I was going to throw it anyways, just hoping, but it looked like he caught it.
"And then they show a replay up there, which I was shocked they showed it, but it ended up looking like a catch on the replay too because you couldn't see the other angle. So that's why we didn't. And then I was told at the end of the drive they saw a couple of other angles and I was told it was incomplete."
Things slowly fell apart for the 49ers after the touchdown, even though they were first able to tie the game at 7-7 after a touchdown run from
Christian McCaffrey. Injuries to quarterbacks
Brock Purdy and
Josh Johnson along with too many turnovers and penalties to overcome wound up being too much for the 49ers to overcome, which made the Smith call just one of several moments the 49ers wish they had back. But if the 49ers were able to hang in the game until the end, that moment in the first quarter would have certainly loomed much larger than it does right now.
Related News
LISTEN
Facebook Comments
More San Francisco 49ers News
49ers insider offers optimistic view of offseason: "They didn't lose any superstars"
Change is inevitable in the NFL. Free agency can often mean drastic change. For the San Francisco 49ers, it meant the departure of 12 unrestricted free agents who found new homes with teams willing to pay them more for their services.
"[W]hile I am happy for them and their families, I am also sad to be losing some of my closest friends for the last 5 years," tight end George Kittle posted on Instagram, discussing the initial flurry of roster activity at the start of the new league year.
While there were more exits than arrivals, San Francisco added one big-name free agent—defensive lineman Javon Hargrave. It's a move that bolsters the interior of a
Javon Hargrave: 49ers-Eagles would have been a different game with a healthy Brock Purdy
Everything changed in the NFC Championship Game when quarterback Brock Purdy exited early with an injury. He eventually returned because his backup, Josh Johnson, exited with a concussion. Purdy could not throw, though. He suffered a tear of the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) in his right elbow, leaving the San Francisco 49ers to become one-dimensional, abandoning the pass and depending solely on the run game.
For fans, it was a difficult game to watch. Everyone anticipated a more evenly matched battle between the two best teams in the NFC. Instead, they got an Eagles powerhouse defense going against a limping 49ers offense.
"We kind of knew it was going to be different when all you can do is run the ball," former Eagles defensive tackle Javon Hargrave said
Jason Kelce: 49ers adding Javon Hargrave "not going to make it any easier" for Eagles
Adding Javon Hargrave was a huge (and shocking) addition by the San Francisco 49ers. While it seems like a perfect fit and addresses a significant team need, no one saw it coming. The Niners didn't have considerable salary cap space, so signing Hargrave to a four-year, $84 million deal was unexpected.
The former Philadelphia Eagles defensive tackle, nicknamed "Grave Digger," joins a defensive line that includes NFL Defensive Player of the Year Nick Bosa and Arik Armstead, bolstering the middle of that unit.
One of the defender's former teammates is happy for Hargrave and his financial good fortune. However, he also knows the loss could be problematic for the defending NFC champions in the upcoming season.
"I'm happy for my man, Grave Digger," Eagles
Why the 49ers checked the boxes for DE Clelin Ferrell
The San Francisco 49ers have to be an ideal landing spot for any player. The team has been to the NFC Championship three times and made a Super Bowl appearance in the last four seasons. For one free-agent defensive lineman, the Niners checked a lot of boxes.
"I think for me, I really just fell in love with the way that they play defense here," Clelin Ferrell said on Thursday, speaking with 49ers reporters for the first time.
Defensive line coach Kris Kocurek was a big draw too. Knowing the coach's background and success in bringing out the best in his players contributed to the decision to sign with the 49ers.
Ferrell added, "So it was just kind of checking that box, for sure."
The 49ers weren't the only team expressing strong interest
