Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

Balancing Garoppolo and Lance may be a challenge for the 49ers

Sep 11, 2021 at 3:56 PM--

On March 26, 2021, the 49ers traded three first-round picks to the Miami Dolphins to move up to the third-overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft. Most knew trading to that spot meant the 49ers would be taking a quarterback.

Since that point, the talk and debate over 49ers' quarterbacks has been constant. That increased even further after the 49ers did the expected and took a quarterback with the third-overall pick, Trey Lance.

Fast forward to Week 1 of the regular season, and not much has changed. Jimmy Garoppolo will be returning as the starter, but there are indications that the 49ers may be implementing a two-quarterback system in some form, which is something you do not see very often in the NFL.

There is the potential for both Garoppolo and Lance to take snaps at any given point. Garoppolo is known as being more of a "traditional-style" quarterback, and Lance the "playmaker" who has a big arm and running-back type speed. The combination of both of them may sound exciting on the surface but brings along many intriguing questions.

Questions like: When exactly do you substitute Lance in? Will the play calling, and changes affect one or both quarterbacks? Will the 49ers be able to get plays and communication in on time? And finally, will this work?

These questions lead back to how Kyle Shanahan maneuvers what could either be a game-changing dynamic or a potential dilemma that hampers the 49ers throughout the 2022 season. The fact that Shanahan, one of the NFL's best offensive minds, will be navigating this situation is a noted plus.

The in-game adjustments and the added layer of Shanahan incorporating two quarterbacks during a game will be fascinating to watch. Many have made the Drew Brees/Taysom Hill comparison as to what a Jimmy Garoppolo/Trey Lance combination could look like. Week 3 of the preseason against the Las Vegas Raiders gave us an idea of what could be in store.

Jimmy Garoppolo started the preseason finale and Trey Lance was incorporated into those drives, with both quarterbacks rotating in-and-out at any given moment. Shanahan said after the game that this type of rotation may not be exactly how the process looks in the regular season, but no one really knows at this point.

If Shanahan can pull this off and is able to manage the strengths of both quarterbacks while putting them in the best position to succeed, the 49ers' offense could be dangerous. If not, the 49ers may end up losing more games than they should, with many likely to point out the unorthodox quarterback approach as the main culprit.

The quarterback situation and how it all plays out could be significant to the entire 2021 season. All eyes may be pointed in that direction starting from the 49ers' Week 1 match-up against the Detroit Lions, as Trey Lance is expected to be active for the game. How things go between Garoppolo and Lance tomorrow could provide an early indication of what is to come for the rest of the season.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
Nobody's perfect. Did you find a mistake in this article? Report it.


  • No Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Jimmy Garoppolo shares thoughts on 49ers future, may seek Aaron Rodgers' advice

By David Bonilla
Sep 21

Aaron Rodgers, for now, looks like he is holding off his eventual successor in Green Bay — Jordan Love. Rodgers' counterpart for the San Francisco 49ers, Jimmy Garoppolo, is trying to do the same. The Niners and Packers will clash on Sunday night as the former tries to remain undefeated in what is expected to be a tight NFC West race. Garoppolo joined The Rich Eisen show today and was asked about his NFL future and what he wants to come out of the 2021 season. Does he want to remain in San Francisco? It might take a superb season for that to happen, much like Rodgers did in 2020 or Garoppolo's mentor in New England, Tom Brady, did with him. "I don't know. To be completely honest, I haven't thought that far ahead yet," Garoppolo said. "It's one of

Mike McDaniel evaluates performances of 49ers QBs Jimmy Garoppolo, Trey Lance in Week 1

By David Bonilla
Sep 17

The San Francisco 49ers escaped Ford Field with a 41-33 victory over the Detroit Lions in Week 1. The offense put up 442 total yards in the effort. Quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo completed 17 of his 25 attempts for 314 passing yards and a touchdown in his 2021 regular-season debut. That's a 68.0 completion percentage. The No. 3 overall draft pick, Trey Lance, completed 100 percent of his pass attempts. Of course, he only made one attempt. That attempt went to wide receiver Trent Sherfield for a five-yard touchdown, though. Lance was in the game for four snaps. Garoppolo had 51 snaps. It wasn't the quarterback rotation that most anticipated going into the game. The rookie was expected to see the field more, something the Lions undoubtedly prepared for. That didn't

Why Kyle Shanahan feels the 2021 49ers O-line may be his best yet

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Sep 11

The offensive line for the San Francisco 49ers hasn't been a huge focus for the team since Kyle Shanahan arrived as the head coach in 2017. In fact, the team has only drafted two offensive lineman within the first four rounds of the draft over the past five years: RT Mike McGlinchey in 2018 and G Aaron Banks this year in the second round. However, the team has made significant strides in other moves to improve the offensive line, trading a third and a fifth round pick for star LT Trent Williams during last year's draft before signing him to an extension this offseason, and picking up Alex Mack as the starting center this offseason as well. With Shanahan's run/play-action oriented offense, a strong offensive line is necessary to work both the edges

Steve Young says 49ers' late game fade in Detroit may be "a sign of immaturity"

By Marc Adams
Sep 16

Former San Francisco 49ers quarterback, and current ESPN analyst, Steve Young spoke on KNBR Radio on Wednesday, as he does each week during the NFL season. Among the other things he discussed on the Tolbert, Krueger and Brooks Show, which included labeling the 49ers quarterback situation as "fraught with terror," considering how it plays out, was how the 49ers finished the game against the Detroit Lions last Sunday. Specifically, how they went from having such a huge lead to almost losing that lead. Much has been discussed on this topic already, and debates have been held around the question of whether coach


Trending News

Share 49ersWebzone