NEW 49ers NFL Draft Hats Available Now! →
Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Age may be the deciding factor in battle between Ahmad Brooks and Eli Harold

Aug 22, 2017 at 5:38 PM--

With 51.5 sacks, San Francisco 49ers linebacker Ahmad Brooks ranks third in team history behind just Bryant Young and Charles Haley when it comes to getting to the quarterback. Brooks had five or more sacks in each of his past eight seasons with the team. Yet, as he enters his 12th NFL season, Brooks finds himself in a competition for the team's starting Sam linebacker spot with Eli Harold, who is entering just his third NFL season.

Brooks will count $6.15 million against the team's salary cap in 2017. Harold, who is 10 years younger than Brooks, will count just over $823,000 against the cap. Despite his sack total, Brooks' overall production level has not matched his salary over the years. With the younger Harold itching to prove himself, some wonder if Brooks even has a place on the 49ers' 53-man roster.

On Sunday, 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan insisted that a player's salary will not be a factor when determining who wins a starting job. He was asked the question with Brooks and Harold given as examples.

"I don't even know what their salaries are," Shanahan said during a conference call. "I try not to even look at that because I want to make the right decision. I don't like anything to skew me on that type of stuff. So, I try to go off what I see at practice. You want to know who's got the most upside and things like that. Who's going to be better throughout the year if given the opportunity? But, you also want to know who, when it's all said and done, who's going to affect your win-loss record the most. Those are the things that I look at personally.

"You don't always want to think who's the best guy for Week 1. Who's the best guy for the 2017 49ers? I try to simplify my thoughts in that way. That's why I really don't find out about salaries until I've already made a decision."

With Shanahan and general manager John Lynch at the onset of their six-year contracts with the 49ers, there is no urgency to throw Brooks into the starting lineup because he has the most experience.

On Monday, Matt Barrows of the Sacramento Bee joined our "No Huddle" podcast and briefly explained why Brooks over Harold might not be as clear-cut as some believe.

"When you're in rebuilding mode like the 49ers are and you've got a six-year contract like John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan do, you're probably going to go with the younger guy a lot of times," Barrows said while discussing battles like the one between Brooks and Harold.

Brooks is used to competition. He entered the past three offseasons with his job seemingly at risk. The 49ers seemed eager to replace him and his bloated salary, but have never been able to put a younger and cheaper player in place to do so.

As a constant through the numerous coaching regimes that the 49ers have gone through in recent years, Brooks has started at least 13 games each season since becoming a starter in 2011. Harold started in Brooks' place during the 49ers' second preseason game and scored higher grades than Brooks in each of the team's two preseason games, per Pro Football Focus.

Brooks has managed to beat the odds in previous seasons but with Shanahan and Lynch seemingly eager to purge the holdovers from the previous regime, one has to wonder how much longer Brooks can prevail over those looking to take his place.

"We have to remember that only half of the roster was flipped from last year," said Zain Naqvi during the latest "No Huddle" podcast episode. "So, there's still another half of the roster that has to go in terms of them wanting to get some of these old-regime guys out and their own guys in.

"I really feel like it takes two seasons for a coach to really set up his own system. The reason why is because the first year, you're kind of clearing out house from the old coach and the old GM and things like that and you're trying to set the foundation for your own scheme. And in the second year, you've had a full offseason to get your guys in and your guys acclimated to the system."

This offseason, Brooks has survived longer than half of his teammates from last year. With the 49ers looking to rebuild and a completely revamped roster filled with younger players all around him, Brooks' time with the team may be nearing an end.


Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers met with Wisconsin S John Torchio, who may attend local pro day ahead of NFL Draft

By David Bonilla
Mar 23

According to Rohan Chakravarthi, the San Francisco 49ers spoke with Wisconsin safety John Torchio on Thursday at the school's pro day. The defensive back may attend the team's local pro day before the 2023 NFL Draft. Torchio (6-1, 208) registered 55 tackles, three tackles for a loss, a sack, six passes defensed, five interceptions, and two touchdowns through 13 game appearances as a senior in 2022, per Sports Reference. He recorded 97 tackles, seven tackles for a loss, 1.5 sacks, seven passes defensed, nine interceptions, and two touchdowns through his four collegiate

6 biggest 49ers draft mistakes of the Shanahan and Lynch era

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Mar 21

The San Francisco 49ers have been known as a team that has built throughout the draft in the Kyle Shanahan era, which has led to seasoned success throughout the head coach's tenure, with the organization reaching the NFC Championship Game three times over the past four seasons. However, among the several draft hits that have propelled their roster to one of the league's best, there have been several mistakes that set the organization back at the time. With the NFL Draft approaching next month, and the 49ers having another integral draft for their future success, let's revisit the five biggest draft mistakes of the Shanahan-Lynch era thus far. Honorable Mention: Trey Lance It feels absolutely unfair to place Trey Lance on this list at

Podcast: 49ers free agency 2023: Best and worst signings so far

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Mar 24

Rohan Chakravarthi and Jack Hammer discuss the 49ers free agent moves, grading the signings like Javon Hargrave thus far. The audio for the show is embedded above, while the video is available below. You can listen to "The Rohan Chakravarthi Show" from our

49ers considered trading Mike McGlinchey last year

By David Bonilla
Mar 25

Mike McGlinchey received a life-changing payday, signing a five-year, $87.5 million deal with the Denver Broncos. The offensive tackle has known for a while that he would not return to the San Francisco 49ers, the only NFL team he has played for and the one that made him the No. 9 overall pick in 2018. General manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan made it clear to McGlinchey that he was likely playing his final months for the team. There was too much money invested in other spots, and the 49ers knew they couldn't compete with other interested teams. Behind the scenes, Lynch and Shanahan kept McGlinchey in the loop of what the team was thinking, and everything pointed to the tackle playing elsewhere in 2023 … maybe even


Trending News

Share 49ersWebzone