How did the 49ers fare? They earned a C grade for their offseason so far, which includes free agency, the NFL Draft, and more.
So what did the 49ers do right according to Barnwell? They held on to QB Colin Kaepernick for one. "As toxic as the relationship between Kaepernick and the San Francisco front office appears to have become, there wasn't a real reason for the 49ers to trade their former starter at quarterback. They have plenty of cap space and didn't use most of it this year," says Barnwell. "If the whole thing goes south, they can cut Kaepernick next year and not feel guilty -- nobody's expecting the 49ers to win this year, anyway."
RELATED
Barnwell also applauded the fact that the 49ers built up their offensive and defensive lines during the draft, including DE DeForest Buckner and OG Joshua Garnett. He also liked the hiring of head coach Chip Kelly. "Kelly isn't a safe bet, and his run as a personnel executive was disastrous, but he managed to get a lot out of Eagles teams with some pretty bad quarterbacks, and nobody doubts his X's and O's acumen," said Barnwell.
Among the negatives for the 49ers offseason, Barnwell pointed out the team's failure to upgrade the rest of the team via free agency despite having a significant amount of salary cap room to do so. "This feels like a team that isn't actively trying to get better, which seems bizarre," he says.
You can read the entire division analysis, including the 49ers, here.
Grades for other NFC West teams are as follows.
Arizona Cardinals: B+
Los Angeles Rams: C
Seattle Seahawks: B
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
PFF: 49ers' Brock Purdy has matched Patrick Mahomes' grade since 2023
Pro Football Focus (PFF) recently evaluated every NFL team's quarterback situation entering the 2026 season, and the San Francisco 49ers were listed among the most stable—largely because of the strength of Brock Purdy's play. In the feature, PFF's John Kosko ranked each... -
49ers face pivotal offseason: Quick thoughts on all 28 free agents
Nearly two weeks have elapsed since the end of the San Francisco 49ers' season, after getting thrashed by the Seattle Seahawks in the divisional round. In recent days, Robert Saleh booked a flight to Nashville to confirm his position as the new coach of the Tennessee Titans.... -
Are these the 3 most likely 49ers cap casualties this offseason?
Bleacher Report analyst Alex Ballentine recently identified the three most likely salary-cap casualties for each NFL team this offseason, and one name on the San Francisco 49ers' list will come as little surprise: wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. General manager John Lynch has... -
NFL.com names 49ers tight end a 'no-brainer' offseason re-signing
The San Francisco 49ers are scheduled to have 28 players hit free agency this offseason, but NFL Media contributor Kevin Patra believes one offensive playmaker stands out as a clear priority to retain given the current circumstances. With All-Pro tight end George Kittle...