49ers Have More Than Injuries to Blame for First Loss

The San Francisco 49ers have spent much of this season finding ways to win despite an extraordinary number of injuries. Entering Sunday's game against the Atlanta Falcons, their top five wide receivers were unavailable, leaving Kyle Shanahan with a severely depleted offense.

Yet the 49ers still built a 14-3 lead and looked headed toward their seventh straight win.

Instead, Atlanta scored 23 unanswered points and handed San Francisco its first loss of the season, 29-20.

The injuries are impossible to ignore, but they don't explain everything. The 49ers had opportunities to win this game, just as they had opportunities to put Washington away much earlier the previous week.

In both games, penalties and other avoidable mistakes made winning considerably harder. Against Washington, they survived. Against Atlanta, they didn't.

Penalties Are Becoming a Problem

The 49ers have generally been a disciplined team under Shanahan, which makes their recent performances particularly concerning.

Against Washington, defensive penalties kept the Commanders in a game San Francisco could have controlled. The 49ers escaped with a win, but the same problems followed them to Atlanta.

On Sunday, San Francisco committed seven penalties for 55 yards. Four defensive penalties gave the Falcons automatic first downs, extending possessions that might otherwise have ended.

One of the most damaging came late in the first half.

With the 49ers leading 14-9, Atlanta faced fourth-and-four outside comfortable field goal range. Osa Odighizuwa jumped offsides as the Falcons attempted to draw San Francisco into a penalty.

Instead of getting the ball back, the 49ers watched Atlanta continue the drive and eventually kick a field goal, cutting the lead to 14-12 before halftime.

Later, penalties involving cornerback Jack Jones helped the Falcons extend drives when San Francisco desperately needed stops.

The defense also struggled to pressure Michael Penix Jr., allowing Atlanta to control the ball for long stretches.

Against Washington, the 49ers allowed four first downs through defensive penalties. They repeated that number against Atlanta.

Eight automatic first downs over two games gave opposing offenses eight extra opportunities. For a team already dealing with significant injuries, those are opportunities it cannot afford to keep giving away.

Turnovers Erased Scoring Opportunities

Despite its depleted receiving corps, San Francisco finished with 400 yards of offense, outgaining Atlanta by 105 yards.

The 49ers moved the football well enough to win. Their inability to protect it was another story.

After Christian McCaffrey temporarily left with a leg injury, rookie running backs Jordan James and Kaelon Black fumbled on consecutive plays. San Francisco recovered James' fumble but lost Black's in Atlanta territory.

That turnover helped change the direction of a game the 49ers had controlled early.

Brock Purdy later threw an interception near Atlanta's 25-yard line while rolling toward the sideline. Instead of throwing the ball safely out of bounds, he gave Jesse Bates III a chance to make a remarkable interception.

Purdy threw another interception late in the fourth quarter, and George Kittle fumbled with 57 seconds left.

Four turnovers, three of them inside Atlanta's 30-yard line, kept San Francisco from turning productive possessions into points.

The missing receivers undoubtedly limited the offense. But even with those limitations, the 49ers created scoring opportunities. They simply failed to capitalize on too many.

One Missed Extra Point Changed the Comeback

Eddy Piñeiro's kicking struggles continued Sunday, and this time the consequences became particularly clear.

When Purdy connected with Kyle Juszczyk for a touchdown late in the fourth quarter, the 49ers cut Atlanta's lead to 26-20.

Piñeiro missed the extra point, his fourth miss of the season.

At that moment, the difference between a five-point and six-point deficit might not have seemed significant. But Atlanta later added a field goal, extending its lead to 29-20.

Had Piñeiro converted the extra point, the score would have been 29-21. San Francisco could have tied the game with a touchdown and a two-point conversion.

Instead, the nine-point deficit required two scoring possessions.

The missed kick didn't directly decide the outcome, and the turnovers and defensive mistakes had already put the 49ers in a difficult position. But it changed what the offense needed to accomplish with time running out.

For a team that has played several close games this season, you can't dismiss that difference.

Getting Healthy Won't Fix Every Problem

At 6-1, the 49ers remain in a strong position, especially considering the injuries they've endured. Getting key players back after the bye week should make them a considerably better team.

But they were already good enough to beat Atlanta, and they were good enough to handle Washington without letting that game get unnecessarily close.

The difference between those two games was the outcome, but the mistakes were familiar.

The 49ers have demonstrated that they can overcome injuries and still compete at a high level. What they haven't demonstrated over the past two weeks is the ability to consistently avoid the penalties, turnovers, and special teams errors that keep giving opponents opportunities.

Returning players will help, but the 49ers need to eliminate those mistakes regardless of who's on the field.

Written By:

Carlos Torres

Carlos Torres is a longtime sports writer who formerly covered major professional and collegiate sports for Bleacher Report. For the past 15 years, he has co-hosted The Back 9 Report, covering golf through conversations with players and others across the sport. He is currently building and developing Spot On Racing and Sports News Deck, independent sports media platforms focused on delivering original coverage, analysis, and commentary. Carlos now brings his experience across sports writing, broadcasting, and digital media to 49ers Webzone.
All articles by Carlos Torres

@CarlosTorresSD

YouTube Channel