Pearsall battled a PCL injury during the 2025 season, but the expectation—or hope—was that the issue would heal naturally during the offseason. His recovery appeared to be trending in the right direction until the start of 49ers training camp, when the young receiver experienced renewed swelling in his knee.
The 49ers and their fans entered the offseason hoping Pearsall would take a major step forward in his third NFL season. Instead, there is now a legitimate possibility that the former first-round pick could require surgery and miss the entire 2026 season.
The 49ers have said they are exploring all available options for Pearsall, but NBC Sports Bay Area insider Matt Maiocco believes the situation has become increasingly concerning for the wide receiver.
"If surgery is required, he's going to miss the season," Maiocco said on Bay Area radio station KNBR. "He's going to miss the entire season."
Maiocco explained that the 49ers chose not to have Pearsall undergo surgery earlier in the offseason because the team believed the injury had a chance to heal without an operation. Additionally, a procedure performed earlier may not have significantly improved his chances of returning during the 2026 season.
"If they had decided to have the surgery, say in February or March or whenever, you're not giving it the full time to recover on its own, but also you're probably going to miss the season anyway," Maiocco said. "So I think that they made a calculated attempt to hope that thing would heal on its own, like it often does. And once it didn't, or it hasn't, now it's time for the 49ers and Ricky Pearsall to decide what they want to do."
The decision to delay surgery was a calculated risk. If Pearsall had undergone the procedure earlier in the offseason, it potentially could have improved his chances of being ready for the 2027 season. However, waiting to see if the injury improves naturally before potentially needing surgery later could now impact his availability beyond 2026.
At this point, Maiocco believes the 49ers should prepare for a season without contributions from Pearsall.
"So at this point, I think it's reasonable, rational, logical for the 49ers to not expect Ricky Pearsall to make any contribution in 2026," Maiocco added. "And so, it really kind of amplifies how important it was for the team to select De'Zhaun Stribling where they did, with the 33rd overall pick. A pick, at the time, I think a lot of people thought was kind of a luxury pick. But now, it's looking more and more like a necessity."
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Christian McCaffrey opens up about 49ers' new backfield plan in 2026
San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey had an NFL-high 413 touches last season. That's something the team clearly wanted to address this offseason to keep its veteran starter fresh through a lengthy 17-game season. The 49ers' solution was to draft Kaelon Black in... -
George Kittle reveals why 49ers are off to a hot start in 2026
The San Francisco 49ers are off to a hot start in the 2026 NFL season after a decisive 35-13 win over the Miami Dolphins on Sunday, improving to 2-0. The offense is firing on all cylinders, with quarterback Brock Purdy playing at an exceptional level. He has completed 80.4% of... -
49ers hope to bring back these 8 players from IR this season
The San Francisco 49ers have reportedly decided not to place defensive end Nick Bosa on injured reserve. However, the decision isn't necessarily related to the expected recovery timeline for the star pass rusher's calf injury, which he suffered ahead of Thursday's... -
49ers reuniting with former second-round pick Dante Pettis
The San Francisco 49ers are reportedly reuniting with former draft pick wide receiver Dante Pettis, according to NFL insider Jordan Schultz. He's one of nine players who worked out for the team on Tuesday, and the receiver is expected to join the practice squad. Reunion! The...