Purdy missed several games last season while battling a lingering turf toe injury. Despite the setback, he posted impressive numbers in nine starts, throwing for 2,167 yards, 20 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions while going 7-2. He also added 402 passing yards and two touchdowns in two playoff games, although he threw three interceptions during that span.
Walder clearly expects Purdy to return to form in 2026 and remain among the NFL's elite quarterbacks. The question is whether he can produce at a level that generates serious MVP consideration.
"You can't argue with Purdy's numbers when he has been on the field," Walder wrote. "His 69.7 QBR over the past four seasons ranks second behind only Josh Allen."
Despite Purdy's production, some critics continue to argue that he is merely a product of head coach Kyle Shanahan's offensive system rather than a driving force behind the 49ers' success.
"The Kyle Shanahan offense might be a hindrance to Purdy getting MVP votes," Walder continued, "but one could make the same argument against Stafford with Sean McVay or Caleb Williams (the other QB I considered here) with Ben Johnson. And it didn't seem to hold the Rams QB back in last season's vote."
Writer makes the case for a Mac Jones trade
Bleacher Report's Moe Moton recently identified one trade candidate for each NFL team. While wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk may seem like the obvious choice—especially with the 49ers eager to listen to offers—the more likely outcome appears to be a release before the season.
That leaves quarterback Mac Jones, who has been the subject of trade speculation throughout the offseason.
If Purdy delivers the MVP-caliber season Walder envisions as a possibility, dealing Jones makes sense. However, if Purdy struggles to stay healthy, Jones' value as a proven backup becomes even more critical for a team with Super Bowl aspirations.
"If a team offers the 49ers a second-round pick for their backup signal-caller who's in the final year of his contract, they should consider the deal," wrote Moton.
Moton noted that Jones is coming off his strongest performance since his rookie campaign, albeit in limited action. The quarterback appeared in 11 games and made eight starts, throwing for 2,151 yards, 13 touchdowns, and six interceptions. Those eight starts came while Purdy recovered from his turf toe injury.
Still, Moton acknowledged that the 49ers should be cautious about moving Jones, given Purdy's recent injury history.
"However, Jones' trade value isn't going to peak beyond what it is right now unless he sees the field for a significant number of snaps this year," Moton added.
"Moreover, Jones will be a free agent in 2027. The 49ers could offer him a lucrative deal to stay, but he may want to find a starting job elsewhere."
If Jones intends to pursue a starting opportunity in 2027 and the 49ers are confident Purdy can stay healthy and thrive in 2026, Moton believes the team should at least explore the possibility of a trade.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' John Lynch addresses Mac Jones buzz and trade market plans
Significant chatter has surrounded San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones, largely because of the injuries to starting quarterbacks around the NFL during the first two weeks of the season. Some have wondered whether other teams have called the 49ers about Jones, who played... -
49ers have strong reason to keep Mac Jones after watching NFL injury situation
The San Francisco 49ers aren't the only NFL team dealing with injuries this season. Four starting quarterbacks have already been sidelined through the first two weeks of the 2026 season. The latest is New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart, who is believed to have suffered an... -
49ers mailbag: Is the run defense a concern? Will SF make a trade soon? Can Jack Jones play safety?
The San Francisco 49ers are coming off a big week one win over the Los Angeles Rams, but there's no shortage of questions surrounding this team as they head into week two. We opened the 49ers Webzone Mailbag to get your best 49ers questions. So, let's jump into this week's... -
49ers' Brock Purdy makes NFL history with remarkable Week 2 performance
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy completed 20 of 22 passes (90.9 percent) for 287 yards and two touchdowns on Sunday in a 35-13 win over the Miami Dolphins, earning a nearly flawless 149.1 passer rating. He also added a rushing touchdown. More importantly, Purdy...